# The Public Office and the Private Purse

![F.P. Dunneagin avatar](https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=32,height=32,format=webp/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/f9f4f828ec9599c1a612328fd5fc68b0a04bc6e95efbf3ad2ac3828090c1c7b7.png)  F.P. Dunneagin     November 17, 2026 · 6 min read      ![Cover image for The Public Office and the Private Purse](https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=1766,height=883,quality=90,format=webp/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/f0ee88d5da6b43876ce5bb36ca37d624bdf0eaf80dab148213edd2423604be06.jpg)

If you prefer to listen, [click here](https://dunneagin.substack.com/p/the-public-office-and-the-private?r=2is4zu&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true) for the spoken version. If you prefer to read, the dispatch continues below.

There was a time when Americans believed that public officials who stole from the government were stealing from the American people. It was a quaint arrangement, admittedly, but one that had served the Republic reasonably well for more than two centuries.

President Donald Trump has now suggested a more economical interpretation.

Asked about allegations involving one of his longtime associates, the President explained that dishonest members of his administration were, in effect, stealing from him. Not from the Treasury. Not from the taxpayers. From him, personally, in his capacity as president.

This is an interesting development in the theory of representative government.

The Founders, who devoted considerable attention to separating public authority from private ambition, apparently neglected to specify that the president was not the beneficial owner of the United States. They may have assumed that the distinction was sufficiently obvious to require no further explanation.

History has demonstrated the dangers of making such assumptions.

Under the new interpretation, the American people retain the privilege of financing their government, Congress retains the inconvenience of appropriating the money, and the president enjoys the satisfaction of regarding any improper diversion of public resources as a personal injury.

One can almost imagine the Treasury Department issuing a revised statement of accounts:

*Assets: The United States of America.*

*Proprietor: Donald J. Trump.*

*Minority shareholders: Approximately 340 million citizens, none possessing a controlling interest.*

The difficulty, of course, is that the president's curious understanding of ownership arrives at a moment when questions about the relationship between public authority and private financial opportunity have become increasingly difficult to ignore.

And the trouble with treating government as personal property is that everyone close to the proprietor may eventually begin wondering what portion of the estate belongs to them.

Consider the curious financial adventures of Alina Habba Mildon, formerly one of the president's personal attorneys.

According to [published reporting](https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trumps-ex-lawyer-alina-habba-loses-massive-contract-days-after-president-blasts-outrageous-deal), she secured a four-year contract worth more than $50 million with a company established by the daughter of Venezuelan banker Julio Herrera Velutini. The agreement was signed while she was serving as acting United States attorney for New Jersey. She subsequently became a senior adviser to the attorney general.

On January 15, 2026, President Trump pardoned Herrera Velutini.

There is no established finding that the contract purchased the pardon, and Habba Mildon emphatically denies having played any role in securing it. Those distinctions matter.

Nevertheless, the arrangement raises questions that would once have caused considerable discomfort among people responsible for protecting the integrity of public office.

The contract reportedly included an $8 million signing bonus, a sum that suggests the legal profession has made remarkable progress since the days when attorneys charged by the hour.

One might reasonably inquire what services commanded such compensation. Ordinary legal advice? Corporate governance? The occasional memorandum? Perhaps a particularly persuasive explanation of why the company required a general counsel with unusually distinguished acquaintances.

We should not presume to know. Indeed, that is precisely why disclosure and independent scrutiny matter.

The president himself eventually pronounced the arrangement outrageous and reportedly urged the family to stop paying her. The company subsequently terminated the contract, citing failure to perform duties. Habba Mildon reportedly retains approximately $14.5 million already received.

It is reassuring to discover that there are limits to the financial rewards of proximity to presidential power. One merely wishes those limits had been established somewhat earlier.

[Meanwhile](https://www.foxnews.com/politics/doj-opens-investigation-trump-ally-corey-lewandowski), another longtime Trump associate, Corey Lewandowski, became the subject of a Justice Department investigation following a criminal referral from the Department of Homeland Security's inspector general.

The reported inquiry concerns allegations that Lewandowski profited from his government role, including questions surrounding his involvement in federal contracts. His attorney denies wrongdoing. An investigation is not a conviction, and allegations are not proof.

But the episode raises a question that extends well beyond the fate of any individual official.

How does a government distinguish between the exercise of public authority and the pursuit of private advantage when the same people move so comfortably between political loyalty, official responsibility, and commercial opportunity?

The traditional answer involves laws, ethics requirements, disclosure, independent oversight, and officials sufficiently removed from the individuals under examination to reach conclusions without first consulting the seating arrangements at Mar-a-Lago.

These safeguards are not particularly glamorous. They involve paperwork, auditors, inspectors general, and the occasional disagreeable question from Congress.

Their principal disadvantage is that they make it difficult to run a republic as though it were a family enterprise.

This is not to suggest that every wealthy acquaintance of a president is corrupt, that every lucrative contract conceals a favor, or that every political adviser is secretly conducting a private business. Such conclusions require evidence.

But public integrity cannot depend entirely upon the innocence of individuals. It requires arrangements that make wrongdoing difficult to conceal, conflicts difficult to ignore, and public decisions possible to examine.

The distinction is fundamental.

A private businessman may regard his company as an extension of himself. He may reward loyal associates, dismiss troublesome subordinates, and complain that anyone who profits at his expense has betrayed him.

A president enjoys no comparable proprietary claim over the government.

The money belongs to the public. The authority is conferred by law. The office is held temporarily. Even the furniture, however garishly redecorated, is not included in the retirement package.

Nor does loyalty to the president substitute for loyalty to the Constitution.

This last distinction is especially troublesome in an administration where personal allegiance can become a political credential. The faithful may reasonably expect recognition for their devotion. But recognition in a constitutional republic is not supposed to include an unrestricted opportunity to convert access into income.

There is a difference between being rewarded for public service and discovering that public service has become an exceptionally promising business development strategy.

The former may be honorable. The latter demands scrutiny.

What makes the President's reported complaint about associates stealing from him so revealing is not that it establishes his intentions. It is that the language itself collapses a distinction on which republican government depends.

The presidency is not a possession. It is an office.

The Treasury is not a personal account. It is a public institution.

And the Department of Justice is not a collection agency for the proprietor.

The American constitutional system was designed around a rather unflattering assessment of human nature: people entrusted with power might be tempted to use it for themselves. The Founders did not imagine that public officials would become virtuous merely by taking an oath. They constructed institutions intended to restrain ambition, expose misconduct, and distribute authority.

It was an ingenious arrangement, though admittedly less convenient than allowing one gentleman to decide who had behaved dishonestly and whether the dishonesty had inconvenienced him.

The difficulty with the proprietary model is that it cannot answer the most important question.

If an associate has stolen from the president, the president may complain.

If an associate has stolen from the American people, the government must investigate.

But if the president himself misunderstands the difference, who is responsible for reminding him?

The answer is not especially mysterious. Congress, the courts, inspectors general, independent investigators, and ultimately the public all have responsibilities within the constitutional order.

None is required to accept the president's personal bookkeeping as the nation's official accounts.

For all their disagreements, the Founders understood that a republic could not survive if public authority became indistinguishable from private property.

They therefore left the presidency in the custody of the people, to be entrusted periodically to an elected occupant.

The occupant may enjoy the office. He may decorate it. He may even imagine that the entire establishment would function better if everyone treated it as his personal enterprise.

But he does not own it.

And when the accounts are finally examined, the American people are not minority shareholders asking permission to inspect the books.

**They are the owners.**

**— Dunneagin**

## Subscribe to Civics Unhinged

A chronicle of American absurdity, written with a straight face and a sharp pen. Civics Unhinged — satire for those who still give a damn.

Thanks for subscribing.

Top  Latest

- [ November 14, 2025   Vought: The Ideologue with the Budget Knife  ](/@civicsunhinged/vought-the-ideologue-with-the-budget-knife)

- [ October 8, 2025   Postmortem by Gaslight  ](/@civicsunhinged/postmortem-by-gaslight)

- [ February 24, 2026   World Stage, MAGA Script: Willfulness as Governance  ](/@civicsunhinged/world-stage-maga-script-willfulness-as-governance)

- [ November 5, 2025   Coup by Courtesy: How the GOP Handed Over the Keys  ](/@civicsunhinged/coup-by-courtesy-how-the-gop-handed-over-the-keys)

- [ November 22, 2026   The $750 Million Change of Heart  ](/@civicsunhinged/the-dollar750-million-change-of-heart)

- [ November 19, 2026   Three Men and the World Between Them  ](/@civicsunhinged/three-men-and-the-world-between-them)

- [ November 18, 2026   The Billionaires’ Right to Be Forgiven  ](/@civicsunhinged/the-billionaires-right-to-be-forgiven)

- [ November 13, 2026   Mr. Justice Alito Discovers Congress  ](/@civicsunhinged/mr-justice-alito-discovers-congress)