# The Gentleman Who Could Not Be Wrong

![F.P. Dunneagin avatar](https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=32,height=32,format=webp/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/f9f4f828ec9599c1a612328fd5fc68b0a04bc6e95efbf3ad2ac3828090c1c7b7.png)  F.P. Dunneagin     October 28, 2026 · 6 min read

There is a particular species of gentleman who approaches every undertaking with the serene assurance that its success has already been guaranteed by his participation. He does not require evidence of his abilities; he possesses something infinitely more satisfactory: his own opinion of them.

Such gentlemen are not uncommon. They may be encountered in boardrooms, gentlemen's clubs, and the occasional family gathering where an uncle, having once repaired a kitchen faucet, considers himself qualified to redesign the municipal waterworks.

Most are harmless. Their ambitions seldom extend beyond inconveniencing their relatives. Occasionally, however, one becomes President of the United States.

President Donald Trump has expressed an interest in meeting with Presidents Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping, an arrangement that invites comparison with the great conferences at which powerful nations have attempted to settle the affairs of the world.

The prospect is intriguing. Three gentlemen, representing three formidable powers, assembled to discuss matters affecting several billion people who have not been invited to attend.

Mr. Trump, I imagine, would approach the occasion with considerable enthusiasm. He has long demonstrated an affection for meetings in which the importance of the participants may be established by the grandeur of the surroundings, the length of the table, and the number of photographers permitted to record the proceedings.

Mr. Putin would presumably arrive with Russia's interests in mind. Mr. Xi would bring China's.

Mr. Trump might bring a photograph of himself.

I do not suggest that the American president would neglect the substance of the meeting. I merely observe that he has frequently displayed an extraordinary confidence in his ability to resolve difficulties through the exercise of his personal charm.

It is a method possessing certain advantages. It requires little preparation, permits considerable improvisation, and provides an explanation for failure that does not involve examining one's own conduct.

Should an agreement prove elusive, the other gentlemen may be declared unreasonable.

Should an agreement appear imminent, the American president may announce a triumph.

Should the agreement subsequently collapse, it may be remembered as a triumph interrupted by circumstances.

There is, however, a small difficulty with this approach.

The other gentlemen have interests of their own.

Indeed, they may possess an inconvenient understanding of those interests that is entirely independent of the American president's assessment of them.

Mr. Putin has spent many years pursuing Russian objectives that have survived changes of government, diplomatic protests, economic sanctions, and repeated declarations that some new understanding might at last be possible.

Mr. Xi governs a country whose ambitions are not ordinarily suspended out of courtesy to visiting dignitaries.

Neither gentleman is obliged to confuse Mr. Trump's satisfaction with an agreement for an agreement itself.

This brings us to a question of some importance: How does a gentleman discover that he has made a mistake?

For most of us, the process is unpleasant but relatively straightforward. We attempt something. It fails. Someone points out the error. We resist the observation, perhaps indignantly, before eventually conceding that our original judgment may have been imperfect.

It is not an agreeable experience, but it has the virtue of permitting improvement.

A president enjoys fewer such opportunities.

He inhabits a world in which disagreement may be interpreted as disloyalty, hesitation as weakness, and unwelcome information as an affront to the dignity of his office.

The higher a gentleman rises, the more carefully those around him may choose their words.

An ordinary man who proposes to purchase a horse with three legs will generally be informed of the deficiency before money changes hands. A president who proposes the same transaction may be congratulated upon discovering a remarkable economy in horseshoes.

There is no necessity for anyone to lie outright. A little enthusiasm, a little judicious silence, and an occasional expression of confidence may accomplish the same purpose.

The president announces an intention.

His advisers admire its boldness.

He explains that success is inevitable.

They praise his optimism.

He encounters resistance.

They deplore the obstinacy of his opponents.

And presently the gentleman finds himself surrounded by an extraordinary unanimity of opinion.

He may reasonably conclude that everyone agrees with him. What he may not discover is how many people have concluded that disagreeing is no longer worth the trouble.

This is a dangerous condition, not because the president has become incapable of intelligence, but because he may have become insulated from its correction.

Intelligence and wisdom are different accomplishments. The former may enable a man to win an argument. The latter may occasionally persuade him that the argument was not worth winning.

Nor is confidence itself a defect. A leader must often act amid uncertainty; hesitation can carry costs of its own.

But confidence becomes troublesome when it ceases to be a conclusion and becomes a premise. A gentleman who believes himself exceptionally capable may undertake difficult enterprises with admirable courage.

A gentleman who believes himself incapable of error has removed the principal means by which experience might improve his judgment.

I have observed that this condition is particularly unfortunate in diplomacy. Foreign leaders are under no obligation to provide an American president with the candid advice that his own advisers may hesitate to offer.

Quite the contrary.

A foreign leader who discovers that his counterpart enjoys praise may provide it generously, particularly when it costs nothing.

He may admire the president's strength, applaud his courage, celebrate his originality, and express profound satisfaction at the prospect of a historic friendship.

Such courtesies are inexpensive.

Territory, security guarantees, economic concessions, and strategic advantages are considerably more valuable.

A compliment, properly administered, may therefore prove a remarkably economical instrument of statecraft.

It is possible, of course, that President Trump understands this perfectly well. He may regard extravagant praise as no more than the customary furniture of international diplomacy.

But the relevant question is not whether a president enjoys flattery. Most gentlemen do.

It is whether he can distinguish flattery from agreement, agreement from compliance, and compliance from the durable advancement of his country's interests.

For a president who places exceptional faith in personal relationships, those distinctions are indispensable.

Consider our proposed gathering of three great powers.

Each gentleman arrives with a conception of the world.

Each possesses ambitions that extend beyond the meeting room.

Each may believe that his presence is essential to whatever settlement emerges.

And each has reason to encourage the others to misunderstand as little—or as much—as may serve his purposes.

The photograph, when taken, will establish that three gentlemen sat together.

It will not establish that they understood one another.

Still less will it establish that they agreed.

History has frequently demonstrated that conferences attended by powerful men may produce consequences quite different from those announced at their conclusion.

The participants depart declaring that a new era has begun. The photographers pack their equipment. The communiqués are distributed.

The nations whose futures have been discussed must then discover what, precisely, has been decided on their behalf.

Here the comedy begins to lose some of its charm. For the gentleman who cannot acknowledge error does not ordinarily bear its entire cost.

His advisers may lose their positions. His allies may lose their confidence. His country may lose opportunities that cannot easily be recovered.

Other nations may lose considerably more.

The difficulty with governing is that reality does not recognize the distinction between a mistake made confidently and one made with considerable embarrassment.

Both produce consequences.

And consequences, unlike advisers, cannot be dismissed for insubordination.

I do not know whether Messrs. Trump, Putin, and Xi will ever assemble in the manner imagined, nor what understandings they might reach if they do.

I merely suggest that the most important preparation for such a meeting is not the selection of a suitable venue, the arrangement of the flags, or the composition of the final photograph. It is the willingness of each gentleman to entertain the possibility that he may have misunderstood something.

That is not a fashionable qualification for greatness.

It offers little material for campaign speeches, does not lend itself readily to commemorative merchandise, and is unlikely to inspire an enthusiastic crowd.

Yet history suggests that the ability to recognize one's limitations may be among the more useful qualities possessed by those entrusted with extraordinary power.

A gentleman need not know everything to govern wisely. He must only recognize that there are things he does not know.

Unfortunately, this modest discovery is most difficult for the man who believes he has already discovered everything.

And should three such gentlemen ever assemble to settle the affairs of the world, I recommend that the rest of us pay rather less attention to the photograph than to the exits.

— Dunneagin

## Subscribe to Civics Unhinged

A chronicle of American absurdity, written with a straight face and a sharp pen. Civics Unhinged — satire for those who still give a damn.

Thanks for subscribing.

Top  Latest

- [ November 14, 2025   Vought: The Ideologue with the Budget Knife  ](/@civicsunhinged/vought-the-ideologue-with-the-budget-knife)

- [ October 8, 2025   Postmortem by Gaslight  ](/@civicsunhinged/postmortem-by-gaslight)

- [ February 24, 2026   World Stage, MAGA Script: Willfulness as Governance  ](/@civicsunhinged/world-stage-maga-script-willfulness-as-governance)

- [ November 5, 2025   Coup by Courtesy: How the GOP Handed Over the Keys  ](/@civicsunhinged/coup-by-courtesy-how-the-gop-handed-over-the-keys)

- [ November 22, 2026   The $750 Million Change of Heart  ](/@civicsunhinged/the-dollar750-million-change-of-heart)

- [ November 19, 2026   Three Men and the World Between Them  ](/@civicsunhinged/three-men-and-the-world-between-them)

- [ November 18, 2026   The Billionaires’ Right to Be Forgiven  ](/@civicsunhinged/the-billionaires-right-to-be-forgiven)

- [ November 17, 2026   The Public Office and the Private Purse  ](/@civicsunhinged/the-public-office-and-the-private-purse)