Civics Unhinged

Civics Unhinged

Bamboozling the Gullible

An Open Letter from P.T. Barnum to Mr. Donald Trump

Originally Published: January 22, 2024

Restored Edition No. 6: September 16, 2026

Editor's Note (Restored Edition No. 6): This essay was originally published on January 22, 2024, and has been reviewed for inclusion in the Permanent Collection of Civics Unhinged. The text preserves the original argument and historical context while incorporating minor editorial corrections, updated classification, and connections to related works.


An Open Letter from P.T. Barnum to Mr. Donald Trump

Dear Mr. Trump,

I congratulate you on your upcoming nomination. You will represent the Republicans in the 2024 presidential election. It seems my ways of persuasion via "freak shows," as you call it, have taken hold in your grand political circus! Of course, I would be remiss if I didn't send a note of appreciation. You carry on the great tradition of bamboozling the gullible. You lead them into following your grand spectacle.

Your nomination is a feat of unparalleled showmanship. Your spectacular performances at the rallies resonate with the right hypnotic tunes, which captivates the crowd. They echo the days of General Tom Thumb's impressive acts.

I could appreciate the colorful array of outlandish claims. I could understand the confounding acts of escalating rhetoric. I could appreciate the grand melodrama of racial grievance. Your production is much like the theatrics at my Grand Traveling Museum of Hippodrome, old chap. Of course, let's not forget the famous "Feejee" mermaid. Also, the tonic glorified snake oil cured ailments. My ever-amused visitors enjoyed them. They were much like certain medications you held in high regard during the pandemic.

You can attract attention and spin fables. Your ability surpasses even the most ingenious hoaxes of yesteryear. You've managed to deceive many with finesse, akin to my legendary hoaxes and urban myths. It's a masterclass in turning a profit or, in your case, garnering followers.

I also want to express my admiration for your audacious forays into the political arena. Your confident strides onto the electoral stage could have left me gasping with envy. You are treading the line between unabashed audacity and theatrical bravado. Your resume has the charisma of an old showman. It's much like when my American Museum made every reveler on Broadway notice. It spreads the paint of your political promises.

Moreover, your knack for telling captivating tales shows an enchanting way of persuading. You also use magical thinking, which is captivating. I've practiced it, twirling skepticism into wonder and mystique. Indeed, you've transformed the election into a grand tour fit for General Tom Thumb. You've dazzled the electorate with fascinating promises. They are as captivating as the exhibit of a "Human Marvel."

The untrained eye may see your antics as mere folly. The trained observer knows better than to underestimate a grand spectacle. They saw Tom Thumb and much like them. I transformed the Moral Lecture Room into unrivaled palaces of palatable entertainment. I hoped to win the approval of the moral crusaders of the age. You have expertly created a theater of partisan reverie. You dazzle and delight your MAGA audience. You have the panache of a top-notch theatrical impresario.

Congratulations on your well-orchestrated symphony of speeches, rallies, and performances. You are a peerless maestro. Your upcoming nomination heralds a new chapter in American political history. Scholars and showmen of every stripe will analyze it with relish and perplexity for generations to come.

Yours in good humor and grand exhibition,

Phineas Taylor Barnum

P.S. The spirit of General Tom Thumb, The Feejee mermaid, and Jumbo the Elephant rejoiced. They are celebrating the stir you have whipped up in your MAGA followers! All the spectacles and specters of the grand circus I've cherished are, too.

Artistically,

P.T. Barnum


📬 To receive each new essay by email the day it publishes, subscribe to Civics Unhinged.

☕ Reader editions and collected volumes—including Volumes 1, 2, 3, and The Liar’s Guide to Autocracy—are available on the Fourthwall bookshelf.

If this week’s dispatch aligned with your reading, forward it to an un-unhinged colleague who still keeps an eye on the clockwork.

Reader and listener correspondence is always welcome at dunneagin@dunneagin.net. Questions, observations, or a note on how you first stumbled into the chronicle are particularly appreciated.

A note on the shelf: Every Tuesday dispatch compiles toward a permanent, physical record. We print what the screen forgets.