# Why light rail isn't a waste of money

By [Brandon Donnelly](https://paragraph.com/@brandondonnelly), 2014-08-09

architect-this-city, atc, brt, bus-rapid-transit, buses, light-rail, lrt, mobility, planning, streetcars, subways, sustainability, the-economist, trams, transit, uncategorized, urbanism

---

Last weekend a friend of mine sent me an article from The Economist talking about [why trams, streetcars, and light rail are a waste of money](http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2014/08/economist-explains-2). The argument is basically that steetcars are expensive, less efficient, and that – despite North America’s renewed interest in them – we should instead be spending our scarce public dollars on more buses.

Here’s a snippet from [the article](http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2014/08/economist-explains-2):

> _…but cash spent on streetcars displaces spending on other, more cost-effective forms of public transport like buses, which offer cheaper and more-efficient service but are considerably less sexy. The capital cost per mile of a streetcar is between $30m and $75m, while a rapid bus service costs anywhere between $3m and $30m, according to the American Public Transportation Association._

Now, there’s no question that buse routes are initially cheaper to implement. You don’t have track to build. But I don’t agree that the cost structure is quite that simple if you consider the number of people you need to move in your city. I struggle to see buses as a more efficient service.

The big difference between modern light rail and buses is capacity. [Toronto’s new streetcars](http://brandondonnelly.com/post/90027114933/do-you-love-or-hate-streetcars) will move about [3 times as many people as your typical bus](http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/transportation/2013/10/28/subway_lrt_or_bus_the_pros_and_cons.html). So you’d need to triple the number of buses and triple the number of drivers – adding to your labor costs – if you want to have a chance at moving the same number of people. 

Streetcars are also electric, which means they run on a renewable energy source. We’re in the process of [making this switch with private transport](http://brandondonnelly.com/post/93638265423/the-landscape-of-electric-charging-stations), so why go backwards when it comes to public transport? You can certainly run electric buses as well, but then you’re building overhead power lines and bringing up your initial costs.

I think the challenge is that when people think of light rail, they think of slow lumbering streetcars. I agree that many of these lines are inefficient and [I’ve written about it](http://brandondonnelly.com/post/82489273569/all-streetcars-are-not-created-equal). But there are a number of ways to implement light rail. And when done well it can efficiently move a lot of people for costs that are far less than a subway.

_Image:_ [_Aecom_](http://aecom.com/vgn-ext-templating/v/index.jsp?vgnextoid=7998dc8bc7c94210VgnVCM100000089e1bacRCRD&vgnextchannel=55a2ef8180554210VgnVCM100000089e1bacRCRD&vgnextfmt=default)

---

*Originally published on [Brandon Donnelly](https://paragraph.com/@brandondonnelly/why-light-rail-isnt-a-waste-of-money)*
