Civics Unhinged

Civics Unhinged

The President Who Monetizes the Presidency

On the constitutional hazards of executive enterprise, and what happens when the chief magistrate's office is valued by the yield.

If you prefer to listen, click here for the spoken edition. If you prefer to read, the dispatch continues below.

Americans are hardly strangers to political corruption. We have seen governors sell influence, senators accept favors, and public officials who blur the line between public service and private gain. From city halls to statehouses to the halls of Congress, the temptation to convert public authority into private advantage has accompanied republican government from its earliest days.

Yet these scandals shared an important characteristic: they involved individuals abusing public office.

What makes the current moment different is the growing perception that the presidency itself may no longer be viewed as a public trust, but as an asset capable of generating value.

For most of American history, the office of the president occupied a peculiar place in the public imagination. Presidents sought influence, certainly. They cultivated political allies, rewarded supporters, and advanced policies favorable to their constituencies. Some left office to write books, deliver speeches, or establish foundations. Others entered private life with considerable wealth.

Yet there remained a broadly understood distinction between the office and the officeholder: the presidency belonged to the republic. The individual merely occupied it for a time.

This distinction was not merely ceremonial. It reflected a deeper republican principle: Public office was understood as a trust temporarily placed in the hands of an elected official for the public's benefit. The authority attached to the office was never intended to become a private possession, much less a commercial opportunity.

George Washington understood this instinctively. So did many of his successors. Their politics differed. Their ambitions differed. Their successes and failures differed. Yet most accepted a common premise: the presidency existed to serve the nation, not the other way around.

Today, that understanding appears increasingly unsettled.

Recent years have witnessed a series of events that, viewed individually, might be dismissed as ordinary political behavior. Donors seek access. Corporations pursue favorable treatment. Media organizations settle disputes. Political allies receive consideration. Wealthy supporters cultivate relationships with those who possess influence.

None of this is entirely new.

What is new is the growing impression that these activities increasingly orbit the presidency itself.

The distinction matters.

Americans have long worried about political corruption because corruption threatens the fair administration of government. But political corruption traditionally implied an improper transaction, an exchange of favors, money, or influence. The concern was the cost of the transaction.

Now, a different concern has emerged.

If the presidency is now being seen in these terms, the consequences extend far beyond any individual officeholder.

When Access Becomes Currency

The presidency has always possessed symbolic value.

Foreign leaders seek meetings with presidents. Business leaders seek access. Political allies seek appointments. Journalists seek interviews. Donors seek influence. Such interactions are inevitable in a system where executive authority is concentrated in a single office.

The question is not whether access to the nation’s chief executive has value. It plainly does.

The question is what happens when that value becomes increasingly visible, increasingly exploitable, and increasingly connected to the officeholder's personal interests.

The modern presidency presents a different temptation.

The office commands immense attention. Every appearance attracts coverage. Every statement moves markets, shapes public opinion, and influences decisions throughout government and society. The presidency continues to possess not only symbolic and political power but also extraordinary financial potential.

Symbolic and political power can be converted.

Visibility can be converted.

Access can be converted.

Association can be converted.

The potential financial value often lies not in the formal exercise of presidential authority, but in access to it, association with it, or proximity to those who wield it. At that point, the presidency no longer functions solely as an institution of governance. It begins to function as an ecosystem of opportunities.

And ecosystems attract participants.

The issue is not whether every transaction violates a law. The issue is whether the office itself increasingly encourages transactional thinking.

A republic can survive isolated corruption. It struggles when public office comes to be viewed less as a trust and more as a source of personal advantage.

The Greater Danger

The greatest danger posed by this development is not the enrichment of a single president.

American history contains no shortage of ambitious, flawed, and occasionally corrupt public officials. The republic survived them all.

The greater danger lies in changing expectations.

Political institutions depend as much upon custom as law. Citizens, officeholders, and public servants inherit assumptions about how authority should be exercised. These assumptions become guardrails long before they become statutes.

Once a practice becomes accepted, future officeholders inherit not only the power of the office but the expectations attached to it.

What one president normalizes, another may expand.

What begins as an exception may become a precedent.

What is tolerated today may be expected tomorrow.

This is why the question extends beyond Donald Trump.

The issue is not whether one president is profiting from public office. The issue is whether future presidents, regardless of party, come to view the presidency itself as an asset capable of producing political, financial, and personal returns.

If that understanding takes hold, the character of the office changes. The presidency ceases to be a trust temporarily granted by the electorate.

It becomes an investment.

And investments are managed differently from trusts.

The Framers understood that public officials would be tempted by power. What concerned them was not simply corruption but dependency, the possibility that public decisions might become entangled with private interests.

Their solution was imperfect. No constitutional system can eliminate ambition, greed, or self-interest. What it can do is establish expectations about the proper use of public authority.

As this essay was being prepared for publication, The New York Times reported that President Trump had defended the billions of dollars in wealth he had reportedly accumulated during his second term, much of it tied to ventures whose value derived from his unique position as president. The particulars will be debated, as they should be. The more enduring question remains unchanged: what happens when the presidency itself becomes financially valuable?

For two and one-half centuries, Americans largely understood the presidency to be a public trust. Presidents held power, but they did not own it. They exercised authority, but they did not possess the office itself.

That understanding now appears less certain.

The concern is not simply that value is being generated around the presidency. The concern is that the presidency is now viewed as an asset from which political, financial, and personal value may be reaped.

A republic can survive unpopular presidents. It can survive ineffective presidents. It can even survive corrupt presidents.

What it may find more difficult to survive is a presidency that increasingly comes to be viewed not as a public trust, but a private political or financial opportunity.

When the office itself becomes the asset, the question is no longer who occupies the presidency.

The question becomes what the presidency has become.

— Dunneagin


Keep reading: The Projection Gap



☕ Reader editions and collected volumes—including Volumes 1, 2, 3, and The Liar’s Guide to Autocracy—are available on the Fourthwall bookshelf.

If this week’s dispatch aligned with your reading, forward it to an un-unhinged colleague who still keeps an eye on the clockwork.

Reader and listener correspondence is always welcome at f.p.dunneagin@gmail.com. Questions, observations, or a note on how you first stumbled into the chronicle are particularly appreciated.

A note on the shelf: Every Tuesday dispatch compiles toward a permanent, physical record. We print what the screen forgets.