Originally Published: July 10, 2026
Restored Edition No. 15: September 16, 2026
Editor’s Note (Restored Edition No. 15): This essay was originally published on July 10, 2026, and has been reviewed for inclusion in the Permanent Collection of Civics Unhinged. The text preserves the original argument and historical context while incorporating minor editorial corrections, updated classification, and connections to related works.
For generations, Cuba occupied a special place in the American imagination. It was a communist outpost ninety miles from Florida. It hosted Soviet missiles. Fidel Castro wore olive drab uniforms, smoked cigars large enough to have their own ZIP codes, and regularly appeared in the nightmares of Cold War strategists.
Those were serious concerns.
That was also several decades ago.
The Soviet Union has since collapsed, the Berlin Wall has become a tourist attraction, and Fidel Castro has departed for that great revolutionary committee meeting in the sky. Yet somehow, Cuba remains one of the most terrifying threats in American politics.
Not an actual threat, mind you.
A political threat.
Every few years, someone in Washington notices that Americans have become distracted by mundane matters such as healthcare, housing costs, infrastructure, climate change, education, or whether the government is still capable of performing basic administrative functions. At that point, a statesman rises to his feet, points dramatically toward the Caribbean, and announces that Cuba is plotting something.
Exactly what Cuba is plotting is rarely specified.
That would only invite questions.
The important thing is that Americans understand the danger. Somewhere in Havana, a committee of aging communists and overworked electrical engineers is apparently masterminding events so consequential that they require immediate congressional attention.
One almost feels sorry for Cuba.
Most nations dream of being taken seriously on the world stage. Cuba has achieved the opposite distinction. It is treated as a geopolitical supervillain long after the rest of the world has moved on to newer villains.
The country struggles with power outages, food shortages, emigration, and an economy that often resembles a museum exhibit on twentieth-century planning. Yet in Washington’s imagination, Cuba remains one dramatic speech away from conquering the Western Hemisphere.
It is an extraordinary achievement.
Most countries spend decades building military strength, economic power, and diplomatic influence. Cuba apparently accomplished the same feat by continuing to exist.
Of course, Cuba’s greatest advantage has never been its military.
Its greatest advantage is that it exists.
That may not sound impressive, but in Washington, it qualifies as a strategic asset.
Every political generation requires a villain. Some countries get dragons, some get dark lords, and some get offshore tax havens. America, however, has long preferred islands. Islands are convenient. They stay put. They do not wander off and join another continent. They sit patiently offshore waiting to be blamed for whatever happens next.
Cuba has performed this service faithfully for more than sixty years.
Agricultural prices rise? Cuba.
A protest movement emerges somewhere in Latin America? Cuba.
A college student grows a beard and starts reading political theory? Cuba.
Someone loses an election? Surprisingly, also Cuba.
At times, one suspects that if a member of Congress burned a bagel during breakfast, an investigative committee would be convened to determine whether Havana had somehow been involved.
This arrangement has worked out well for everyone except Cuba.
American politicians receive a permanent source of outrage.
Cable news receives dramatic graphics.
Think tanks receive conference invitations.
Fundraising emails practically write themselves.
Meanwhile, Cuba receives another reminder that it remains the most famous island in the Western Hemisphere not named Manhattan.
The truly remarkable part is that none of this requires Cuba to do anything.
An ordinary country must work tirelessly to maintain relevance. Cuba merely wakes up each morning and discovers that someone in Washington has once again become alarmed by its continued existence.
Imagine the burden.
The average Cuban citizen is attempting to find groceries, keep the lights on, and persuade younger relatives not to emigrate. Yet somewhere thousands of miles away, a politician is describing the island as though it were assembling a fleet capable of retaking the Panama Canal.
One almost admires the efficiency of the arrangement.
The less capable Cuba becomes, the more imaginative its enemies must become.
And imagination, unlike military power, is an unlimited resource.
That may explain why Cuba occupies such a peculiar place in American politics. It has become less a country than a prop.
A real country can disappoint you.
A symbolic country can do anything.
It can threaten democracy.
It can undermine capitalism.
It can corrupt youth.
It can explain election results.
It can justify campaign donations.
It can fill airtime between commercials.
Most importantly, it can save politicians from having to discuss problems that are considerably closer to home.
This is the point at which Cuba ceases to be a foreign policy issue and becomes a domestic marketing strategy.
The purpose is not to understand Cuba.
The purpose is to understand fear.
Fear is one of the few political products that never goes out of style.
The packaging changes. The slogans change. The villains change.
The sales technique remains the same.
Which brings us to the latest effort to Make Cuba Terrifying Again.
Apparently, after six decades of warnings, embargoes, speeches, sanctions, hearings, investigations, and declarations of imminent danger, some people have concluded that Americans are insufficiently alarmed.
This is a bold claim.
One imagines the marketing meeting.
“People aren’t frightened enough.”
“Sir, we’ve been warning them since the Eisenhower administration.”
“Exactly. We need fresh messaging.”
And thus, another generation is invited to believe that the exhausted island ninety miles from Florida remains the central challenge of twenty-first century American governance.
Not inflation.
Not healthcare.
Not infrastructure.
Not housing.
Not artificial intelligence.
Not climate change.
Not whether Congress can pass a budget without threatening national cardiac arrest.
Cuba.
Again.
Perhaps it is time for a modest proposal.
Perhaps Washington should place Cuba on a temporary six-month leave of absence.
No hearings.
No emergency statements.
No breathless warnings.
No congressional delegations standing in front of maps.
No experts appearing on television to explain that this time they are absolutely serious.
Just six months.
Leave Cuba alone.
Treat it the way Americans treat Paraguay.
Or Luxembourg.
Or most of Canada.
The experiment would be fascinating.
Would the Republic survive?
Would the Constitution continue functioning?
Would Americans still be able to purchase groceries, attend baseball games, and complain about the weather?
I suspect they would.
The greater danger might lie elsewhere.
Entire political ecosystems could collapse.
Think tanks might have to discuss actual policy.
Fundraising consultants might be forced to invent new subject lines.
Cable news producers could find themselves covering legislation.
Members of Congress might even be compelled to explain how they intend to solve problems that exist inside the United States rather than ninety miles offshore.
The economic consequences alone could be devastating.
An entire generation of professional alarmists might suddenly discover that Cuba had been doing more work for them than they had been doing for themselves.
Fortunately, such risks are purely theoretical.
No one in Washington is likely to permit Cuba to retire from its duties.
The island remains far too useful.
After all, Cuba has become one of the most reliable employees in American politics. It has reported for work every day since the Eisenhower administration. It requires no salary, receives no pension, and never complains when assigned the blame for yet another crisis.
That is a level of dedication rarely encountered in public service.
And so the warnings will continue.
The speeches will continue.
The hearings will continue.
The declarations of imminent danger will continue.
Somewhere in Havana, an exhausted electrical worker will attempt to restore power to a neighborhood suffering another blackout while American politicians describe him as part of a geopolitical menace of almost supernatural proportions.
One hopes he appreciates the compliment.
For more than sixty years, Cuba has occupied a singular place in the American imagination. It has survived presidents, congresses, commissions, investigations, embargoes, sanctions, editorials, speeches, and enough predictions of its imminent collapse to fill a small library.
Yet somehow the island endures.
The truly remarkable thing is not that Cuba survived all those years.
The remarkable thing is that after all this time, Washington still expects us to be frightened.
At some point, even the monster in the movie deserves a rest.
But apparently not this one.
Because in a city increasingly devoted to performance, every show needs a villain.
And when all else fails, there is always Cuba.
Still sitting exactly where it has been all along.
Waiting patiently for America to become terrified again.
** Cuba’s request for retirement was reportedly denied after federal officials determined that replacing a sixty-year-old threat would require a costly government study.
📬 To receive each new essay by email the day it publishes, subscribe to Civics Unhinged.
☕ Reader editions and collected volumes—including Volumes 1, 2, 3, and The Liar’s Guide to Autocracy—are available on the Fourthwall bookshelf.
If this week’s dispatch aligned with your reading, forward it to an un-unhinged colleague who still keeps an eye on the clockwork.
Reader and listener correspondence is always welcome at dunneagin@dunneagin.net. Questions, observations, or a note on how you first stumbled into the chronicle are particularly appreciated.
A note on the shelf: Every Tuesday dispatch compiles toward a permanent, physical record. We print what the screen forgets.