Originally Published: February 11, 2025
Restored Edition No. 5: September 16, 2026
Editor’s Note (Restored Edition No. 5): This essay was originally published on February 11, 2025, and has been reviewed for inclusion in the Permanent Collection of Civics Unhinged. The text preserves the original argument and historical context while incorporating minor editorial corrections, updated classification, and connections to related works.
On a tranquil Presidents’ Day morning, George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln, and Theodore Roosevelt convened an emergency meeting under the towering monument they called home, high above the South Dakota plains. There, on the rock face they’ve adorned for decades, they had received some news that required their immediate attention: a bill introduced by Representative Anna Paulina Luna (R-FL) that proposed adding Donald Trump’s likeness to Mount Rushmore.
These four historical icons, frozen in stone for over seventy years, had heard some wild ideas in their time. But this? This idea took the cake. A bill to carve another face into the mountain — Trump’s face, no less? You would think it was a joke. But as Rep. Luna’s announcement made clear, it wasn’t. And so, the four monumental figures decided it was time for a little chat, where they might — just for once — take the floor and respond to the towering absurdity of it all.
George Washington: The Reluctant Father of the Nation
“Now, I’m no expert in humor,” Washington began, eyeing the bill with the kind of sternness that had once made him the most famous “serious man” in American history. “But it appears we’ve entered the realm of bad jokes...and not the funny kind.”
He puffed out his chest (as much as stone allows), adjusting the invisible sash of responsibility that weighed heavily on his non-existent shoulders. “As I recall, I didn’t fight a revolution so we could put faces of divisive, unstable miscreants on a monument meant to symbolize the virtues of unity and democracy. It would be like hanging a portrait of a tax cheat in the halls of the IRS — hardly the vision we had in mind.”
He sighed heavily and looked wistfully toward the horizon, probably imagining a world where presidents didn’t try to destroy the Constitution. “Anyone who undermines the rule of law at every turn, whose greatest triumphs include inciting insurrection and claiming the title of ‘most impeached president in history,’ doesn’t deserve to stand with us. I didn’t cross the Delaware so he could make a mockery of it.”
Thomas Jefferson: Architect of the Declaration and a ‘Somewhat’ Suspicious Philosopher
Jefferson — who, given his extensive career as a wordsmith, was undoubtedly feeling a deep, literary urge to break out a few pithy comments — strode forward, clearing his throat. “I’ve spent a lifetime writing about liberty, freedom, and the sanctity of law, but even I can’t find a way to spin this into something resembling a ‘perfect union.’”
He continued with his trademark sarcasm. “To think, a man who is so disinterested in the Constitution — something he’s likely never read — that he might as well wipe his golf clubs with it is now being proposed as someone worthy of joining us on this sacred rock? Let me tell you something: a country that allows such behavior doesn’t need more presidents — it needs a good lawyer.”
A thoughtful expression crossed his stone face. “If he spent more time reading and less time tweeting, he might realize Mount Rushmore stands for democracy — not self-glorification.”
Abraham Lincoln: The Emancipator, Still Fighting a Civil War — on His Day Off
Lincoln, ever the voice of reason in a sea of absurdity, piped up next, though not without a touch of exasperation. “Well, I always thought the hardest thing I’d ever do was keep the Union together during a bloody Civil War. It turns out that dealing with this guy is harder.
“Look, I understand the need to bring people together,” he began, “but Trump’s ‘unifying message’ seems to consist of name-calling and golf courses, which, let me assure you, are not the foundations of a great democracy.”
A beat of silence followed. “The man disrupted a peaceful transition of power, incited an insurrection, and, oh yes, received not one but two impeachments. I’m sorry, but even my ‘Honest Abe’ reputation can’t stretch that far. The only thing Trump has contributed to this country is an alarming ability to normalize failure.”
Theodore Roosevelt: The Trust-Buster, But Not the ‘Trust Fund Baby’
Teddy Roosevelt, who once took on corporate monopolies, leaned forward, rubbing his hands together like a mischievous schoolboy. “Let’s cut to the chase,” he boomed. “Trump’s idea of leadership is bullying, boasting, and grifting. My brand of leadership — now that was about action. I charged up San Juan Hill! I gave America national parks! I didn’t hide in the White House while the Capitol was overrun by thugs who wanted to tear up the Constitution!”
He let out a short laugh, and a few of the birds perched on nearby rocks even fluttered in surprise. “No, no — Trump’s legacy isn’t one of public service. It’s a grift cooked up with scandal and served with a side of self-promotion. A leader who bows down to authoritarian figures and defends autocracies does not belong in the company of giants who fought for freedom.”
Washington, Jefferson, Lincoln, and Roosevelt: The Verdict Is In (And It’s Not Good)
With the matter settled, the four, who, for once, didn’t need to speak to agree, gazed at each other in silent understanding. Washington, ever dignified, broke the silence: “This bill is not just a misguided idea; it’s an embarrassment. And the idea that Trump, who has accelerated his efforts to rip up the Constitution in his second term, is somehow fit for this monument? Well, it defies all sense of reason.”
Jefferson chimed in, a wry smile playing at the corner of his lips. “I might have written about revolution, but this is a whole new kind of revolt — one that challenges the very fabric of our democracy. Let’s just say that if his face goes on this mountain, I’m getting off it.”
Lincoln, his tone unwavering, added, “We each fought for liberty, and that man is no liberator. His second term? It’s just the beginning of a battle to see how far he can drag this country down into his gutter and away from the values that truly matter.”
Teddy Roosevelt, shaking his head, summed it up with a final chuckle: “And let’s not forget: when it comes to Mount Rushmore, we may not always get to pick who gets immortalized. But we sure know who shouldn’t.”
The Lunacy of the Proposal
In the end, the four figures agreed. Trump’s face would never join theirs. While the idea was a laughable stunt designed to stir the MAGA base, it also represented a dangerous turn in American politics — one where power-hungry leaders like Trump sought to rewrite history by erasing the very principles upon which the nation was founded.
So, to be clear: Trump’s place isn’t carved in stone; it’s better left as a warning in the history books — a tale of how one man, desperate for recognition, sought to tear down the republic for his gain. If the American people insist on immortalizing him, they can carve his face onto an outhouse door at Mar-a-Lago.
But not here. Not on Mount Rushmore.
And that, my friends, is no joke.
~Meeting notes transcribed by Dunneagin~
📬 To receive each new essay by email the day it publishes, subscribe to Civics Unhinged.
☕ Reader editions and collected volumes—including Volumes 1, 2, 3, and The Liar’s Guide to Autocracy—are available on the Fourthwall bookshelf.
If this week’s dispatch aligned with your reading, forward it to an un-unhinged colleague who still keeps an eye on the clockwork.
Reader and listener correspondence is always welcome at dunneagin@dunneagin.net. Questions, observations, or a note on how you first stumbled into the chronicle are particularly appreciated.
A note on the shelf: Every Tuesday dispatch compiles toward a permanent, physical record. We print what the screen forgets.