Civics Unhinged

Civics Unhinged

Apparently, Losing an Election Is Grounds for Admission.

America has always been a welcoming country, provided one meets the appropriate qualifications. These have varied considerably over the years, but the Trump administration appears to have introduced a new one: losing an election while remaining on sufficiently friendly terms with the president.

Flávio Bolsonaro, having lost Brazil's presidential election (by more than four million votes), found himself in a disagreeable position. The voters had selected someone else, the Brazilian judiciary ordered him to surrender his passports, making his prospects for remaining in Brazil considerably less comfortable.

Fortunately, he had friends in Washington.

According to published reporting, a White House official helped arrange Bolsonaro's departure from South America. President Donald Trump personally authorized his temporary admission to the United States.

This was an impressive display of administrative efficiency from a government not generally celebrated for its enthusiasm for admitting foreigners.

Ordinarily, the administration approaches immigration with the disposition of a hotel proprietor who has discovered that the guests intend to stay permanently. Doors are secured, credentials examined, and considerable attention devoted to explaining why the country cannot possibly accommodate another person.

But apparently there is room at the inn.

The distinction, one gathers, is political.

Bolsonaro was not merely a visitor seeking better weather. He was a defeated presidential candidate who disputed the legitimacy of the election he had lost. His departure occurred while Brazilian authorities were pursuing investigations and seeking compliance with judicial restrictions.

None of this establishes his guilt of any criminal offense. Nor does it establish that American officials committed one by assisting him.

But neither proposition is necessary to understand what happened.

The American president chose to assist a political ally who had rejected the verdict of his country's voters.

That is the relevant fact.

There is something wonderfully revealing about an administration that lectures the world on national sovereignty while reserving the right to decide which foreign politicians deserve its personal hospitality.

One might reasonably suppose that the United States would regard the outcome of Brazil's election as a matter for Brazilians. After all, Americans have historically shown considerable sensitivity when foreigners offer opinions about the legitimacy of their elections.

But Mr. Trump has never been especially troubled by the limitations of consistency.

It is possible, of course, that the administration regards Bolsonaro's arrival as a purely humanitarian matter. Political defeat can be emotionally devastating, particularly when accompanied by judicial inquiries. One can imagine the discomfort of discovering that millions of one's fellow citizens have not merely voted against one's candidacy but expect the result to be respected.

Still, the United States cannot reasonably offer sanctuary to every disappointed politician. There would scarcely be room for the ordinary immigrants whom the administration is so determined to exclude.

And here lies the more consequential observation: a president possesses considerable discretion over immigration and foreign relations. The exercise of that discretion inevitably reveals priorities. But when an administration makes exceptional efforts to accommodate a particular foreign political figure, the public is entitled to consider what that accommodation says about the administration’s understanding of democratic legitimacy.

The question is not whether Flávio Bolsonaro deserves sympathy, nor whether he will ultimately be convicted of anything.

It is whether the American presidency should become a refuge for political allies who find the decisions of their own electorates disagreeable.

Perhaps the administration has discovered a new principle of democratic government: elections are binding upon the winners, but the losers may apply for accommodations in Miami.

The voters of Brazil have rendered their verdict.

Washington, apparently, has provided the appeal.

— Dunneagin