<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/">
    <channel>
        <title>Linda Xie</title>
        <link>https://paragraph.com/@lindaxie</link>
        <description>undefined</description>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 06:01:26 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <docs>https://validator.w3.org/feed/docs/rss2.html</docs>
        <generator>https://github.com/jpmonette/feed</generator>
        <language>en</language>
        
        <copyright>All rights reserved</copyright>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Experiments in DAO governance]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@lindaxie/experiments-in-dao-governance</link>
            <guid>i9ZCR27cVtbPI2t2FwZ2</guid>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Dec 2022 19:51:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[This piece was co-authored with Derek Hsue and cross-posted here.IntroductionCrypto governance has no shortage of worthwhile proposals and discussions. Across all categories of DAOs, there are interesting case studies around how protocols design governance processes, as well as proposals on DAO vendor selection, protocol economics, and more. Crypto governance mechanisms are still nascent, and it is one of the most active areas of innovation. In this piece, we’ll explore several governance exp...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This piece was co-authored with <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/derek_hsue">Derek Hsue</a> and cross-posted <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.reverie.ooo/post/experiments-in-dao-governance">here</a>.</p><h2 id="h-introduction" class="text-3xl font-header !mt-8 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Introduction</h2><p>Crypto governance has no shortage of worthwhile proposals and discussions. Across all categories of DAOs, there are interesting case studies around how protocols design governance processes, as well as proposals on DAO vendor selection, protocol economics, and more. Crypto governance mechanisms are still nascent, and it is one of the most active areas of innovation. In this piece, we’ll explore several governance experiments worth paying attention to and summarize key takeaways from each of them.</p><h2 id="h-experiments-in-dao-governance-meta-design-and-process" class="text-3xl font-header !mt-8 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Experiments in DAO governance meta-design and process</h2><p>For any protocol to succeed and reach scale, various stakeholders should have input into the protocol design and direction. Most protocols today are designed as one token one vote, which is a simple but incomplete method. For reasons that are described well by Vitalik <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/08/16/voting3.html">here</a>, pure token holder voting systems can lead to inequalities, incentive misalignments, and potential attacks through vote buying. Designing sustainable, scaleable governance systems for all stakeholders is no simple task, but there are various approaches as outlined below.</p><h3 id="h-optimism-bicameral-governance-system" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Optimism bicameral governance system</h3><p>Optimism <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/optimismFND/status/1519001562345005057">launched</a> the Optimism Collective in April 2022 to create a decentralized ecosystem and experiment with governance. For background, the Optimism Collective is a group of communities, companies, and people supportive of the Optimism ecosystem, stewarded by the Optimism Foundation. While most protocol governance designs have historically involved token governance alone, the Optimism Collective is a bicameral system governed by 2 houses, the Citizens’ House and the Token House.</p><p>The Token House votes on project incentives, protocol upgrades, and manages the treasury fund. The Token House was established by the first Optimism token airdrop (out of many future ones), which distributed tokens to thousands of people who have engaged in “positive-sum, community-oriented behavior” such as donating to Gitcoin grants and voting in DAOs.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/ae17594e04273a4b1f1d927fa50bc51245ed5c6e57a25838296aa851ed7f839d.jpg" alt="" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="hide-figcaption"></figcaption></figure><p>The Citizens’ House focuses on distributing <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://medium.com/ethereum-optimism/retroactive-public-goods-funding-33c9b7d00f0c">retroactive public goods funding</a>, generated from revenue collected by the Optimism network. Citizenship is granted by non-transferable tokens and will be allocated to a growing number of citizens over time. This ensures Optimism is represented by a broad set of ecosystem participants (not just token holders) and that Optimism governance won’t be driven by a plutocratic system.</p><h3 id="h-element-dynamic-governance-council" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Element dynamic governance council</h3><p>Element <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://mirror.xyz/0x3fcAf7DDf64E6e109B1e2A5CC17875D4a5993F39/bctuLRkf7oBL4mMJ9lPf0y0blFjBDslTUfUL0CEk1gc">launched</a> its DAO in March 2022 as part of its decentralization roadmap. Tokens were distributed to Element community members, Ethereum Core developers, and DeFi ecosystem projects.</p><p>Element created a Governance Steering Council (<a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://medium.com/element-finance/the-governance-steering-council-63aea7732262">GSC</a>) with additional governance powers and responsibilities. Membership is made up of members with at least 110k tokens or 0.9% of the circulating supply delegated to them. The membership threshold is run on a continuous, rolling basis so the GSC is always open to anyone who receives enough delegation. Council membership is dynamic on a block-to-block basis, meaning that delegated votes can change at any time, resulting in changes to membership. This keeps council members accountable to community members and helps ensure they vote in their best interests.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/6c8195c2af67d8611de20db4e1e20e689c59024a27ce04ddccafcfe146f85394.png" alt="" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="hide-figcaption"></figcaption></figure><p>Overall, the GSC is an effort to address the lack of governance participation by allowing users to select representatives they align with. However, each GSC member only has one vote and token holder votes can override the GSC members at any time to maintain a balance so that the largest token holders don’t have the most controlling power.</p><h3 id="h-lidos-dual-governance-structure" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Lido’s dual governance structure</h3><p>Lido’s dual <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://research.lido.fi/t/ldo-steth-dual-governance/2382">LDO + stETH governance structure</a> is a novel attempt at implementing formal checks and balances in governance.</p><p>In a coin voting governance system, token holders are the only direct input into governance and can have excess impact on decisions. Other stakeholders risk being disenfranchised and subject to the whims of tokenholders. Lido’s dual LDO + stETH governance structure aims to address these concerns - it allows stETH holders staking on Lido to “veto” certain governance decisions. The scope of what stETH holders can veto is based on the downside severity of potential attacks. This includes things like protocol upgrades, mint/burns of LDO, protocol fees, and managing the node operator set.</p><p>This essentially creates a “check” on LDO holders’ governance power and ensures multiple protocol stakeholders have direct input into the governance process.</p><p>Dual stETH Governance is not live yet, as key parameters around scope and veto rules are still being discussed. Upon launching, it will be a valuable case study on how to create a governance structure that represents and allows for formal input from multiple sets of stakeholders.</p><h3 id="h-ens-metropolis-pods" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">ENS Metropolis pods</h3><p>One of the major issues with scaling DAO governance is the difficulty in keeping up with everything happening in the DAO. The amount of information and overhead required to vote on routine decisions is large. Similarly, delegates don’t need to be involved in all aspects of day-to-day DAO operations either. Delegates won’t be an expert in every topic from finance to technical development to economic design and might not care about reviewing highly specific details. It is more efficient to establish smaller specialized groups that can focus on a specific area.</p><p>For example, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://blog.metropolis.space/how-ens-dao-brought-working-groups-on-chain/">ENS DAO</a> has been working with Metropolis (formerly known as Orca), a DAO implementation that specifically focuses on enabling small working groups called pods. Each pod can specialize in a specific area such as DAO operations, protocol improvements, community, and public goods.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/d3d1d9be0716c51d9fbc3443f588c085668a37111d7a4e6764537703e5916352.png" alt="" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="hide-figcaption"></figcaption></figure><p>Access to pods is authorized through membership NFTs which can be revoked and allows for rotating out old members and rotating in new members. Token holders can delegate their votes (or even specific smart contract permissions) to a group address but members within that group can change over time. Each pod can also create subpods to delegate the workload further.</p><h3 id="h-nouns-community-led-experiments" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Nouns community-led experiments</h3><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://nouns.wtf/">Nouns</a> is a DAO with a daily auction of a generative NFT, with all proceeds going to a central treasury controlled by NFT holders. It has a rich ecosystem of experiments funded by the protocol treasury and stands out for the breadth of initiatives it funds. A few worth highlighting include Prop House, Nouns Builder, and Agora.</p><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://prop.house/">Prop House</a> is an open bounty system to build and fund new NounsDAO project proposals. While many protocols have grant programs, Prop House stands out for the range of things it funds - from large murals and consumer goods, to developer tooling, new front-ends, and MEV bots. Nouns is notable for the enormous range and scope of things it funds, and Prop House is at the center of this dynamic.</p><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://nouns.build/">Nouns Builder</a> is a new tool created by Zora to allow anyone to replicate the Nouns auction dynamic. It’s a simple no-code tool and lowers the costs of creating and scaling a DAO. Nouns Builder helps proliferate the daily auction mechanism, and essentially “productizes” some of the key innovation that has helped Nouns grow in the first place. Nouns’ daily auction mechanism is an important primitive for increasing distribution and engagement, and allowing others to use it easily is valuable.</p><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.nounsagora.com/">Agora</a> is a delegation tool that allows Nouns holders to have granular control over how to use and distribute their governance rights. It has some notable features including:</p><ul><li><p>Full Delegate Visibility: All voting track records and reasoning behind the vote is shown.</p></li><li><p>Liquid Delegation: Allows token holders to distribute their voting power in a modular way, letting certain delegates vote on a certain class of decisions while reserving other decisions for separate delegates.</p></li><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://prop.house/nouns/agora-delegate-race">Delegate Race</a>: Recurring competitions to allocate voting power to the most upvoted delegates.</p></li></ul><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/f78f2d26a22eeac25e3b6ab17be15a279b4773b81fb8ee1d6dae5c279374a9b4.png" alt="" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="hide-figcaption"></figcaption></figure><p>Overall, Nouns represents one of the most exciting and innovative projects in crypto governance. It is very likely that more primitives and tooling built for Nouns will proliferate and influence how other protocols build and scale their governance platforms.</p><h2 id="h-noteworthy-dao-governance-proposals" class="text-3xl font-header !mt-8 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Noteworthy DAO Governance Proposals</h2><p>DAO governance has no shortage of proposals containing debate and drama. From vendor selection proposals, to protocol vision and roadmap proposals, to protocol economics, there are a myriad of examples to go through.</p><h3 id="h-atom-20" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">ATOM 2.0</h3><p>Every protocol goes through a “hero’s journey” of understanding what its core mission is, and how to capture value in doing so. It took Bitcoin ~10 years to decide on a vision of “Digital Gold,” but not before considering <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://medium.com/@nic__carter/visions-of-bitcoin-4b7b7cbcd24c">other paths</a> such as “digital cash” or “payments network.” Ethereum has also considered many different paths, including “World Computer, “fundraising platform” “DeFi,” and “DAOs.”</p><p>Cosmos is no different - it has undergone many discussions on its long-term purpose and vision. The most recent effort, the <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://forum.cosmos.network/t/proposal-82-rejected-atom-2-0-a-new-vision-for-cosmos-hub/7328">ATOM 2.0 initiative</a>, is a collaboration between many stakeholders within the Cosmos ecosystem to create a unified vision for the Cosmos Hub.</p><p>The main purpose of this initiative is to give the Cosmos Hub a way to create value for the ecosystem and capture it for ATOM holders. This is done through a few specific concepts, including interchain security, liquid staking, an interchain scheduler, and an allocator module. Together, these ideas allow the ATOM Hub to provide security, funding, and support for other application chains. Protocols such as USDC, Neutron, and others plan on launching and using some of the key ideas laid out in the paper.</p><p>The <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.mintscan.io/cosmos/proposals/82">ATOM 2.0 proposal </a>ultimately did not pass, as some community members did not agree with all components of the paper, especially those around economic policy and token allocation. Nonetheless, discussion continues on how to best move forward, and many of the ideas laid out are still being carried through. Overall, the ATOM 2.0 initiative is a valuable case study on how protocols coalesce on a unified vision and focus.</p><h3 id="h-osmosis-bridge-selection" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Osmosis Bridge Selection</h3><p>The Osmosis bridge selection process was a unique way for a DAO to conduct vendor selection. For background, Osmosis is a decentralized exchange that provides access to assets on all chains, starting with Cosmos. It became essential to enable Osmosis users to trade EVM assets, and doing so would require integrating EVM to Cosmos bridge providers. For UX and engineering reasons, the community decided that selecting a single canonical bridge provider was optimal, as opposed to integrating multiple.</p><p>Picking a single canonical provider required a vendor bake-off that compared the bridge providers on various axes - UX, security, execution, and reputation. Four bridges participated in this bake-off: Axelar, Wormhole, Nomad, and Gravity. These debates took place over Community Calls, AMAs, Twitter Spaces, and other public venues.</p><p>The final choice was left to the DAO itself, with the voting <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://gov.osmosis.zone/discussion/4482-osmosis-canonical-ethereum-bridge-proposals">process</a> taking place via a series of on-chain governance proposals. All four bridge options created a proposal, with the proposal with the most “YES” votes being selected. Axelar ended up winning the final vote, and today remains the canonical bridge for EVM chains to Osmosis. Many more protocols will need to work with external partners, and the Osmosis Bridge Selection process remains an interesting case study to analyze.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/3039c0510e20e1f42baefd0e9e19addec090a476f3a62f465ad1b2a3a694eb7c.png" alt="" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="hide-figcaption"></figcaption></figure><h3 id="h-fei-and-rari-dao-merger" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Fei and Rari DAO merger</h3><p>Fei and Rari Capital <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://thedefiant.io/rari-capital-fei-merger">merged</a> in Dec 2021, becoming the largest DAO merger seen to date. Both communities voted to allow Rari Capital’s RGT tokens to be converted to Fei’s governance token TRIBE, at a rate of ~26.7 TRIBE per RGT. Token holders that did not agree with the merger were given an opportunity to exit or “ragequit” so that the remaining token holders would be aligned. While there ended up being issues with the merger such as a debate over compensation involving a Rari Capital hack as well as Tribe DAO itself <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://tribe.fei.money/t/tip-121-proposal-for-the-future-of-the-tribe-dao/4475">shutting down</a>, it is an interesting experiment of how protocols can merge.</p><h3 id="h-uniswap-fees" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Uniswap fees</h3><p>There has been significant discussion around whether or not to turn on a “fee switch” for Uniswap which would lead to a portion of the fees being retained by the Uniswap protocol. Uniswap community members <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://gov.uniswap.org/t/consensus-check-fee-switch-pilot/17384">proposed</a> turning on this fee switch in a testing capacity that would be among a limited set of 3 pools for 120 days.</p><p>The proposal was <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://snapshot.org/#/uniswap/proposal/0xe9f8e5dd7ec26f7c0e7dd9e19bb8d57497d27d4a74be01cd3cad159cf3901b7f">supported</a> by an overwhelming majority during a consensus check conducted in Aug 2022. Given Uniswap’s important role in the DeFi ecosystem, the experiment results will likely help guide other projects in discussions around whether or not they should vote in ways for the protocol and community to be able to earn from fees and accrue value.</p><h3 id="h-gitcoin-company-to-dao" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Gitcoin company to DAO</h3><p>Gitcoin DAO launched in May 2021 and the original company behind building Gitcoin, Gitcoin Holdings, intended to <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://gov.gitcoin.co/t/passing-the-torch/10971">pass the torch</a> over time to further decentralize the project. Gitcoin DAO passed a <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://gov.gitcoin.co/t/proposal-the-gitcoin-foundation-a-proposal-to-represent-the-gitcoin-dao-irl-by-a-cayman-islands-foundation/9983">proposal</a> in March 2022 to transfer the ownership of Gitcoin Holdings’ assets (domains, code repositories, trademarks, social media accounts) to the Gitcoin Foundation.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/34615212158729c5eb75ab43f39c0b872831602a21cfcaba25ebb5e63fef89b2.png" alt="" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="hide-figcaption"></figcaption></figure><p>Employees who were part of Gitcoin Holdings subsequently submitted proposals to Gitcoin DAO to join the DAO as an official working group. For example, the Gitcoin Product Collective team which focused on building key products in the ecosystem under Gitcoin Holdings <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://gov.gitcoin.co/t/s15-proposal-gitcoin-product-collective-workstream-proposal-budget-request/11058">requested</a> to formally enter the DAO as a workstream and receive funding for their work which was voted in by Gitcoin DAO.</p><h2 id="h-conclusion" class="text-3xl font-header !mt-8 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Conclusion</h2><p>Decision-making across thousands of tokenholders is no easy task. Crypto governance is still very early and has <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.reverie.ooo/post/musings-on-governance">room to improve</a> across many facets, including <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.reverie.ooo/post/spending-money-well">resource allocation</a>, checks and balances, and distribution of power.</p><p>There’s no panacea today, but tracking experiments across the ecosystem can help shed some lessons for the next iteration of protocol governance. We hope this synopsis provides a resource for protocol operators aiming to launch, bootstrap, and operate their governance process efficiently.</p><p><em>Thanks to </em><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/lsukernik"><em>Larry</em></a><em>, </em><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://mobile.twitter.com/c__bergz"><em>Carl</em></a><em>, </em><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/fededaffina"><em>Fed</em></a><em>, </em><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/MylesOneil"><em>Myles</em></a><em>, </em><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/getty_hill"><em>Getty Hill</em></a><em>, </em><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/jcliff42"><em>Jordan Clifford</em></a><em>, </em><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/chaserchapman"><em>Chase Chapman</em></a><em>, </em><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/kbw"><em>Kyle Weiss</em></a><em>, and </em><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/lay2000lbs"><em>Leighton Cusack</em></a><em> for reviewing and giving feedback on this post.</em></p><p><em>Disclaimer: Scalar Capital is an investor in Optimism, Gitcoin, Element, and Metropolis.</em></p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>lindaxie@newsletter.paragraph.com (Linda Xie)</author>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Key learnings from DAOs]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@lindaxie/key-learnings-from-daos</link>
            <guid>Sf8f5Ko5U9zKvFKBwrui</guid>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 May 2022 20:34:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[A decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) is a group organized around a specific mission that coordinates through a shared set of rules enforced on a blockchain. DAOs themselves are just organizational structures that control shared economic resources and/or protocol rules, and each DAO can be different in how it operates. Some DAOs are private and others are open for anyone to join and contribute. For some DAOs, active contributors can get paid by the DAO for their work. DAOs have been o...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) is a group organized around a specific mission that coordinates through a shared set of rules enforced on a blockchain. DAOs themselves are just organizational structures that control shared economic resources and/or protocol rules, and each DAO can be different in how it operates. Some DAOs are private and others are open for anyone to join and contribute. For some DAOs, active contributors can get paid by the DAO for their work.</p><p>DAOs have been one of my favorite spaces in crypto to spend time in. The ability for people all over the world to come together to build towards a shared mission is exciting, especially when that same group could never have been formed under a traditional company due to various arbitrary barriers (e.g. location, age, part-time, non-traditional education/work experience). For more info on the potential of DAOs, please see my <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://linda.mirror.xyz/Vh8K4leCGEO06_qSGx-vS5lvgUqhqkCz9ut81WwCP2o">beginner’s guide to DAOs</a>.</p><p>This post covers some of my key takeaways from working with DAOs. Most of my experience has been as a delegate for Gitcoin DAO but I’ve also participated in and observed many others. There’s no perfect DAO structure and each one has its own culture so what works for one DAO won’t necessarily work for another. The following reflects my personal experience and perspective and other people might have a different one. The entire space is also constantly iterating to find out what works and what doesn’t.</p><p><strong><em>When initially starting a DAO:</em></strong></p><ul><li><p><strong>Establish a clear mission</strong>. This is critical to keep a diverse and ever-evolving community aligned over time and guide decision-making. If someone comes to the DAO with a funding proposal that is out of scope, it should be an easy no. If the DAO’s priorities aren’t clear, it will be much more challenging to keep the group focused on progressing toward the mission.</p></li><li><p><strong>Consider progressive decentralization</strong>. While the intention of many DAOs is to fully decentralize operations and decision-making, dropping a community into a DAO structure without guidance or leadership will often result in a lack of effective coordination. The founding team almost always has the most context and will ideally set the course for the DAO to progressively empower the broader community over time.</p><p>For example, the newly formed <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://gov.optimism.io/t/working-constitution-of-the-optimism-collective/55">Optimism Collective</a> has a working constitution that defines the Optimism Foundation’s role as a steward early on and how the Foundation will help guide the collective with plans to increasingly decentralize its role over time.</p></li></ul><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/36ae6aa4ad5dbbdffe919a4ad738a538dbe0f70ab3b2301e7f41995ae8a62334.png" alt="Section of Optimism Collective working constitution" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Section of Optimism Collective working constitution</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Operations:</em></strong></p><ul><li><p><strong>Smaller working groups are more efficient</strong>. It should not be the case that all DAO members vote on every decision needed in the DAO. It’s impossible to try to keep up with everything and it’s not the best use of everyone’s time, especially as the DAO scales. For this reason, I like the delegate model as seen with DAOs like Gitcoin and ENS, which allow token holders to delegate their votes to a person or group that is able to dedicate the time needed to make informed decisions.</p><p>Similarly, delegates don’t need to be involved in all aspects of day-to-day DAO operations either. Delegates won’t be an expert in every topic from finance to technical development to economic design and might not care about reviewing highly specific details. It is more efficient to establish smaller specialized groups that can focus on a specific area.</p><p>For example, each quarter in Gitcoin DAO, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/AnnikaSays/status/1524120164522131456">working groups</a> share what they accomplished in the past quarter and the budget they need for the next quarter to then be voted on by delegates. <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/OrcaProtocol/status/1517568136173834255">ENS DAO</a> has been working with <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.orcaprotocol.org/">Orca</a> which is a DAO implementation that specifically focuses on enabling small working groups called pods. Another example is <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://docs.aave.com/developers/getting-started/readme">Aave V3</a> which lets whitelisted addresses update parameters without having to go through a governance vote. However, governance will have the ability to revoke these whitelisted addresses or add new ones.</p></li></ul><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/b258a5be8e586cf04eaa1d3ce93c3d86c43676f290f21977f078151ea2f6fbe4.jpg" alt="Gitcoin DAO workstreams requesting a budget (image credit: Annika Lewis)" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Gitcoin DAO workstreams requesting a budget (image credit: Annika Lewis)</figcaption></figure><ul><li><p><strong>Explore ways to establish accountability</strong>. It is important to account for how involved each delegate and working group contributor is. In Gitcoin DAO, one attempt to measure delegate engagement is with <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://stewards.eth.limo/">Steward Health Cards</a> which measure things like voting activity and forum participation. Gitcoin DAO is in the <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://gov.gitcoin.co/t/introducing-steward-health-cards-2-0/10418/4?u=linda">process</a> of building Workstream Health Cards and has also started quantifying DAO contributions so that some of the workstream contributors can work their way into becoming top delegates through engagement and participation in the DAO. These metrics should be refined over time so that it’s not gameable and doesn’t encourage the wrong behavior such as voting just for the sake of voting regardless of knowledge or expertise.</p><p>Delegate metrics can be helpful for members who are deciding where to delegate their votes. Sometimes people might just delegate to someone they recognize but that might not actually be an active delegate. I’m also very open to the idea of delegate election cycles which can be a way for people to phase out of the DAO when it’s no longer something they want to work on and keeps delegates thinking about if the DAO is something they want to continue to commit their time to.</p></li></ul><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/9e3108ac4ea0e05d8b19b2ab56550517125a800bf0625fa2c1819771f6e5a773.png" alt="Gitcoin DAO Steward Health Cards" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Gitcoin DAO Steward Health Cards</figcaption></figure><ul><li><p><strong>Discuss compensation structures</strong>. There should be an open discussion regarding compensation structures when a significant work commitment is required from members or delegates. Not everyone can afford to work part-time on a DAO for free so they should be compensated for their work. In a delegate model, I believe all major delegates should be compensated for the gas they spend on voting and submitting on-chain proposals, at a minimum. This gives every delegate an equal opportunity to participate. Ideally, the DAO would also work towards standardizing compensation so that the DAO is not drastically underpaying or overpaying.</p></li><li><p><strong>Set the DAO up for long-term sustainability</strong>. Consider diversifying the DAO treasury whether it’s a public round or private movement of funds into more stable assets like USDC or DAI (example of Forefront’s public <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://snapshot.org/#/ffdao.eth/proposal/QmTqgWB7w372zStj45QkqZu6HtXP2NpzDamsoDAq8u25zV">treasury diversification</a> round). Crypto is a volatile space and, no different than a company, it’s important to make sure that the DAO can operate for the long run. Be stringent on what expenses are paid from the DAO especially if it’s a recurring expense and there is no clear replenishment of funds.</p></li></ul><p><strong><em>Culture:</em></strong></p><ul><li><p><strong>Foster a culture of being comfortable saying no and having tough conversations</strong>. Since there is no CEO who is the ultimate decision-maker and is able to quickly say no to things that don’t align with the company goals, DAO members and delegates are responsible for protecting the DAO’s resources (time, attention, treasury). When a DAO treasury is openly available for anyone to make funding proposals, it can quickly get out of control. When you are potentially working with a lot of friends and people you respect, it can be difficult to say no and have tough conversations when requesting resources for certain projects that aren’t in the best interest of the DAO. Help foster a culture early on where everyone knows decisions are being made in the best interest of the DAO and that a no is not personal.</p></li><li><p><strong>Establish structures so members can take breaks</strong>. Crypto being 24/7 and a DAO having async communication from people all over the world, with no break or time off standards, can be exhausting and lead to burnout. Set up ways for members to let others know they are taking time off. For example, Forefront even has a <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://ffdao.notion.site/Forefront-Compensation-3825ebe3f4744204936ebe081c03b288">DAO-bbatical</a> (sabbatical) as part of their compensation so that after 3 years full-time with Forefront, contributors get a paid leave of up to 6 months for rest, travel, research and/or acquisition of new skills or training. In a delegate model, it would be ideal if there was liquid voting so that delegates themselves could delegate votes to others if they are not active for a period of time (or if it’s just not their expertise and wouldn’t be the best use of their time). This is no different than having a colleague take over someone’s work at a company while they are on vacation.</p></li><li><p><strong>Experiment early on</strong>. Experiment with different systems and processes to see what works well for the DAO and what doesn’t. Early on it’s okay to experiment as long as it’s communicated transparently. The larger the DAO gets, the more difficult it is to experiment, change or introduce processes. One area which might be interesting to explore is the governance legos from <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/element_fi/status/1492203186874114053">Element voting vaults</a> which enable use cases such as giving voting power to Github contributors or allowing members to vote who are staking or providing liquidity on their tokens.</p></li></ul><p>Thanks to <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/willwarren">Will Warren</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/jcliff42">Jordan Clifford</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/Sim_Pop">Simona Pop</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/notscottmoore">Scott Moore</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/derek_hsue">Derek Hsue</a>, and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/JulzRoze">Julia Rosenberg</a> for reviewing this post.</p><p><em>Disclaimer: Scalar Capital is an investor in Gitcoin, Element, Optimism, Forefront, and Orca. This post is not investment advice.</em></p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>lindaxie@newsletter.paragraph.com (Linda Xie)</author>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A beginner's guide to social tokens]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@lindaxie/a-beginner-s-guide-to-social-tokens-2</link>
            <guid>hyrC21YFLBGQtwpYto24</guid>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Nov 2021 17:25:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[What are social tokens?Social tokens are tokens issued by individual creators or communities that enable community members to collaborate and share ownership in the value created together. Social tokens can be earned as rewards for contributing to the group and can be used for purposes such as granting access to a chat group or voting on community decisions. “Social token” is a broad term that encompasses personal tokens (formed around an individual), community tokens (formed around a communi...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3 id="h-what-are-social-tokens" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">What are social tokens?</h3><p>Social tokens are tokens issued by individual creators or communities that enable community members to collaborate and share ownership in the value created together. Social tokens can be earned as rewards for contributing to the group and can be used for purposes such as granting access to a chat group or voting on community decisions. “Social token” is a broad term that encompasses personal tokens (formed around an individual), community tokens (formed around a community), and creator tokens (formed around a creator).</p><p>Sometimes social tokens are associated with <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://linda.mirror.xyz/df649d61efb92c910464a4e74ae213c4cab150b9cbcc4b7fb6090fc77881a95d">non-fungible tokens (NFTs)</a>, which exploded in popularity in 2021. NFTs are unique assets that are represented as a token such as a digital art piece or a plot of virtual land. While NFTs are “non-fungible” meaning that each item is unique, social tokens are “fungible” meaning that each individual token can be exchanged for another of the same token. For example, a $1 bill is fungible as it is easily tradable for another $1 bill. Strong communities can form around both NFTs and social tokens. For example, with the NFT collectibles <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.larvalabs.com/cryptopunks">CryptoPunks</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://boredapeyachtclub.com/#/">Bored Ape Yacht Club</a>, and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.stonercats.com/">Stoner Cats</a>, each project has members that own the individual NFTs but are also part of the wider community. And a single community can make use of both social tokens and NFTs such as using social tokens to make governance decisions and NFTs to reward contributors.</p><p>Social tokens are also often associated with <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://linda.mirror.xyz/Vh8K4leCGEO06_qSGx-vS5lvgUqhqkCz9ut81WwCP2o">decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs)</a>, which are groups organized around a mission that coordinate through a shared set of rules enforced on a blockchain. Social tokens can be used for governance over a DAO, but they do not have to be. There can be cases where a social token is only used for non-governance purposes like rewarding supporters with early access to merchandise or exclusive opportunities.</p><h3 id="h-examples" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Examples</h3><p>Social tokens can be used to represent a wide range of access rights, from a person’s time, access to an exclusive group, or partial ownership of a community treasury. Their use cases can also evolve, with more features added over time.</p><p>Some of the earliest social token experiments involved “personal tokens” where an individual with a unique skill set tokenized blocks of their time. For example, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://mobile.twitter.com/bramanathan/status/1220739081946034176">Reuben Bramanathan</a> and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/dApp_boi/status/1088656981307445250">Matthew Vernon (dApp_boi)</a> both tokenized blocks of their time where one unit of the associated token could be redeemed for one hour of consultation in their respective areas of expertise and these tokens could be freely traded in the open market.</p><p>There were also personal tokens designed to behave like tokenized Income Sharing Agreements (ISAs), where individuals tokenized the rights to a percentage of their future income. <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/AlexMasmej/status/1202286736627453953?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1202286736627453953%7Ctwgr%5E%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&amp;ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Ftryroll.com%2Falexmasmej-open-community-uniswap%2F">Alex Masmej</a> was one of the first people to create a social token with this type of structure. Another early social token was issued by the Grammy award-winning recording artist <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/rac/status/1311395812279087104?lang=en">RAC</a>, which gave token holders access to a private Discord group and early access to exclusive merchandise drops. The RAC token was retroactively distributed to Bandcamp and Patreon supporters as well as supporters who had previously bought RAC merchandise. This allowed RAC to directly interact with and reward early supporters.</p><p>We have also seen the emergence of decentralized organizations formed around communities with a specific mission, such as <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.notion.so/Mission-Vision-and-Values-05d66a9089d643d4981ffcad9e446163">BanklessDAO</a>, which aims to create user-friendly onramps for people to discover decentralized finance through education, media, and culture.</p><p>Another popular social token is <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.fwb.help/">Friends with Benefits (FWB)</a>, which is a community of Web3 artists, operators, and thinkers. To join the FWB Discord chat, one must have a minimum number of FWB tokens and submit a short application to demonstrate commitment to the community’s success. The FWB token also provides governance rights to influence the allocation of the FWB community treasury. The FWB community has even held in-person events that require proof of token ownership.</p><p>WHALE is a prominent social token that is backed by high-value NFTs that include digital art, blockchain gaming, virtual real estate, and others. Token holders gain access to exclusive membership channels, NFT airdrops, and networking opportunities. The WHALE and FWB communities decided to align with each other by completing a <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://fwb.mirror.xyz/9DCOelQSQVlBgqy4lKAa3CGq0N_ckECsuRp6CJeRnrg">token swap</a> of 7,900 FWB for 4,380 WHALE.</p><p>Another community, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://forefront.market/">Forefront</a>, which specializes in social token content and has its own social token called FF, has a great <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://forefront.market/creators">overview</a> of major social token projects.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/ea02962b5a69ec0aba44418208f2d0cd167a49ebe7ec013c73fd715a95537768.png" alt="Forefront profiles page covering popular social tokens" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Forefront profiles page covering popular social tokens</figcaption></figure><p>BanklessDAO, FWB, Forefront, and many other communities have introduced the concept of “seasons” which are periods of time where the group focuses on a certain set of goals, and members who are active and contribute towards those goals are given rewards exclusive to that season. This keeps everyone rallied together and aligned on an objective.</p><p>An example of a social token in the traditional tech space is Reddit’s <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.reddit.com/community-points/">Community Points</a>, which are Ethereum-based tokens that are used to reward users for posting high-quality content, and that can be redeemed for unique items like badges that confer social status within the subreddit community and can affect voting weights in polls. This feature is being tested in the r/CryptoCurrency (points are called <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/gj96lb/introducing_rcryptocurrency_moons/">Moons</a>) and r/FortNiteBR (points are called <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.reddit.com/r/FortNiteBR/comments/gj8tm1/introducing_rfortnitebr_bricks/">Bricks</a>) subreddits, which each have millions of subscribers.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/a35895804900f79db56227bf03942bf9b6a33179002431ec0f68774de4177b1d.png" alt="Subreddit leaderboard of top community points earners" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Subreddit leaderboard of top community points earners</figcaption></figure><h3 id="h-social-token-tools" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Social Token Tools</h3><p>We’ve seen influential figures across all areas from music to sports issue social tokens. There are a number of social token issuers that make it easy for creators and communities to mint their own tokens such as <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.coinvise.co/">Coinvise</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://rally.io/">Rally</a>, and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://tryroll.com/">Roll</a>. These platforms also have features that enable social token issuers to distribute tokens to their community and adjust specific parameters like token vesting schedules.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/74ca09e9f54100f1cc9cf1c05526831ac230e4998e5755b38e012e2473deefd2.png" alt="Coinvise dashboard for issuing a social token" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Coinvise dashboard for issuing a social token</figcaption></figure><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://mirror.xyz/">Mirror</a>, a decentralized publishing platform, also enables writers and creators to issue both NFTs and social tokens as part of a crowdfund through their platform.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/b19302e42cd5f0293e66e4b15b4eb52424f470705f9d4faf3210a6eda0756f58.png" alt="Supporters of Emily Segal’s novel crowdfund on Mirror received NOVEL tokens" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Supporters of Emily Segal’s novel crowdfund on Mirror received NOVEL tokens</figcaption></figure><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://seedclub.xyz/">Seed Club</a> is a DAO that builds, supports, and invests in social token communities.</p><p>One of the tools that has enabled a new wave of social tokens to emerge is <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://collab.land/">Collab.Land</a>, which built a Telegram and Discord bot that connects to an Ethereum wallet to verify each user’s token balance before allowing them to join the chat. This allowed for the creation of token permissioned groups, such as FWB with their native tokens, which helped ensure that those joining the group had a certain level of skin in the game. There are also tools like <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.mintgate.app/">MintGate</a> that enable token gated content and that can be used to generate secret links for things like events, videos, and websites.</p><p>Social token communities can use governance tools like <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://snapshot.org/#/">Snapshot</a> and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.withtally.com/">Tally</a> so that token holders can vote on decisions within the group.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/25b431e0f2e496780a29e0ccd0fa8ceace70be20e0fdcaaf8f6d9665ef51167e.png" alt="Example of a Snapshot governance vote for Friends with Benefits (FWB)" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Example of a Snapshot governance vote for Friends with Benefits (FWB)</figcaption></figure><h3 id="h-risks" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Risks</h3><p>Since a social token can be used to represent all sorts of things, there are legal questions that each creator must consider to ensure their token is compliant with regulatory requirements.</p><p>Even though social tokens are permissionless, meaning anyone can own them, there can still be centralized points of control, which can potentially lead to issues. One <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://thedefiant.io/social-tokens-get-rolled-on/">incident</a> occurred when the social token issuer Roll had a compromise of the private keys for almost $5.7 million of creator tokens. The attacker immediately sold the tokens from creators on the platform which caused a huge decrease in the price of the tokens. This led to the communities having to urgently decide what to do next. Fortunately, community members came together and successfully moved on from the situation. For example, the Friends with Benefits community voted to issue a new FWB token and airdropped the new tokens to existing members to help reset ownership levels. This ended up demonstrating that the communities were able to work together to get past a difficult situation. However, this acted as another reminder that security is critical in the crypto space and that points of centralization can create systemic issues.</p><p>Another risk worth noting is that once a social token is issued and freely traded, it is subject to market fluctuations which can at times be heavily driven by speculation. This can potentially negatively impact a community. It’s important to think through how having a freely traded token can affect community morale and cohesion. There are ways to alleviate this issue such as making tokens non-transferable in the early stages, as the community is forming, as well as introducing long vesting schedules to ensure that community members are long-term aligned.</p><h3 id="h-future" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Future</h3><p>There are a lot of potential use cases for social tokens and I expect many more creators and communities to issue them in the future. Shared ownership of social tokens among community members contributes to long-term value alignment. It is just the beginning when it comes to experimenting with new ways of rewarding community members for their participation and empowering community members through governance. More people will be hired by social token communities in part-time or full-time roles, which will provide an alternative to traditional career paths. Social graphs can be created based on the tokens that individuals hold to help people discover new communities and meet others who share the same interests.</p><p>Finally, we are seeing social tokens flip the fundraising process on its head. We have seen a number of social token communities like FWB and Forefront <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/FWBtweets/status/1453393681415741440">raise</a> <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/forefront__/status/1438522434865356800">capital</a> from traditional VCs where the investors had to pitch the communities on why they should be included in the round. This shifted the power dynamics from the investors to the community and I only expect it to be more common for VCs to have to pitch communities in the future.</p><h3 id="h-resources" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Resources</h3><h4 id="h-understanding-social-tokens" class="text-xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-3 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Understanding social tokens</h4><ul><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://forefront.market/learn">Forefront Learn</a></p></li><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://2020inreview.forefront.news/">Forefront Social Tokens Year in Review</a></p></li><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://coopahtroopa.mirror.xyz/DYSs-mhdJi1uXZTaiyJfwiFZYAF9kRK6yBsAplk6A68">Social Token Refresh</a> by Coopahtroopa and Forefront</p></li></ul><h4 id="h-keeping-up-with-social-tokens" class="text-xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-3 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Keeping up with social tokens</h4><ul><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://forefront.market/newsletter">Forefront newsletter</a></p></li></ul><p>If you want to get in touch about interesting social token ideas or projects, I’m <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/ljxie">@ljxie</a> on Twitter.</p><p>Thanks to <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/willwarren">Will Warren</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/jcliff42">Jordan Clifford</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/carlosecgomes">Carlos</a>, and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/0xjenil">Jenil</a> for reviewing this post.</p><p><em>Disclaimer: Scalar Capital is an investor in Forefront and Coinvise. This post is not investment advice.</em></p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>lindaxie@newsletter.paragraph.com (Linda Xie)</author>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A beginner's guide to social tokens]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@lindaxie/a-beginner-s-guide-to-social-tokens</link>
            <guid>UsdBqeFYjFdtWdYeaywF</guid>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Nov 2021 17:12:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[A beginner&apos;s guide to social tokensWhat are social tokens?Social tokens are tokens issued by individual creators or communities that enable community members to collaborate and share ownership in the value created together. Social tokens can be earned as rewards for contributing to the group and can be used for purposes such as granting access to a chat group or voting on community decisions. “Social token” is a broad term that encompasses personal tokens (formed around an individual), c...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2 id="h-a-beginners-guide-to-social-tokens" class="text-3xl font-header !mt-8 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">A beginner&apos;s guide to social tokens</h2><h3 id="h-what-are-social-tokens" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">What are social tokens?</h3><p>Social tokens are tokens issued by individual creators or communities that enable community members to collaborate and share ownership in the value created together. Social tokens can be earned as rewards for contributing to the group and can be used for purposes such as granting access to a chat group or voting on community decisions. “Social token” is a broad term that encompasses personal tokens (formed around an individual), community tokens (formed around a community), and creator tokens (formed around a creator).</p><p>Sometimes social tokens are associated with <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://linda.mirror.xyz/df649d61efb92c910464a4e74ae213c4cab150b9cbcc4b7fb6090fc77881a95d">non-fungible tokens (NFTs)</a>, which exploded in popularity in 2021. NFTs are unique assets that are represented as a token such as a digital art piece or a plot of virtual land. While NFTs are “non-fungible” meaning that each item is unique, social tokens are “fungible” meaning that each individual token can be exchanged for another of the same token. For example, a $1 bill is fungible as it is easily tradable for another $1 bill. Strong communities can form around both NFTs and social tokens. For example, with the NFT collectibles <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.larvalabs.com/cryptopunks">CryptoPunks</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://boredapeyachtclub.com/#/">Bored Ape Yacht Club</a>, and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.stonercats.com/">Stoner Cats</a>, each project has members that own the individual NFTs but are also part of the wider community. And a single community can make use of both social tokens and NFTs such as using social tokens to make governance decisions and NFTs to reward contributors.</p><p>Social tokens are also often associated with <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://linda.mirror.xyz/Vh8K4leCGEO06_qSGx-vS5lvgUqhqkCz9ut81WwCP2o">decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs)</a>, which are groups organized around a mission that coordinate through a shared set of rules enforced on a blockchain. Social tokens can be used for governance over a DAO, but they do not have to be. There can be cases where a social token is only used for non-governance purposes like rewarding supporters with early access to merchandise or exclusive opportunities.</p><h3 id="h-examples" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Examples</h3><p>Social tokens can be used to represent a wide range of access rights, from a person’s time, access to an exclusive group, or partial ownership of a community treasury. Their use cases can also evolve, with more features added over time.</p><p>Some of the earliest social token experiments involved “personal tokens” where an individual with a unique skill set tokenized blocks of their time. For example, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://mobile.twitter.com/bramanathan/status/1220739081946034176">Reuben Bramanathan</a> and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/dApp_boi/status/1088656981307445250">Matthew Vernon (dApp_boi)</a> both tokenized blocks of their time where one unit of the associated token could be redeemed for one hour of consultation in their respective areas of expertise and these tokens could be freely traded in the open market. </p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/8716d7073a33884447216ea88145e9ce9c5115f9c4a96ddc86f9631ed20d46be.png" alt="dApp_boi BOI tokens and what they could be redeemed for (1 BOI = 1 hour of design work)" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">dApp_boi BOI tokens and what they could be redeemed for (1 BOI = 1 hour of design work)</figcaption></figure><p>There were also personal tokens designed to behave like tokenized Income Sharing Agreements (ISAs), where individuals tokenized the rights to a percentage of their future income. <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/AlexMasmej/status/1202286736627453953?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1202286736627453953%7Ctwgr%5E%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&amp;ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Ftryroll.com%2Falexmasmej-open-community-uniswap%2F">Alex Masmej</a> was one of the first people to create a social token with this type of structure. Another early social token was issued by the Grammy award-winning recording artist <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/rac/status/1311395812279087104?lang=en">RAC</a>, which gave token holders access to a private Discord group and early access to exclusive merchandise drops. The RAC token was retroactively distributed to Bandcamp and Patreon supporters as well as supporters who had previously bought RAC merchandise. This allowed RAC to directly interact with and reward early supporters.</p><p>We have also seen the emergence of decentralized organizations formed around communities with a specific mission, such as <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.notion.so/Mission-Vision-and-Values-05d66a9089d643d4981ffcad9e446163">BanklessDAO</a>, which aims to create user-friendly onramps for people to discover decentralized finance through education, media, and culture.</p><p>Another popular social token is <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.fwb.help/">Friends with Benefits (FWB)</a>, which is a community of Web3 artists, operators, and thinkers. To join the FWB Discord chat, one must have a minimum number of FWB tokens and submit a short application to demonstrate commitment to the community’s success. The FWB token also provides governance rights to influence the allocation of the FWB community treasury. The FWB community has even held in-person events that require proof of token ownership.</p><p>WHALE is a prominent social token that is backed by high-value NFTs that include digital art, blockchain gaming, virtual real estate, and others. Token holders gain access to exclusive membership channels, NFT airdrops, and networking opportunities. The WHALE and FWB communities decided to align with each other by completing a <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://fwb.mirror.xyz/9DCOelQSQVlBgqy4lKAa3CGq0N_ckECsuRp6CJeRnrg">token swap</a> of 7,900 FWB for 4,380 WHALE.</p><p>Another community, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://forefront.market/">Forefront</a>, which specializes in social token content and has its own social token called FF, has a great <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://forefront.market/creators">overview</a> of major social token projects.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/ea02962b5a69ec0aba44418208f2d0cd167a49ebe7ec013c73fd715a95537768.png" alt="Forefront profiles page covering popular social tokens" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Forefront profiles page covering popular social tokens</figcaption></figure><p>BanklessDAO, FWB, Forefront, and many other communities have introduced the concept of “seasons” which are periods of time where the group focuses on a certain set of goals, and members who are active and contribute towards those goals are given rewards exclusive to that season. This keeps everyone rallied together and aligned on an objective.</p><p>An example of a social token in the traditional tech space is Reddit’s <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.reddit.com/community-points/">Community Points</a>, which are Ethereum-based tokens that are used to reward users for posting high-quality content, and that can be redeemed for unique items like badges that confer social status within the subreddit community and can affect voting weights in polls. This feature is being tested in the r/CryptoCurrency (points are called <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/gj96lb/introducing_rcryptocurrency_moons/">Moons</a>) and r/FortNiteBR (points are called <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.reddit.com/r/FortNiteBR/comments/gj8tm1/introducing_rfortnitebr_bricks/">Bricks</a>) subreddits, which each have millions of subscribers.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/a35895804900f79db56227bf03942bf9b6a33179002431ec0f68774de4177b1d.png" alt="Subreddit leaderboard of top community points earners" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Subreddit leaderboard of top community points earners</figcaption></figure><h3 id="h-social-token-tools" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Social Token Tools</h3><p>We’ve seen influential figures across all areas from music to sports issue social tokens. There are a number of social token issuers that make it easy for creators and communities to mint their own tokens such as <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.coinvise.co/">Coinvise</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://rally.io/">Rally</a>, and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://tryroll.com/">Roll</a>. These platforms also have features that enable social token issuers to distribute tokens to their community and adjust specific parameters like token vesting schedules. </p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/74ca09e9f54100f1cc9cf1c05526831ac230e4998e5755b38e012e2473deefd2.png" alt="Coinvise dashboard for issuing a social token" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Coinvise dashboard for issuing a social token</figcaption></figure><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://mirror.xyz/">Mirror</a>, a decentralized publishing platform, also enables writers and creators to issue both NFTs and social tokens as part of a crowdfund through their platform. </p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/b19302e42cd5f0293e66e4b15b4eb52424f470705f9d4faf3210a6eda0756f58.png" alt="Supporters of Emily Segal’s novel crowdfund on Mirror received NOVEL tokens" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Supporters of Emily Segal’s novel crowdfund on Mirror received NOVEL tokens</figcaption></figure><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://seedclub.xyz/">Seed Club</a> is a DAO that builds, supports, and invests in social token communities.</p><p>One of the tools that has enabled a new wave of social tokens to emerge is <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://collab.land/">Collab.Land</a>, which built a Telegram and Discord bot that connects to an Ethereum wallet to verify each user’s token balance before allowing them to join the chat. This allowed for the creation of token permissioned groups, such as FWB with their native tokens, which helped ensure that those joining the group had a certain level of skin in the game. There are also tools like <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.mintgate.app/">MintGate</a> that enable token gated content and that can be used to generate secret links for things like events, videos, and websites.</p><p>Social token communities can use governance tools like <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://snapshot.org/#/">Snapshot</a> and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.withtally.com/">Tally</a> so that token holders can vote on decisions within the group.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/25b431e0f2e496780a29e0ccd0fa8ceace70be20e0fdcaaf8f6d9665ef51167e.png" alt="Example of a Snapshot governance vote for Friends with Benefits (FWB)" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Example of a Snapshot governance vote for Friends with Benefits (FWB)</figcaption></figure><h3 id="h-risks" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Risks</h3><p>Since a social token can be used to represent all sorts of things, there are legal questions that each creator must consider to ensure their token is compliant with regulatory requirements.</p><p>Even though social tokens are permissionless, meaning anyone can own them, there can still be centralized points of control, which can potentially lead to issues. One <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://thedefiant.io/social-tokens-get-rolled-on/">incident</a> occurred when the social token issuer Roll had a compromise of the private keys for almost $5.7 million of creator tokens. The attacker immediately sold the tokens from creators on the platform which caused a huge decrease in the price of the tokens. This led to the communities having to urgently decide what to do next. Fortunately, community members came together and successfully moved on from the situation. For example, the Friends with Benefits community voted to issue a new FWB token and airdropped the new tokens to existing members to help reset ownership levels. This ended up demonstrating that the communities were able to work together to get past a difficult situation. However, this acted as another reminder that security is critical in the crypto space and that points of centralization can create systemic issues.</p><p>Another risk worth noting is that once a social token is issued and freely traded, it is subject to market fluctuations which can at times be heavily driven by speculation. This can potentially negatively impact a community. It’s important to think through how having a freely traded token can affect community morale and cohesion. There are ways to alleviate this issue such as making tokens non-transferable in the early stages, as the community is forming, as well as introducing long vesting schedules to ensure that community members are long-term aligned.</p><h3 id="h-future" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Future</h3><p>There are a lot of potential use cases for social tokens and I expect many more creators and communities to issue them in the future. Shared ownership of social tokens among community members contributes to long-term value alignment. It is just the beginning when it comes to experimenting with new ways of rewarding community members for their participation and empowering community members through governance. More people will be hired by social token communities in part-time or full-time roles, which will provide an alternative to traditional career paths. Social graphs can be created based on the tokens that individuals hold to help people discover new communities and meet others who share the same interests. </p><p>Finally, we are seeing social tokens flip the fundraising process on its head. We have seen a number of social token communities like FWB and Forefront <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/FWBtweets/status/1453393681415741440">raise</a> <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/forefront__/status/1438522434865356800">capital</a> from traditional VCs where the investors had to pitch the communities on why they should be included in the round. This shifted the power dynamics from the investors to the community and I only expect it to be more common for VCs to have to pitch communities in the future.</p><h3 id="h-resources" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Resources</h3><h4 id="h-understanding-social-tokens" class="text-xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-3 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Understanding social tokens</h4><ul><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://forefront.market/learn">Forefront Learn</a></p></li><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://2020inreview.forefront.news/">Forefront Social Tokens Year in Review</a></p></li><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://coopahtroopa.mirror.xyz/DYSs-mhdJi1uXZTaiyJfwiFZYAF9kRK6yBsAplk6A68">Social Token Refresh</a> by Coopahtroopa and Forefront</p></li></ul><h4 id="h-keeping-up-with-social-tokens" class="text-xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-3 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Keeping up with social tokens</h4><ul><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://forefront.market/newsletter">Forefront newsletter</a></p></li></ul><p>If you want to get in touch about interesting social token ideas or projects, I’m <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/ljxie">@ljxie</a> on Twitter.</p><p>Thanks to <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/willwarren">Will Warren</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/jcliff42">Jordan Clifford</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/carlosecgomes">Carlos</a>, and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/0xjenil">Jenil</a> for reviewing this post.</p><p><em>Disclaimer: Scalar Capital is an investor in Forefront and Coinvise. This post is not investment advice.</em></p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>lindaxie@newsletter.paragraph.com (Linda Xie)</author>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A beginner’s guide to DAOs]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@lindaxie/a-beginner-s-guide-to-daos</link>
            <guid>7p4GsBM5wfigLy0ayhiI</guid>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Mar 2021 19:36:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[What are DAOs?A decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) is a group organized around a mission that coordinates through a shared set of rules enforced on a blockchain. One of the main benefits of a DAO is that they are more transparent than traditional companies since all actions and funding in the DAO are viewable by anyone. This significantly reduces the risk of corruption and censorship. Publicly traded companies must provide independently audited financial statements, but shareholders ...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3 id="h-what-are-daos" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">What are DAOs?</h3><p>A decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) is a group organized around a mission that coordinates through a shared set of rules enforced on a blockchain.</p><p>One of the main benefits of a DAO is that they are more transparent than traditional companies since all actions and funding in the DAO are viewable by anyone. This significantly reduces the risk of corruption and censorship. Publicly traded companies must provide independently audited financial statements, but shareholders only get to see the financial health of the organization at a snapshot in time. Since a DAO&apos;s balance sheet exists on a public blockchain, it is completely transparent at all times, down to every single transaction.</p><p>DAOs typically are more globally accessible and have lower barriers to entry than companies. Given the transparency and lower barriers to entry, there will likely be lower switching costs for DAO members who don’t agree with the rules and actions. DAOs sharing a similar mission might need to compete for members and are incentivized to be as transparent as possible and not extract too much rent from the group so that they are able to attract top members. DAOs might also need to quickly evolve to meet the members&apos; needs.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/70dad511850f1f8dc7213158a1d2636f577f2164fcfbb80f147dbe6826e1a156.png" alt="DAO vs Company. Source: Aragon" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">DAO vs Company. Source: Aragon</figcaption></figure><p>The goal for this post is not to detail every DAO in crypto, but to give a high level overview of what DAOs are, why they are interesting, and showcase some of their potential use cases.</p><h3 id="h-examples-of-daos" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Examples of DAOs</h3><p>Perhaps the most notorious DAO so far was <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_DAO_(organization)">The DAO</a> which launched in April 2016 as a decentralized venture capital fund. Members contributed ETH and received <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://etherscan.io/token/0xbb9bc244d798123fde783fcc1c72d3bb8c189413">DAO tokens</a> in return that could be used for voting on which projects the funds should be allocated to. It raised $150 million in ETH and was hacked with $60 million stolen. One interesting part is that even though the DAO is now defunct, anyone is still able to see all of the transactions that occurred since it is on a public blockchain and this record will never go away. Unfortunately the DAO hack temporarily left a negative impression or skepticism of the term DAO for many people but DAOs are an extremely powerful form of organizing and it didn’t take long to see a resurgence in DAO activity in the crypto space.</p><p>Crypto projects themselves can be considered DAOs if they are managed by decentralized governance where token holders can vote on the direction of the project or various parameter settings, rather than solely determined by a centralized team. For example, token holders of <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://makerdao.com/en/">MakerDAO</a> building a decentralized stablecoin are able to govern the system and vote on parameters such as fees charged.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/6b9812924e01a8dabe58a4c615fefce5c4eaaf838ce5d6397633fd23a51986a6.png" alt="Example of a MakerDAO executive proposal" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Example of a MakerDAO executive proposal</figcaption></figure><p>Another example is <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.curve.fi/">Curve DAO</a> building an automated market maker (AMM) that generates fees and provides revenue sharing for token holders that lock their tokens. The longer the Curve token (CRV) is locked for, the greater the amount of voting power and rewards received for the DAO member. Unlike traditional companies where profits are paid out pro rata, this DAO is setup such that voting power and revenue share is weighted according to the length of time a token holder has remained invested.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/f2610bfb03a35f6ada9c66e135283abf35045c0d47f112e976598f0687169217.png" alt="Curve DAO" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Curve DAO</figcaption></figure><p>A DAO&apos;s assets can be controlled by stakeholders directly via a token. Stakeholders can be pseudonymous and based anywhere in the world. These pseudonymous stakeholders can come together to allocate a DAO&apos;s assets for anything, including to hire employees. This is something that is happening today. DAOs, consisting of hundreds of known and pseudonymous members, have legitimately hired employees based on community reputation alone. For example the Empty Set Dollar (ESD) DAO is paying a $180,000 salary to its community manager Lewi who said this was the highest salary role of his career. Other blockchains like <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://medium.com/@linda.xie/a-beginners-guide-to-tezos-c9618240183f">Tezos</a> and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://medium.com/@linda.xie/a-beginners-guide-to-decred-2fc61670d67c">Decred</a> have also had this type of system in place for rewarding contributors for their work.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/7b892eba33c728fbd8dd81103f2740f1ea0997dd3514f73dc3fb18fe127173c4.png" alt="" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="hide-figcaption"></figcaption></figure><p>We have seen a number of DAOs created for the purpose of funding investments or grants. <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.molochdao.com/">Moloch DAO</a> is a DAO that awards grants to advance the Ethereum ecosystem. They also allow people to withdraw funds in a “ragequit” if they do not agree with the overall decisions of the DAO. MolochDAO’s contracts have been forked many times to create other DAOs. <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://metacartel.xyz/">MetaCartel Ventures</a> is a for-profit fund that invests in dapps and is an early investor in many prominent crypto projects including Zapper and Rai. Members consist of experienced builders in the crypto community. Similarly, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.thelao.io/">The LAO</a> is another DAO made up of Ethereum enthusiasts that has invested early on in projects including Boardroom and Aavegotchi. MetaCartel Ventures and The LAO are both examples of DAOs that have strong access to deal flow in the crypto ecosystem on par or sometimes even greater than many venture funds as founders want to work with the DAO members and the DAO itself represents the ethos of crypto.</p><p>We’ve also seen DAOs emerge that are catered for more specific investment opportunities such as owning <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://linda.mirror.xyz/df649d61efb92c910464a4e74ae213c4cab150b9cbcc4b7fb6090fc77881a95d">NFT</a> art and virtual gaming items. <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/yieldguild">Yield Guild Games</a> is a play-to-earn gaming guild that is turning gamers into investors by buying NFTs in games like Axie Infinity, League of Kingdoms, and The Sandbox.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/e7b15b5602c7197a3d24d5903b3c67fa997ca216d14613a52f654522ef66d6bd.png" alt="" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="hide-figcaption"></figcaption></figure><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://flamingodao.xyz/">FlamingoDAO</a> is a for-profit, NFT focused DAO. They have been actively investing in NFTs and made <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.coindesk.com/early-cryptopunk-digital-collectible-sells-for-762k-in-ether">news</a> when they paid $762k in ETH for a rare CryptoPunk NFT.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/3ce6e1b77728ac3b8e0a903dc9ed9a3f3173f076521b236e2893ee5f53c2a18c.png" alt="" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="hide-figcaption"></figcaption></figure><p>There are also DAOs that are organized around work such as <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://raidguild.org/">Raid Guild</a> which is a decentralized collective of builders and designers available to work on products in the crypto space and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://metafactory.ai/">MetaFactory</a> organized around fashion and culture that sells products they create.</p><h3 id="h-dao-tools" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">DAO tools</h3><p>There are a number of tools built for creating and coordinating DAOs such as <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://aragon.org/">Aragon</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://daostack.io/">DAOStack</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://daohaus.club/">DAOhaus</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://llama.community/">Llama</a>, and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://myco.space/">MyCo</a> so that members do not have to build everything from scratch.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/25677b198cc5cd1c6de44ed9916c4e1b759b177f7cb88bad5349bb1a5c9bc78e.png" alt="Creating a DAO in DAOhaus" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Creating a DAO in DAOhaus</figcaption></figure><p>There are also tools like <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://snapshot.page/#/">Snapshot</a> that specifically manage proposals for voting by token holders, making it easy to see relevant details of the proposal and the status of the vote.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/6ed8cf244192d00cb1379e9300a96a86f5d3203c954429c4ebf942915a4071c1.png" alt="Snapshot page for a Yearn.finance proposal" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Snapshot page for a Yearn.finance proposal</figcaption></figure><p>There are even projects where you can buy and sell governance votes such as <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://automata.fi/">Automata</a>. This concept can be controversial as it might lead to those with large amounts of capital being able to control the votes but I think the creation of these types of borrowing and lending systems will be inevitable and will only lead projects to harden their governance system.</p><p>On the metrics side there is <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://deepdao.io/#/deepdao/dashboard">Deep DAO</a> for keeping track of the DAO ecosystem. It isn’t necessarily comprehensive but it is interesting to see metrics such as number of members, proposals, and voter participation.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/a7fef312eddad7d7da4ebac0db687c090defb60d8732a4430606f70581c46e90.png" alt="DAO metrics on Deep DAO" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">DAO metrics on Deep DAO</figcaption></figure><h3 id="h-future-use-cases" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Future Use Cases</h3><p>There are a ton of interesting use cases for DAOs and we are only just at the start of the design space. With DAOs, we’ll be able to experiment with governance systems at a rapid pace to quickly improve on what works and what doesn’t. For example, there could be a DAO that uses futarchy for decision making which would consist of members betting in prediction markets and then using the outcome of those markets to determine the action.</p><p>We will also see <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/Flynnjamm/status/1337879523333836800">meta-governance</a> when DAOs themselves serve a number of different protocols and receive governance tokens in return. DAOs will start voting and acting as delegators in other DAOs.</p><p>One possible use case is a DAO where all members are anonymous and can build up reputation in the DAO without having to reveal their identity. This allows members to be on a more even playing field and makes it easier for DAOs to reward individual contributors rather than possibly catering to higher profile members with a large following already.</p><p>Another interesting use case for DAOs is owning collective NFT art where each member can vote on different attributes of a piece of art and have the overall art piece change depending on individual attributes.</p><h3 id="h-potential-issues" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Potential issues</h3><p>DAOs are powerful ways to organize but there may be potential issues with them and they aren’t the ideal system for everything. While DAOs can replace aspects of legal contracts with code and save a tremendous amount of operational overhead, in some cases there are no legal protections outside of the rules outlined by the smart contracts facilitating the DAO. This can create issues if control of the DAO is centralized or vaguely defined, although some DAOs may also form legal entities behind the DAOs themselves. There was also a <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/awrigh01/status/1369328856260354051">Wyoming DAO bill</a> passed through the Wyoming Senate committee that would help with the creation of legally recognized DAOs.</p><p>Depending on how the DAO is set up, it might be more difficult to coordinate and move quickly compared to centralized leadership like a CEO making quick decisions when necessary. However, a DAO could set up quorums that don’t take too long and set requirements as to how responsive DAO members need to be. Also in the beginning when there are a lot of decisions to be made, there could be more centralization among certain members and then the DAO decentralizes over time in what is referred to as “progressive decentralization.”</p><p>There is also the possibility of voter apathy where not all members will want to vote or are even best qualified to vote on all changes. In this case there will likely be voters delegating to members that can be more informed and active in voting that also align with their beliefs. These representatives are sometimes referred to as protocol politicians as they often campaign for delegated votes by members in the DAO similar to how existing politicians do. We might have the emergence of protocol lobbying groups that try to influence these politicians’ decisions. On the flip side one day we might even see DAOs lobbying and be major political institutions in society themselves.</p><p>Another issue is that by having the membership be so open, it is possible that it could lead to lower quality and higher noise within the DAO but these can be addressed through DAO screening processes or minimum token holding amounts to at least make sure the participant has skin in the game and is incentivized to see the DAO succeed.</p><h3 id="h-resource" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Resource</h3><p>Here is an additional resource to understand DAOs further:</p><ul><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/05/06/daos-dacs-das-and-more-an-incomplete-terminology-guide/">DAOs, DACs, DAs and More: An Incomplete Terminology Guide</a> by Vitalik Buterin</p></li></ul><p>If you want to get in touch about interesting DAO ideas or projects, I’m <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/ljxie">@ljxie</a> on Twitter.</p><p>Thanks to <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/willwarren89">Will Warren</a>, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/jcliff42">Jordan Clifford</a>, and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/Flynnjamm">Brian Flynn</a> for reviewing this post.</p><p><em>Disclaimer: Linda Xie is a Managing Director of Scalar Capital Management, LLC, an investment manager focused on cryptoassets which holds ETH and Ethereum tokens. This post is not investment advice.</em></p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>lindaxie@newsletter.paragraph.com (Linda Xie)</author>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A beginner's guide to NFTs]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@lindaxie/a-beginner-s-guide-to-nfts</link>
            <guid>dwVSF7VhstNdDUwFB93G</guid>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Jan 2021 21:41:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[What are NFTs?Non-fungible token (NFT) is a term used to describe a unique digital asset whose ownership is tracked on a blockchain, such as Ethereum. Assets that can be represented as NFTs range from digital goods, such as items that exist within virtual worlds, to claims on physical assets such as clothing items or real estate. In the coming years, we will see NFTs used to unlock entirely new use cases that are only made possible by crypto.**Tokens redeemable for real world goods on [Zora](...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3 id="h-what-are-nfts" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">What are NFTs?</h3><p>Non-fungible token (NFT) is a term used to describe a unique digital asset whose ownership is tracked on a blockchain, such as Ethereum. Assets that can be represented as NFTs range from digital goods, such as items that exist within virtual worlds, to claims on physical assets such as clothing items or real estate. In the coming years, we will see NFTs used to unlock entirely new use cases that are only made possible by crypto.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/099091de77b0698dd732de206682497ff3b7ae00ddb1dd80c9a93795d9027a42.png" alt="**Tokens redeemable for real world goods on [Zora](https://store.zora.co/)**" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">**Tokens redeemable for real world goods on [Zora](https://store.zora.co/)**</figcaption></figure><p>While the Ethereum ecosystem is where most NFT activity has taken place to date, NFTs can exist on other smart contract platforms too. This is because, at their core, NFTs are just digital abstractions used to represent assets that are one of a kind. Non-fungible token isn’t the most intuitive term since we don’t commonly refer to the fungibility of objects in the physical world, but this is an important technical distinction when it comes to how an asset is represented on a blockchain. The goal for this post is not to detail every project within the NFT space, but to give a high level overview of what NFTs are, why they are interesting, and showcase some of their potential use cases.</p><h3 id="h-why-are-nfts-interesting" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Why are NFTs interesting?</h3><p>NFTs are powerful because, when combined with other financial building blocks on Ethereum, they allow anyone to issue, own, and trade them. This makes interacting with NFTs significantly more efficient than in traditional platforms. The same reason why cryptocurrency used in payments is more efficient than traditional payments, that it is borderless and significantly easier to transfer, applies to NFTs. For example, if you want to create tradable in-game items as a game developer, then you can instantly have them be tradable through protocols that allow for decentralized exchange of NFTs. You don’t have to create your own marketplace or go through the onboarding process of a centralized platform in order to have the items be tradable.</p><p>NFT activity can go well past trading and include actions like being able to borrow and lend, support fractional ownership (e.g. <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.niftex.com/">NIFTEX</a>), or use it as collateral in taking out a loan (e.g. <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://nftfi.com/">NFTfi</a>). The possibilities are endless when you have the ability to combine NFTs with DeFi building blocks. For example, the game <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="http://aavegotchi.com">Aavegotchi</a> combines DeFi and NFT gaming where each Aavegotchi character represents a user’s collateral that is deposited within the lending platform <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://aave.com/">Aave</a>, but you can also battle the characters, level them up, and equip wearables that change their traits.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/588a68fe4eccd21a0b22f08818572fa8f76ba781af484b76e1154c3eb25aca1a.png" alt="**Aavegotchi gaming attributes change based on actions taken in DeFi**" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">**Aavegotchi gaming attributes change based on actions taken in DeFi**</figcaption></figure><p>NFTs can cover an extremely wide variety of areas given they are simply digital representations of ownership but there has been significant growth within art and gaming in particular. Note that many digital works of art and gaming items are a subset of a larger category of NFT collectibles. There is also the emerging space of social tokens, which sometimes falls into the NFT category or that is closely related to it.</p><h3 id="h-art" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Art</h3><p>NFTs can make fractionalized ownership more accessible, so if there is a valuable item that otherwise wouldn’t have been accessible for someone to own, now they can own a piece of it. Custody of a physical item still requires a trustworthy custodian, but being able to issue, hold, and trade it as a cryptoasset unlocks more use cases. One can also craft an NFT such that the creator receives a percentage of all secondary sales in a completely automated way. Artists typically don’t receive a cut of secondary sales in the traditional art world.</p><p>Programmable art is another interesting concept where a piece of artwork can incorporate on-chain data to dynamically update certain features or characteristics of the work. For example, one could create a piece of programmable art whose background changes if the price of ether goes above a certain dollar-value. There are countless creative possibilities.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/7903f86d67df3182fafa23df2d37457db35e993d6beda714ddc9b092ddea35b8.png" alt="**Rutger van der Tas [artwork](https://async.art/art/master/0x6c424c25e9f1fff9642cb5b7750b0db7312c29ad-83) that changes based on if it’s day or night**" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">**Rutger van der Tas [artwork](https://async.art/art/master/0x6c424c25e9f1fff9642cb5b7750b0db7312c29ad-83) that changes based on if it’s day or night**</figcaption></figure><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://async.art/">Async Art</a> is a digital art marketplace known for programmable art. Many artists on Async sell artwork where someone is able to own the “master” copy which consists of a number of individual layers, but other people can own the individual layers and adjust their attributes over time. Imagine groups of people being able to own art collectively, where members of the group manage attributes of the work.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/b321d7c494800be13cf8a8e3e4306b6303d1d3d55a02e39dad7303315f146b9e.png" alt="**Osinachi [artwork](https://async.art/art/master/0x6c424c25e9f1fff9642cb5b7750b0db7312c29ad-118) that includes a master and layers that can be individually adjusted**" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">**Osinachi [artwork](https://async.art/art/master/0x6c424c25e9f1fff9642cb5b7750b0db7312c29ad-118) that includes a master and layers that can be individually adjusted**</figcaption></figure><p>A common question about digital artwork is what can you do with it? These works can be displayed in digital frames in a physical setting for people to enjoy. The digital artist Beeple sold physical tokens along with his digital NFTs and made <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://niftygateway.com/itemdetail/primary/0x6e5dc5405baefb8c0166bcc78d2692777f2cbffb/21">$3.5 million</a> from sales in an auction on the Nifty Gateway marketplace.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/8ec7a20222b01b2831032a7a6aa56abbead4133760d0ea1149300ba51595ab64.png" alt="**Artist Beeple’s physical token that came with the NFT sale**" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">**Artist Beeple’s physical token that came with the NFT sale**</figcaption></figure><p>Digital artwork can also be displayed in online collections like a <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://superrare.co/thevault/collection">SuperRare profile</a> as well as in virtual worlds. There are a number of art galleries within <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="http://cryptovoxels.com">Cryptovoxels</a>, a virtual world where users can buy and sell land parcels as NFTs. As virtual reality spaces become more popular, having digital art to display will become more common. This wouldn’t be much different than someone spending money on video game items to customize a character’s appearance, already a multi-billion dollar industry.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/28d8d91f7666fe04cc0bc6cb283bf641ee26189d8d7cb7b5eb42516b7464f2de.png" alt="**Digital art gallery in Cryptovoxels**" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">**Digital art gallery in Cryptovoxels**</figcaption></figure><p>A common skepticism is that someone can just take a screenshot of the image or get a digital file so it’s not really scarce. However, the same argument could apply to physical items as well. Anyone can take a photo of the Mona Lisa or create a replica of it, but it isn’t the real item from the artist. People are willing to pay a premium for the original work. Another interesting aspect of digital art or collectibles is that you can easily verify the item’s ownership history. Some digital items might be worth more depending on who owned it in the past.</p><p>With NFTs, you can also prove that the item is real and tamper proof. This is an issue in the physical collectibles space. For example, a <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T206_Honus_Wagner">T206 Honus Wagner baseball card</a> was sold to Wayne Gretzky for $451k and sold again for several million dollars. One of the sellers of the card later admitted in court to trimming the card’s edges to make it look better. You can ensure NFT supply doesn’t change and there’s no counterfeit or continued printing. For example, there are many <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAvLC3fz068&amp;">counterfeit Black Lotus</a> cards in the popular game Magic: The Gathering. Common verification methods include bending the card to make sure it doesn’t crease or going through centralized grading services whose rating significantly affects the card&apos;s value.</p><h3 id="h-gaming" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Gaming</h3><p>Steam, a popular video game platform, has a <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://steamcommunity.com/market/?">Community Market</a> where in-game items can be bought and sold. Steam’s marketplace is centralized and collects a transaction fee of 5% for each item from the buyer. Games like Team Fortress 2 and Dota 2 take an additional fee of 10% for their items sold.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/9318267fac2a5840a86d7246cd54f05313a23388c0acfb6cdabf90d2c6f5ab97.png" alt="**Steam Community Market**" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">**Steam Community Market**</figcaption></figure><p>Steam also restricts user wallet balances to $2,000 and the price of a single item to $1,800. While these cases are outliers, many in-game items can actually sell for significantly larger amounts such as the <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.engadget.com/2013-11-06-dota-2-pink-war-dog-courier-sells-for-38-000.html">DotA 2 pink war dog courier</a> for $38,000. Within the crypto space there have also been high priced sales such as the $170,000 <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://thenextweb.com/hardfork/2018/09/05/most-expensive-cryptokitty/">CryptoKitty</a>. Similarly Magic: The Gathering’s coveted <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.polygon.com/2019/3/5/18251623/magic-the-gathering-black-lotus-auction-price">Black Lotus</a> card sold for $166,100. There is certainly demand for valuable in-game items. In decentralized marketplaces, there isn’t a limit imposed on what game items can be sold and for what amount.</p><p>Decentralized marketplaces can significantly reduce transaction fees due to the improved efficiency of starting up and operating a marketplace. Marketplaces can also improve overall user experience and increase interest in the game. Hearthstone is a wildly popular digital collectible card game created by Blizzard Entertainment that had over <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://variety.com/2018/gaming/news/hearthstone-has-over-100-million-players-1203019919/">100 million players</a> in 2018. Hearthstone opted to not have a marketplace for their cards which leaves opportunity for other digital collectible card games that allow for an open marketplace. <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://godsunchained.com/">Gods Unchained</a> and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.skyweaver.net/">SkyWeaver</a> are two trading card games (TCGs) that have cards that are freely tradable. You are also able to earn cards as you level up in the game. Players that did not purchase packs of cards will still be able to improve upon the game’s default decks. It’s an exciting feeling knowing that the earned cards have real world value and can be sold or traded for other cards. Gods Unchained also lets users earn tokens for when they win a match or refer their friend. The tokens themselves unlock rare in-game items and are also freely tradable.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/fecc73b660fb3dacb70c3751a74d4bd203899cad3188a5d51c88c58a42f4047f.png" alt="**Gods Unchained**" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">**Gods Unchained**</figcaption></figure><p>One of the most popular games in crypto is <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://axieinfinity.com/">Axie Infinity</a>. You battle with a team of pet Axies and level them up. There&apos;s no aspect of the gameplay that feels like a blockchain game but there is the added benefit of being able to openly trade the Axies on NFT marketplaces such as <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://opensea.io/">OpenSea</a>. The game has become popular in the <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.coindesk.com/nft-game-filipinos-covid">Philippines</a> and earning tokens from the game has become a viable source of income for players even <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.playtoearn.online/2020/07/08/axie-infinity-beats-minimum-wage-in-many-countries/">beating minimum wage</a> in many countries. There is also a decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) called <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://yieldguild.io/">Yield Guild Games</a> which leases Axies to players that want to get started with the game but don’t have the funds to purchase them. Several rare Axies were even <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.delphidigital.io/reports/why-we-spent-159k-on-digital-battle-pets-2/">purchased</a> for $159,000 total.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/d40d0cecb1fa5728a1983327383d0eff60acb3094b5db7ee720cf0db84e17602.png" alt="**Axie Infinity battle**" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">**Axie Infinity battle**</figcaption></figure><p>There’s another popular game <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://zkga.me/">Dark Forest</a> where you can explore different planets and collect Artifact NFTs on new planets, which give bonuses when attached to the planet. Being able to discover and collect these items or even win them in a battle and then trade them in decentralized marketplaces can make the game even more fun.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/b0db5feb6a35606eba6aab9fbc1894a365fcad9d10654f16c2c946a7de73c540.png" alt="Planet in Dark Forest which has an Artifact NFT" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Planet in Dark Forest which has an Artifact NFT</figcaption></figure><p>One concern with making in-game items tradable is that the ability to trade items can negatively affect the gameplay as people are focused on extracting value from the system or only the players that are willing to pay a lot of money for items can enjoy the game. Diablo III had an auction house where users could trade in-game items for in-game currency and cash. It was <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.wired.com/2013/09/diablo-auction-house/">shut down</a> because of how it affected the game. It was no longer fun and rewarding since players would just buy the best loot. In Diablo III, having the best loot was essentially the goal of the game so having an auction house severely affected gameplay whereas other games are not set up this way. It’s important for game developers to find a balance on what should be freely traded for their game (e.g. skins rather than weapons, <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://secure.eveonline.com/plex/">game time</a> itself can be traded, etc).</p><h3 id="h-social-tokens" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Social tokens</h3><p>The emerging area of social tokens grew significantly in 2020. Social tokens are a broad category of tokens issued by individuals and communities. This term encompasses other similar terms like personal token, community token, and creator token. So far there hasn’t been a standardized term but I will use social tokens to refer to the broader category. Social tokens enable creators and communities to have more ownership in what they are building which is extremely exciting.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/8d4050500b0f600901797df29fdc60841560820a02b57702dd4c168ad40e49d6.png" alt="Social tokens map created by Forefront and Seedclub in [Social Tokens Year in Review](https://2020inreview.forefront.news/)" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Social tokens map created by Forefront and Seedclub in [Social Tokens Year in Review](https://2020inreview.forefront.news/)</figcaption></figure><p>Early experiments of social tokens involved people tokenizing their time. For example <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/bramanathan?lang=en">Reuben Bramanathan</a>, who previously worked on legal and product at Coinbase, tokenized his time where 1 <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.bramanathan.com/">$CSNL</a> token equaled 1 hour of his time and was freely traded. We also saw people attempting to tokenize part of their future income. Platforms like <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://tryroll.com/">Roll</a> and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://coinvise.co/">Coinvise</a> make it easier for people to issue their own token.</p><p>One prominent example of a social token is <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://blog.ourzora.com/home/introducing-rac">$RAC</a>, a community token by the Grammy award winning recording artist <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/RAC">RAC</a>, issued through Zora. Token holders get access to a private Discord group and receive early access to merch drops with more perks to be added in the future. The token was retroactively distributed to his supporters including Bandcamp and Patreon supporters, people who had bought merch, and will eventually be distributed to all Twitch supporters. This allows creators to directly interact with and reward their early supporters.</p><p>One of the tools that enabled a new wave of social tokens was <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://collab.land/">Collab.Land</a>, which built a Telegram and Discord bot that connects to an Ethereum wallet to verify token balance before joining a chat group. This allowed for the creation of token permissioned groups, such as <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.jammpad.com/">$JAMM</a> and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://andrwlee.medium.com/announcing-karma-dao-first-ever-token-permissioned-networking-chat-group-on-telegram-5feab7a54def">$KARMA</a> with their native tokens, which helped make sure that those joining the group had a certain level of skin in the game. Another feature of Collab.Land is a leaderboard that keeps track of who has contributed the most to the chat group. You could imagine token rewards distributed to those with the highest amounts of participation to reward engagement.</p><p>Another useful social token tool is <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://unite.community/">Unite Community</a> which allows for creators to easily distribute their tokens to followers through their social media channels and reward engagement.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/7a1c1541e04a63d63d7a88663c1b8590c23f36be52f91c0eb09d05ebed5e2f81.png" alt="Unite.community distribution" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Unite.community distribution</figcaption></figure><p>The interesting part about social tokens is that it can represent anything from a person’s time to specialized access to collective ownership of a community. There is a lot of potential for social tokens and I expect many more creators to issue them in the future.</p><h3 id="h-future" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Future</h3><p>These are just a few of the many use cases that are possible and have gotten some traction. There will likely be a significant increase in NFT adoption over the next several years. Traditional assets like equity getting tokenized seems like a clear progression in the future as it would make transferring them far more efficient. Then we’ll see tokenization that bridges the traditional world but adds new possibilities such as advertising space represented as an NFT where you could sell advertising rights to a site and have that be freely tradable. This would be a form of digital real estate. These NFTs would allow people to bet that a website will get a lot of traction and that the advertising space will become more valuable. Then we’ll start seeing more tokens with brand new concepts that are only made possible because of crypto which is what I’m most excited about.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/1135e84c04466747c9d71fa1e434614091a375c949fe9f6be5841d5b3ad37114.png" alt="Table from Will Warren’s presentation at [0xpo](https://www.0xpo.com/)" blurdataurl="" nextheight="600" nextwidth="800" class="image-node embed"><figcaption HTMLAttributes="[object Object]" class="">Table from Will Warren’s presentation at [0xpo](https://www.0xpo.com/)</figcaption></figure><p>There are a few aspects of the user experience that need to be improved in order for NFTs to become more accessible. We need to have improvements to scaling since transaction fees can make some transactions very expensive or infeasible. Scaling research is already in the works with many different teams in Ethereum working on scaling solutions and we also are seeing other blockchains being built that are catered specifically for this use case. Another point of friction with NFTs is that holders will need to self-custody them. However this complexity can be abstracted away with user friendly wallets that make it easy to onboard and support features such as a PIN, biometrics, and social account recovery. I’m optimistic that these will get built out over time and we will see a huge wave of creativity and experimentation in the NFT space.</p><h3 id="h-resources" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Resources</h3><p>Here are some additional resources to understand NFTs further and keep up with developments.</p><h4 id="h-understanding-nfts" class="text-xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-3 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Understanding NFTs</h4><ul><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://andrewsteinwold.substack.com/p/-quick-overview-of-the-nft-ecosystem">Quick Overview of the NFT Ecosystem</a> by Andrew Steinwold</p></li><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://opensea.io/blog/guides/non-fungible-tokens/">The Non-Fungible Token Bible</a> by Devin Finzer</p></li><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://2020inreview.forefront.news/">Social Tokens Year in Review</a> by Cooper Turley</p></li></ul><h4 id="h-keeping-up-with-nfts" class="text-xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-3 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Keeping up with NFTs</h4><ul><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://artsdefi.substack.com/">DeFi Arts Intelligencer newsletter</a> by William Peaster</p></li><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://andrewsteinwold.substack.com/">Zima Red newsletter</a> by Andrew Steinwold</p></li><li><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://forefront.market/">Forefront newsletter</a> on social tokens</p></li></ul><p>If you want to get in touch about interesting NFT ideas or projects, I’m <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/ljxie">@ljxie</a> on Twitter.</p><p>Thanks to <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/willwarren89">Will Warren</a> and <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://twitter.com/jcliff42">Jordan Clifford</a> for reviewing this post.</p><p><em>Disclaimer: Linda Xie is a Managing Director of Scalar Capital Management, LLC, an investment manager focused on cryptoassets which holds ETH and Ethereum tokens. This post is not investment advice.</em></p><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xC89ae0710A76B303Ad819159c02a9b4e7578075D">Gitcoin Grants, Axie scholarships, First Mint Fund</a></p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>lindaxie@newsletter.paragraph.com (Linda Xie)</author>
            <enclosure url="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/09b47a6847bdc463cbf2d85237e729cec7374db435a7daff52292f548c1df911.jpg" length="0" type="image/jpg"/>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>