America’s political system has always been vulnerable to opportunists who declare themselves “independent thinkers” while cashing checks from the industries they pretend to regulate. Few have embodied this tradition with more gusto than Joe Manchin. Now, in the autumn of his career, the New York Times has seen fit to re-anoint him as a kind of philosopher king of centrism. He’s retired, yes, but apparently retirement hasn’t stopped him from handing out life lessons — from the deck of his yacht.
The Times piece is almost affectionate, portraying him as “voluble,” reflective, maybe even indispensable. But let’s recall the record. Manchin is the man who joined hands with Kyrsten Sinema to hobble Biden’s early legislative agenda. While Democrats held a fleeting majority, and the country was desperate for decisive reforms, Manchin positioned himself as the human speed bump on Pennsylvania Avenue. He didn’t just slow progress—he narrowed it to a single lane, then charged a toll.
“The Brand Is Just So Bad”
In the Times interview, Manchin suggests that Kamala Harris’s loss in 2024 wasn’t really about her but about the party’s “bad brand.”
The party brand, Joe, didn’t just go bad on its own, like milk left on a West Virginia porch. It was curdled in real time by self-serving moderates who spent four years publicly scolding their own side while giving Republicans endless cover to play the obstruction game. When the Democratic brand looked dithering, divided, and powerless, it was because Joe Manchin was on Sunday shows explaining why good policy had to die in committee.
It’s the equivalent of burning down the kitchen and then shaking your head about the smell of smoke.
Manchin laments that “the country doesn’t want radical change.” But the policies he killed—child tax credits that lifted millions out of poverty, paid family leave, serious climate investments, protections against the erosion of voting rights—weren’t radical. They were popular. They were mainstream. What was radical was Manchin’s insistence that compromise must always mean moving right, and that moderation means defending the status quo until the floor collapses beneath us.
The Yacht as Metaphor
Let us not overlook the boat.
For years, Manchin lived aboard Almost Heaven, a 65-foot yacht moored in the Washington Potomac. It was the ultimate metaphor for a politician adrift between two shores, neither of them working-class America. While West Virginia struggled with coal transition, opioid epidemics, and crumbling infrastructure, its senior senator was hosting bipartisan wine-and-cheese salons on the water.
In the Times profile, the boat returns like an old friend. Manchin reflects on his career while the river laps gently against the hull. It’s hard to imagine a more perfect encapsulation of his political brand: isolated from consequence, sustained by privilege, and convinced that because you’re floating between both banks, you must be in the right place.
Coal, Climate, and Cash
The interview also glosses over the fundamental conflict at the heart of the Manchin myth: money.
For years, Manchin’s personal wealth was tied to Enersystems, a coal brokerage firm he founded that paid him millions in dividends while he chaired the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee. Every time he gutted climate legislation in the name of “fiscal responsibility,” his bank account quietly cheered. This wasn’t moderation; it was conflict of interest dressed in a bespoke suit.
Yet the political press has always treated Manchin’s obstructionism as a principled regional stance, as though he were simply channeling the coal miners of West Virginia. But those miners didn’t benefit from his obstinacy. They got polluted air, disappearing pensions, and the slow decline of their communities while their senator defended the fossil fuel industry under the guise of common sense.
The Danger of Nostalgia
Why does the Times keep reviving Joe Manchin? Because the political press has an incurable addiction to the myth of the sensible center.
In the media’s imagination, the center is where wisdom lives. It’s the place of serious adults, bipartisan dinners, and polite compromises. Never mind that the “center” in American politics has often been the graveyard of moral progress, from civil rights to climate action.
Manchin represents a fantasy: that if we just had more reasonable guys who liked to talk over bourbon, Washington would work again. But Washington didn’t stop working because people stopped drinking together. It stopped working because one party embraced authoritarian revanchism while the other allowed itself to be held hostage by rent-seeking opportunists who mistook their own leverage for moral authority.
The Myth of the Virtuous Center
Joe Manchin didn’t save the country from radicalism; he helped pave the road to where we are now. By weakening popular legislation, demoralizing the Democratic base, and legitimizing Republican obstruction as “bipartisan concern,” he contributed directly to the cynicism that defines our politics today.
Now he sits on his yacht, dispensing advice about how the Democrats need to move back to the middle. It’s advice from a man who mistook the middle of the river for high ground.
The political obituary for Joe Manchin has been written many times, yet he keeps bobbing back to the surface. But we should be clear about what his legacy really is: not the triumph of common-sense moderation, but the cautionary tale of a political class that would rather preserve the architecture of gridlock than risk the discomfort of real change.
📬 To receive each new essay by email the day it publishes, subscribe to Civics Unhinged.
☕ Reader editions and collected volumes—including Volumes 1, 2, 3, and The Liar’s Guide to Autocracy—are available on the Fourthwall bookshelf.
If this week’s dispatch aligned with your reading, forward it to an un-unhinged colleague who still keeps an eye on the clockwork.
Reader and listener correspondence is always welcome at dunneagin@dunneagin.net. Questions, observations, or a note on how you first stumbled into the chronicle are particularly appreciated.
A note on the shelf: Every Tuesday dispatch compiles toward a permanent, physical record. We print what the screen forgets.