# The World Is Not Finished

*How optimism changes what you notice, what you attempt, and what becomes possible.*

By [zoz.eth](https://paragraph.com/@0xzoz) · 2026-10-02

---

  

I’ve felt something in my own life that I don’t have a tidy explanation for. Optimism seems to change my relationship with what happens next. Sometimes it feels as though life is meeting me halfway. Call it luck, call it “lucky girl syndrome”. I’m interested in the experience before we decide what to call it.

Reading the optimism chapter in David Deutsch’s _The Beginning of Infinity_ gave that feeling there was somewhere more substantial to go. Here was an argument about what reality permits, rather than instructions for maintaining a pleasant mood.

His principle of optimism is blunt: “All evils are caused by insufficient knowledge.” A fairly confrontational thing to put in a chapter about optimism.

He is not calling ignorance wicked, or suggesting that someone suffering could have avoided it by being more positive. His claim concerns the knowledge needed to overcome problems. That knowledge might be missing from an entire civilisation. We might fail to create it, or discover it too late. Optimism offers no exemption from consequences. What it challenges is the assumption that our present inability to solve something tells us what can ever be solved.

Peter Thiel approaches the opposing view that demonstates the evil claim from above from a considerably stranger direction.

In his discussions of the Antichrist, Thiel imagines power arriving through the promise of protection from catastrophe. In his interpretation, fear of destruction could make people accept an authority capable of stopping scientific and technological development. The offer is peace and safety; the danger, as he describes it, is permanent control and stagnation. He also acknowledges the danger on the other side: development that produces catastrophe. A blocker to epistemology. Encouraging Duetch's claim but from an opposite angle

Deutsch is not making Thiel’s theological argument but it helps frame it, and putting them beside each other does not settle which technologies should proceed or what safeguards they need. But the comparison brings a question into focus: if overcoming suffering requires knowledge we have yet to create, what happens when the process of discovery is closed down?

The personal version of that question is less apocalyptic, but worth asking. How much of what we call being realistic is an accurate assessment of our circumstances, and how much is a decision that nothing sufficiently different can happen? when you start thinking from this lens, most of day to day occurrences that are outside of ones routine start to seem.. rather pessimistic.

That is where optimism begins to interest me.

**Your problem is not necessarily a law of nature**

Imagine a community living beside a river it cannot safely cross.

They could spend generations describing the problem accurately. The current is strong. The water is deep. People have tried and died. There would be plenty of evidence that crossing is dangerous, and no shortage of people with good reasons to say so.

None of that establishes that the river must remain uncrossable.

A bridge would change the situation without changing the laws of nature. Gravity would carry on doing exactly what it had been doing. The difference would be an arrangement of materials made possible by knowledge, resources and work.

The danger was real. So was the possibility of doing something about it.

Deutsch develops a related distinction in _constructor theory_, a proposed approach to physics concerned with which transformations are possible, which are impossible, and why. What could be made to happen belongs in the explanation of the world, alongside what happens to be occurring now. This is a physical framework, not evidence that wishing influences unrelated events.

For ordinary life, the distinction is useful enough without the physics terminology.

“I cannot do this” and “I do not currently know how to do this” describe different situations. The first can sound like a settled property of the person speaking. The second identifies something that might change.

Of course, adding _yet_ to a sentence does not make it true. Some goals are impossible under the conditions available. Some cost more than they are worth. Other people retain the right to decline whatever role you have assigned them in your future.

But before accepting a limit, it helps to know what the limit actually is.

Take something you have quietly filed under _not for me_. What is the evidence? A missing skill? Two unsuccessful attempts? A lack of resources? Something another person told you years ago?

“I tried twice, using the same approach, and it didn’t work” is useful information. “Nothing ever works out for me” is a much larger claim wearing the same evidence.

You may still decide to stop. At least you will be deciding about the actual problem, rather than a verdict you have gradually attached to yourself.

**You cannot picture all of it yet**

The part of Deutsch’s argument I keep coming back to is his observation that “some of the opportunities and some of the discoveries will be inconceivable in advance”. Progress therefore requires someone willing to remain open to those possibilities and prepare for their arrival.

That is a different demand from visualising a particular future until you feel certain it will happen.

It asks you to make room for a future you cannot yet visualise.

There is an awkward assumption inside the instruction to decide exactly what you want: that the version of you making the decision already understands the worthwhile possibilities. Sometimes that is reasonable. You know the skill you want to learn or the practical problem you need to solve.

But sometimes learning changes the goal itself.

You encounter something that gives you a different understanding of what would make life good. A conversation changes the question you were asking. You become capable of something that had never occurred to you as a serious prospect.

In those circumstances, insisting that life follow the original picture would be an odd form of optimism. You would be asking everything you have yet to learn to obey the preferences you had before learning it.

A plan can give you direction without being granted that much authority.

The practical question is how to prepare for something you cannot predict. You cannot make a detailed plan for a discovery you have not made. You can, however, develop the ability to notice, understand and respond when something unfamiliar becomes relevant.

That might mean learning a skill before its full use is obvious. It might mean having a conversation without needing it to lead somewhere. It might mean leaving enough attention available to follow a question that does not fit your current plan.

Or to the retardmaxxing friends of ours: fuck around and find out

None of this requires treating every distraction as a sign. Curiosity can waste your afternoon. Sometimes an interesting person is just an interesting person.

The point is to allow a little investigation before demanding a complete justification. Some opportunities cannot provide references because the conditions that make them opportunities are still forming.

I think this is a more generous relationship with the future. You can care about where you are going while accepting that you are not yet qualified to describe everything worth finding.

**One thing makes other things possible**

Stuart Kauffman’s idea of the _adjacent possible_ gives this a useful shape. A development can make further developments accessible. The available possibilities change as new things appear.

In _The Dynamics of Correlated Novelties_, researchers modelled a process in which encountering something new enlarges the space that can subsequently be explored. They tested its predictions against patterns in activities including music listening, language and Wikipedia editing. The research concerns how novelty unfolds; it is not a demonstration that optimism attracts luck.

Consider a simple example.

You become interested in an unfamiliar subject and learn enough to have a proper conversation about it. That conversation introduces you to someone working on a problem. Helping with the problem teaches you something else. A possibility then becomes apparent that neither of you had considered at the beginning.

It would be easy, afterwards, to describe the sequence as a lucky encounter. Perhaps it was. But the later opportunity was also made possible by what developed along the way.

You were not simply choosing from a fixed selection of outcomes. Your participation helped change what was available.

This matters because we often ask a first step to explain an entire future. Where will this lead? What will I get out of it? How do I know it is worth doing?

Those are sensible questions when the cost is substantial. They become less useful when they demand information that only participation could produce.

A conversation does not need to justify a five-year plan. An afternoon spent learning something does not need to become a new identity. You can take a small step, see what it reveals, and decide again.

That is one plausible way to understand the feeling that life begins opening up. The possibilities may genuinely be changing as you proceed. From inside the experience, that can feel remarkably different from repeatedly choosing between the same familiar options.

It does not mean every sequence leads somewhere good. It means the first view is not always the most informative one.

**Give the future something to work with**

There is something strange about a bridge before it exists.

At first, it might be an idea, then a drawing or a calculation. None of those can carry a person across a river. Yet they can influence the actions through which something that _can_ carry a person is built.

A representation of an unrealised future has acquired a role in the present.

No backwards causation is required. The bridge has not sent instructions through time. Someone has imagined a possibility and begun arranging the conditions through which it might become actual.

That is why I find “your thoughts only change your behaviour” an incomplete dismissal of the idea that thought shapes reality. Behaviour is part of reality. Conversations, experiments and acts of care have consequences. Explaining a connection does not make the connection trivial.

William James explored this in _The Will to Believe_. He argued that, in some relationships and cooperative situations, a willingness to act before the outcome is established can help bring that outcome into existence. He distinguished these cases from questions whose answers do not depend on our belief.

Imagine several neighbours who would enjoy a community garden. Everyone is waiting for evidence that the others would contribute. Nobody asks, so the evidence never arrives.

Then someone makes a suggestion. Another offers tools. Someone knows where there might be a suitable plot. An uncertain possibility now has people working on it.

The first person did not need certainty. They needed enough interest to find out.

This is where a desired future becomes useful: it changes something you do in the present.

A wish for friendship becomes an invitation. An idea becomes a rough version another person can respond to. A problem you have been carrying around becomes a specific question put to someone who might understand part of it.

Keep the action proportionate to what you know. An invitation is an experiment. Repeatedly ignoring a refusal is not optimism.

And pay attention to what comes back. The response may improve your idea, expose a weakness or reveal that you are asking the wrong person. All of that is more useful than trying to manufacture confidence while nothing changes.

You are giving the possibility a way to encounter reality. Reality gets a say.

**Your past has a sampling problem**

There is a reason to be careful about letting experience have the final word.

Jerker Denrell and James March’s research on the _hot-stove effect_ describes how learning can become biased against unfamiliar or risky alternatives. Something produces an early disappointment, so it is avoided. Avoidance then restricts the information that might show the initial judgment was too negative.

Their account also recognises the cost of trying again: sometimes you merely persist with something that really is poor.

The useful question is how your experience was collected.

Suppose you attend a group for the first time and have an awkward evening. That may tell you the group is a poor fit. It may tell you that first visits are awkward. Going back once could help distinguish between the two.

If you never return, your initial interpretation can survive indefinitely without facing another test. Years later, it may feel less like a conclusion you reached and more like something you simply know.

It is possible to become very certain about an experience you have carefully avoided repeating.

That does not mean you owe every disappointment another chance. Some situations provide more than enough evidence, and some are unsafe. The useful place to experiment is where the belief is broad, the evidence is limited, and the cost of checking is manageable.

Before trying, write down what you expect. Afterwards, record what happened, including the bits that do not suit your preferred explanation.

This is equally necessary for an optimistic story. Counting the pleasant coincidences while forgetting everything else can make almost any belief look impressive.

I would rather have an optimism that can survive accurate accounting.

Sometimes the result will be that a particular approach deserves to be abandoned. That is allowed. You can want meaningful friendships and leave a group that consistently makes you miserable. You can remain interested in a problem while admitting that your proposed solution does not work.

There is no obligation to defend your first idea for the rest of your life.

Especially if the point was to discover something you did not already know.

**Include the part you would rather skip**

An attractive future can also become a comfortable place to hide.

In four experiments, Heather Kappes and Gabriele Oettingen found that induced, idealised positive fantasies could reduce energisation, measured through physiological and behavioural indicators. Imagining a desirable outcome did not necessarily produce the effort needed to pursue it.

That is a useful complication for anyone hoping to think their way into a better life.

Imagination helps identify what you care about. But mentally enjoying the result can become a substitute for dealing with whatever stands between you and it.

Oettingen’s work on _mental contrasting_ brings the desired future into contact with the obstacles in present reality. Combined with specific plans for responding to those obstacles, the approach has shown modest average benefits for goal attainment across studies. The results vary, and publication bias may make the average effect look larger than it is.

The practical version is straightforward.

Take something you genuinely want to improve. Describe what would be different. Then identify the obstacle most relevant to your next step.

Perhaps you want stronger friendships but habitually wait for other people to initiate. The useful action is fairly clear. Make a specific invitation. You do not control whether it is accepted, but you can stop leaving your contribution entirely to chance.

Perhaps the obstacle is external. The resources are unavailable. Another person does not want what you want. The timing makes the original plan unworkable.

Recognising that is part of understanding the situation. You may need help, a different approach or a different goal.

This is also where the whole thing can become unpleasant if handled carelessly. Once every outcome is attributed to the quality of someone’s thoughts, suffering becomes evidence that they thought incorrectly. They get the original problem and then an invoice for insufficient belief.

Nothing in the argument here warrants that.

There are circumstances a person cannot change with the knowledge, time and support available to them. Some damage cannot be undone. Another person’s apparent good fortune tells you very little about what would have been possible in your situation.

Optimism also does not require constant cheerfulness. An anxious thought is not an order accidentally placed with the universe.

You can be frightened and investigate. You can be disappointed and change direction. You can need rest before being ready for either.

What matters is whether the difficulty has taught you something specific, or persuaded you to close the whole subject.

**Leave room for something you could not have asked for**

The attraction of “lucky girl syndrome”, at least to me, is the possibility of having a less hostile relationship with uncertainty. There is something appealing about entering the future without assuming that every unknown is waiting to take something from you.

I want to preserve that without claiming the universe has a personal interest in my plans.

The mechanisms discussed here offer a way to do so. Expectations can influence participation. Participation can produce knowledge and relationships. Those can change what becomes possible next. That is a synthesis of the argument, not proof that any particular coincidence was caused by optimism.

There is still room for chance, and for misremembering it.

But I do not think an intelligible explanation has to drain the experience of its significance. The bridge remains strange. A world contains beings who can imagine something absent, understand enough to build it, and thereby change what happens in that place.

We are among the parts of reality capable of learning about it and doing something with what we learn.

That is where I think optimism belongs as a value. I cannot establish it as a law favouring good outcomes. I can see a reason to value the processes through which conditions become understandable and, sometimes, improvable.

The universe does not have to be personally benevolent for something benevolent to happen within it. An act of care can make a difference without first obtaining a guarantee about the character of existence.

Nor does improvement have to look like the future we originally wanted.

This is the consequence of Deutsch’s point that I find most useful. Some discoveries will be beyond what we can presently imagine. Preparing for them means accepting that a worthwhile future may require us to revise our idea of what worthwhile looks like.

A plan can remain useful while being incomplete. A failed attempt can remain a failure without becoming a description of everything still possible. You can have a direction without pretending to know what every worthwhile turn will look like.

That feels closer to the optimism I wanted to understand in the first place. Enough confidence to participate, and enough curiosity to avoid mistaking the current picture for the whole thing.

The life I can imagine from here is limited by what I know from here. I would like to leave some room for what I haven’t learned yet.

---

*Originally published on [zoz.eth](https://paragraph.com/@0xzoz/the-world-is-not-finished)*
