There are moments in American public life when a man surveys the wreckage around him, studies the role he played in producing it, and arrives at the only conclusion available to a sufficiently confident person: What this country needs is more people like me.
Former Senator Joe Manchin of West Virginia has reached that moment.
Manchin, who left the Democratic Party in 2024 to become an independent, has joined with his daughter Heather and assorted political operatives to form something called the Independent Leadership Council. Its mission is to recruit and support independent candidates for Congress and, eventually perhaps, create the beginnings of an independent political movement capable of loosening the two major parties’ grip on American government.
It is a bold idea.
It is an audacious idea.
It is also rather like the fellow who spent several years standing in the doorway announcing that nobody was getting through until someone listened to him, then retired and opened a school for doorway management.
Manchin explains his theory with admirable simplicity: “I’m living proof that one vote makes a difference,” he told The New York Times.
Sir, no one disputes this.
We all watched.
For the first two years of Joe Biden's presidency, Democrats governed with the narrowest possible Senate majority: 50 Democratic-aligned senators, plus Vice President Kamala Harris to break ties. That made every Democratic senator important.
It made Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema something else entirely.
They became Washington's most celebrated political endangered species: the Legislator Who Must Be Consulted.
The White House could negotiate with congressional leaders. Congressional leaders could negotiate with committee chairs. Committees could negotiate with one another.
And eventually everyone could negotiate with Joe.
Manchin opposed the original Build Back Better legislation and announced in December 2021 that he could not support it, depriving Democrats of the vote required to pass Biden's signature social-spending package.
To be fair—and fairness is especially important when preparing someone for roasting—Manchin later helped negotiate the considerably smaller Inflation Reduction Act, which became law. He was not simply an obstructionist wandering Capitol Hill carrying a large wooden “NO” sign.
He believed in legislation.
He merely preferred legislation that had first passed through Joe Manchin.
Then came voting rights.
Republicans blocked Democratic voting-rights legislation with the filibuster. Democrats proposed changing Senate rules enough to let the bill proceed.
Manchin and Sinema joined all 50 Republicans in refusing.
The proposed rules change failed, 52 to 48. The voting-rights legislation died with it.
Again, Manchin had a principle. He believed the filibuster protected the Senate and encouraged bipartisan compromise.
He was entitled to believe that.
A senator is not elected to be a button pushed whenever party leadership wants the machine to go ding.
But there is a difference between independent judgment and constructing an entire political identity around the proposition that government works best when everybody must come see you first.
And now we arrive at the Independent Leadership Council.
Apparently, the lesson Manchin drew from his years at the center of a narrowly divided Senate was not that such concentrated leverage might be a structural problem.
It was that we need more of it.
The Council wants independent candidates who will not caucus with either major party. That is not some incidental preference. Manchin calls it “the biggest thing.”
Which raises a tiny organizational question.
Congress is run through caucuses.
Committees are organized through parties.
Leadership positions are organized through parties.
Legislative schedules are organized through parties.
Committee assignments, hearings, negotiations ,and much of the machinery determining which proposals ever reach the House or Senate floor are intertwined with the party structure.
Manchin knows this.
Indeed, he acknowledges that independent senators refusing to caucus could be shunned, chastised, and potentially excluded from committees.
Excellent.
We appear to have the plan.
Step One: Elect members of Congress who refuse to participate in the organizations through which Congress organizes itself.
Step Two: Have those organizations deprive them of influence over much of the work Congress performs.
Step Three: Save democracy.
One begins to understand why Washington employs so many consultants.
The Manchins believe there may be three to five congressional races in which independents could break through this year. Heather Manchin says unaffiliated or independent voters now outnumber Republicans or Democrats in 16 states and 106 congressional districts.
That deserves serious attention.
Millions of Americans really are dissatisfied with both parties. Many voters genuinely feel unrepresented by either. Gerrymandering, closed primaries, and increasingly ideological partisan ecosystems can reinforce the feeling that voters are being asked to select between two political organizations, neither of which quite fits them.
There is a real democratic problem buried in here.
There is nothing inherently unserious about trying to reshape American politics from outside its existing arrangements. Political movements have done it before. The Democratic Leadership Council, whatever one thinks of the policies it championed, spent years developing an identifiable governing philosophy before Bill Clinton carried much of that philosophy into the White House. It had an answer to the question every political movement eventually has to answer: What are you for?
And that is the question missing here. Independent of what is easy enough to understand. Independent in favor of what?
Which makes it unfortunate that Joe Manchin has arrived carrying a mirror.
Because the answer to political alienation cannot simply be to create another class of politicians whose influence derives primarily from withholding allegiance until everyone else satisfies them.
Compromise is not the same thing as leverage.
Independence is not the same thing as indispensability.
And statesmanship is not measured by how many people must wait outside your office.
The distinction matters because Manchin's argument contains something seductive. A handful of independent senators in a closely divided chamber really could force the parties to negotiate with them.
Of course they could.
So could a man who owns the only bridge out of town.
The interesting question is what he charges for crossing it.
And the ambitions apparently do not stop with Congress.
Asked whether their movement might eventually produce an independent presidential candidate in 2028, Joe Manchin responded, “Oh my gosh, wouldn’t that be wonderful.” Heather Manchin agreed that congressional victories might begin building precisely such a pipeline.
Perhaps.
America has survived Whigs, Federalists, Democratic-Republicans, Know-Nothings, Progressives and several political parties whose names now survive mainly as questions on high-school history exams. There is nothing sacred about the present two-party arrangement.
Maybe it should be disrupted.
Maybe independent candidates could improve Congress.
Maybe some future coalition outside the present parties will eventually become necessary.
But before launching the political movement intended to cure Washington's dysfunction, it might be useful to distinguish between the virtues of independent thinking and the pleasures of being the fellow everybody has to ask.
Joe Manchin says one vote can make a difference.
He is absolutely right.
For several years, the country received an unusually comprehensive demonstration.
And now, apparently, he would like to franchise the business.
— Dunneagin
📬 To receive each new essay by email the day it publishes, subscribe to Civics Unhinged.
☕ Reader editions and collected volumes—including Volumes 1, 2, 3, and The Liar’s Guide to Autocracy—are available on the Fourthwall bookshelf.
If this week’s dispatch aligned with your reading, forward it to an un-unhinged colleague who still keeps an eye on the clockwork.
Reader and listener correspondence is always welcome at dunneagin@dunneagin.net. Questions, observations, or a note on how you first stumbled into the chronicle are particularly appreciated.
A note on the shelf: Every Tuesday dispatch compiles toward a permanent, physical record. We print what the screen forgets.