Originally Published: January 3, 2024
Restored Edition No. 7: September 16, 2026
Editor's Note (Restored Edition No. 7): This essay was originally published on January 3, 2024, and has been reviewed for inclusion in the Permanent Collection of Civics Unhinged. The text preserves the original argument and historical context while incorporating minor editorial corrections, updated classification, and connections to related works.
A Modest Proposal for the Immodest: Trump’s Ever-Elusive Quest for a Ballot Spot
As the political circus pitches its tent once again, the time comes to reflect upon the grand spectacles of yesteryear — to reminisce about a simpler time when the most complex conundrum for a politician was deciding which baby to kiss or which state fair corndog would look least unflattering on camera. Those idyllic days now seem as distant as the notion of a humble Trump, a figure whose latest legal escapades make a charging bull in a china shop seem subtly nuanced in comparison.
Let's take a leisurely saunter down the memory lane of recent legal filings. Here we find the beacon of relentless ambition, former President Donald J. Trump, with his heart set on a return to the presidential primary ballots. He is not just content with having the political spotlight, he wants the entire sun. It must vex him to no end that two states, Colorado and Maine, have had the audacity to invoke the insurrection clause of the 14th Amendment, cutting off his ballot access as if to say, "You shall not pass!"
Let's ponder the irony. Mr. Trump, whose rise to political infamy was in part thanks to reality TV — where eliminations are arbitrary and typically reserved for flavorless contestants or those who fail at beachside obstacle courses — now finds the very real possibility of being eliminated from state ballots not by text votes, but by the rule of law. Oh farce, thy name is jurisprudence!
One can't help but picture the draft of the petition; the language is as florid as the galleries of Versailles, wherein Trump's attorneys argue with fervent zeal that their client's previously televised performances do not a rebellion make. I'm positively verklempt at the notion that the 6th of January was perhaps no more than an unaired pilot for "The Apprentice: Capitol Edition."
And, oh! How the authors of the petition must have typed with the gallant force of a Revolutionary War drummer boy, drumming up a defense as tireless as it is tire-some, opining that the conduct of Mr. Trump was as innocent as a toddler's tantrum — admittedly a tad more destructive and significantly less adorable.
The petition practically writes itself, does it not? A declaration that the grand poobah of politics is the victim of not one, but two (and who knows, perhaps more will join the trend) state supreme courts, enmeshing him in a web of judicial jiggery-pokery that seeks to deny him the opportunity to grace the oval office once again with the odor of fast-food burgers and the scent of greasy fries.
Behold the spectacle as he calls upon the highest court in the land to disentangle him from his legal labyrinth, asking for a miracle elixir from the Supreme Court to cure his chagrin, akin to a snake oil salesman peddling wares to the gullible. It's the stuff of Dickensian caricature. If only Dickens had the foresight to imagine a reality television star turned into the most powerful man in the free world.
We must give pause and ponder whether Joseph Welch, had he been a contemporary to our saga, would have peered over his spectacles, a gleam in his eye, to deliver another scathing rebuke fit for an era all too familiar with the theatrics of indignation. Would he have mustered the composure to ask Trump, "Have you no sense of decency, sir, at long last?" Or would he be drowned out by the cacophony of tweets, retweets, and unceasing news alerts?
In crafting this literary lampoon, one must handle the subject with the delicate precision of a surgeon—or, in this case, perhaps the heavy-duty gloves of a nuclear waste handler. We navigate the treacherous waters between the Scylla of contemptuous ridicule and the Charybdis of giving too much credence to the farcical charade unfurling before us.
It takes a Herculean effort to maintain professional decorum amidst the tragicomedy, but contemplate we must, the ceaseless endeavors of an ex-president auditioning for a part he's already played—clinging to the script with an orange-tanned grip, even as the audience files out muttering about rehashed lines and predictable plot twists.
But, alas, our tale is yet unfinished. The quill quivers over the parchment as the Supremes contemplate whether to pen the final act or prolong the enchanted dance of filings and rebuttals. Stay tuned, fellow spectators, for the spotlight loves to linger on the boldest player in the grand playhouse of political absurdity. And Mr. Trump, ever the showman, knows not how to exit stage left.
Best regards,
Dunneagin
📬 To receive each new essay by email the day it publishes, subscribe to Civics Unhinged.
☕ Reader editions and collected volumes—including Volumes 1, 2, 3, and The Liar’s Guide to Autocracy—are available on the Fourthwall bookshelf.
If this week’s dispatch aligned with your reading, forward it to an un-unhinged colleague who still keeps an eye on the clockwork.
Reader and listener correspondence is always welcome at dunneagin@dunneagin.net. Questions, observations, or a note on how you first stumbled into the chronicle are particularly appreciated.
A note on the shelf: Every Tuesday dispatch compiles toward a permanent, physical record. We print what the screen forgets.