Civics Unhinged

Civics Unhinged

When a President Puts Himself on the Ballot

When campaign rhetoric collides with the machinery of government, the stakes become constitutional.

If you prefer to listen, click here for the spoken edition. If you prefer to read, the dispatch continues below.

On a recent Wednesday night in Dallas, during the Republican Party’s midterm convention, the president of the United States asked voters to do something rather unusual.

“Pretend I’m on the ballot,” Donald Trump told them. “I’m on the ballot. Just one more time.”

Then he sweetened the proposition.

If Republicans retain control of Congress in November, Trump said, every adult American would receive what he called a $5,000 “Trump Dividend.” The proposal could cost more than $1 trillion, would require congressional approval, and arrived without much explanation of precisely how it would work.

But set the money aside for a moment.

The first sentence may have been the more revealing one.

“Pretend I’m on the ballot.”

Presidents have always campaigned. They endorse candidates, raise money, attack the opposition, defend their records, and try to persuade voters that life will become substantially less pleasant if Congress falls into the hands of the other party.

That is politics.

Presidents and political parties also make promises: elect us and taxes will fall. Elect them and civilization will collapse. Give us Congress and prosperity will follow shortly thereafter.

That, too, is politics.

But presidents possess something ordinary politicians do not: they control the machinery of the executive branch.

And that makes the boundary between campaigning in an election and involving the government in its administration rather important.

The President Who Is Not on the Ballot

Donald Trump will not appear on the ballot in November.

Republican candidates for the House and Senate will. Democratic candidates will. Independent candidates will. State and local candidates will.

Trump will not.

Yet his administration has become increasingly involved not merely in arguing about the election, but in the governmental machinery surrounding it.

The Justice Department has sued states seeking unredacted voter lists containing personal information such as driver’s-license numbers and partial Social Security numbers. It has also sent letters to election officials telling them to preserve records from the 2024 election and informing them that their states are under investigation.

According to The New York Times, the department has sued 30 states seeking voter data. It has lost 23 of those cases, won none, and awaits decisions in the remainder.

And then, there are Homeland Security investigations.

Homeland Security ordinarily concerns itself with such modest matters as drug trafficking, human trafficking, money laundering and other transnational crimes. It has now been enlisted in the search for noncitizens who voted illegally.

ProPublica examined Justice Department data covering January 2025 through May of this year. Fewer than 150 suspected noncitizen voters were referred for prosecution. Forty-one people were charged with illegal voting or other election-related crimes.

More than 150 million people voted in the last presidential election.

None of this means illegal voting should be ignored. It is a crime. Investigate it. Prosecute it when the evidence warrants.

But another question is worth asking: How much of the federal government should be mobilized to establish the electoral claims of the president who controls it?

The Mailman Has a New Job

Meanwhile, another part of the federal government—the United States Postal Service—was preparing for a new assignment.

USPS’s traditional role in elections has been refreshingly comprehensible.

Election officials mail ballots.

Voters mail them back.

The Postal Service delivers them.

This apparently lacked ambition.

Trump’s March 2026 executive order envisioned a federal system involving citizenship information, special ballot-envelope requirements, barcodes, and lists determining which voters could receive and return ballots through the mail. It also directed the attorney general to prioritize investigations involving the unlawful distribution of ballots.

The Supreme Court has now blocked those new mail-voting requirements from taking effect before November.

That settles an immediate question. It does not settle the larger one.

The Constitution assigns the initial responsibility for determining the “Times, Places and Manner” of congressional elections to the states and gives Congress authority to alter those regulations.

Not the president.

But legality is only part of what should concern us.

Presidencies operate within laws. Healthy presidencies also operate within expected norms.

And one expected principle ought to be easy to articulate: the president should not use the executive machinery he controls to place himself between citizens and the casting of their ballots.

Not because every president is corrupt. But because every president is interested.

The Problem of Interest

Imagine the arrangement without Donald Trump.

Imagine a Democratic president facing the possibility of losing Congress.

Now imagine that president campaigning furiously to preserve Democratic control while the Justice Department demands state voter records; while federal law-enforcement agencies search voter rolls for evidence supporting the president’s claims about illegal voting, and the administration attempts to impose new federal requirements on the way mail ballots reach voters.

Republicans would be entitled to ask whether something had gone badly wrong.

And they would be right to ask.

The principle cannot depend upon which president occupies the White House.

That is the entire point of having one.

The question is not whether we trust this president with the authority.

The question is whether we would want any president possessing it.

Power acquired by the president you favor eventually becomes power inherited by the president you do not.

There is another reason to care: In July, Pew Research Center asked Americans whether they believed November’ midterm elections would be conducted fairly and accurately.

Only 55 percent said they were confident they would be.

That is lower than before the 2024, 2022, and 2020 elections.

Perhaps more revealingly, confidence was almost identical among Republicans and Democrats.

An election does not merely have to produce an accurate count. Citizens must also be able to believe that the government administering the laws surrounding that election did not have its thumb on the scale.

Which brings us back to Dallas.

Pretend I’m on the Ballot

Donald Trump may inadvertently have provided the clearest explanation of the problem himself: “Pretend I’m on the ballot.”

Very well.

Let us pretend.

If the president wishes to place himself politically on the ballot, he is entitled to do so.

Let him campaign.

Let him defend his record.

Let him promise $5,000 checks, denounce Democrats, praise Republicans, and tell voters that the fall of civilization itself hangs upon the congressional delegation from suburban Philadelphia.

That is democracy.

But the moment a president places himself politically on the ballot, another principle becomes more important, not less: he should keep his hands off the ballot box.

Election officials should know whom they serve: the voters.

Federal agencies should know whom they serve: the public.

And the president should remember that the extraordinary powers entrusted to his office belong to the presidency—not to his campaign, not to his party, and not to his desire to remain politically indispensable.

We hold elections for a reason.

They are the mechanism by which citizens decide who will exercise governmental power.

That mechanism cannot command confidence if the people already exercising governmental power begin rearranging it while asking voters to keep them there.

Donald Trump asked Americans to pretend that he is on the ballot this November.

Perhaps we should.

And then remember why no president should be allowed to administer an election as though he were.

— Dunneagin


Keep reading: The Law the President Cannot Write

📬 To receive each new essay by email the day it publishes, subscribe to Civics Unhinged.

☕ Reader editions and collected volumes—including Volumes 1, 2, 3, and The Liar’s Guide to Autocracy—are available on the Fourthwall bookshelf.

If this week’s dispatch aligned with your reading, forward it to an un-unhinged colleague who still keeps an eye on the clockwork.

Reader and listener correspondence is always welcome at dunneagin@dunneagin.net. Questions, observations, or a note on how you first stumbled into the chronicle are particularly appreciated.

A note on the shelf: Every Tuesday dispatch compiles toward a permanent, physical record. We print what the screen forgets.