# An unsold condo tax misdiagnoses the real estate market

By [Brandon Donnelly](https://paragraph.com/@brandondonnelly), 2026-09-27

development, real estate, vancouver, condo market, david eby, enhanced hst rebate, toronto, unsold condos, vancouver

---

When developers build new, for-sale housing, they are incentivized to sell that housing. That’s the business. If developers are sitting on unsold inventory — there’s an [estimated](https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/british-columbia/article-eby-proposes-tax-on-unsold-condos-to-encourage-developers-to-sell/) 4,000 newly-completed unsold condominiums in the Vancouver region — it’s typically indicative of market conditions; meaning developers are _sitting_ on inventory because they have no other choice, not _holding_ inventory because they’re trying to price gouge.

Last week, BC Premier David Eby [announced](https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/british-columbia/article-eby-proposes-tax-on-unsold-condos-to-encourage-developers-to-sell/) that, if re-elected, his government would impose a new 2% tax on recently completed condominiums if they sit empty for more than 1 year. This would be levied against the assessed value of the property and increase by 1% for each additional year. So, by year three, the tax would be 3%.

This would be a punitive tax that seems to suggest developers are not already incentivized to sell their housing inventory. Eby positioned the tax as a way to encourage developers to further lower their prices and sell homes at price points that people are willing to pay. While it would certainly be a “stick” for developers, why punish home builders? That’s less than optimal for long-term housing supply.

A valuable indicator of current market conditions can be found in [Ontario’s new enhanced HST rebate](https://brandondonnelly.com/ontarios-new-new-home-hst-rebate-seems-to-be-working/). It represents a meaningful cost reduction on the price of new housing and all signs point to this rebate being passed through to purchasers at or close to 100% of the value. It’s a sign that developers are not looking to price gouge. They’re trying to balance competing objectives and ultimately move their inventory.

---

*Originally published on [Brandon Donnelly](https://paragraph.com/@brandondonnelly/an-unsold-condo-tax-misdiagnoses-the-real-estate-market)*
