<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/">
    <channel>
        <title>Unmediated Thoughts</title>
        <link>https://paragraph.com/@unmediatedthoughts</link>
        <description>undefined</description>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 22:34:57 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <docs>https://validator.w3.org/feed/docs/rss2.html</docs>
        <generator>https://github.com/jpmonette/feed</generator>
        <language>en</language>
        <copyright>All rights reserved</copyright>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why the "Epstein Affair" Matters]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@unmediatedthoughts/why-the-epstein-affair-matters</link>
            <guid>Suv7bdHkVbII6VqAnfd5</guid>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Feb 2026 00:26:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[The Jeffrey Epstein saga has the rare quality of being a story where public fascination has grown rather than faded with time. Epstein died in 2019, which is ancient history in our frenetic media environment, yet he has become more infamous with each passing year. The release of a new tranche of his private communications this month by the Department of Justice has ignited further public interest in the case, turning Epstein and his crimes into a landmark event in American culture. The whole ...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Jeffrey Epstein saga has the rare quality of being a story where public fascination has grown rather than faded with time. Epstein died in 2019, which is ancient history in our frenetic media environment, yet he has become more infamous with each passing year. The release of a new tranche of his private communications this month by the Department of Justice has ignited further public interest in the case, turning Epstein and his crimes into a landmark event in American culture. The whole thing deserves a suitably memorable title at this point, something like the “Epstein Affair,” to which future historians (assuming there are any) can easily refer back.</p><p>My colleagues and I at Drop Site News have been publishing an <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/s/epstein-and-israel"><u>ongoing exclusive series</u></a> of stories about Epstein, focused on his sprawling network of <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/jeffrey-epstein-ehud-barak-leaked-emails-mongolia-security-deal"><u>political</u></a>, <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/jeffrey-epstein-ariane-de-rothschild-ehud-barak-swiss-bank-israeli-cyberweapons"><u>financial</u></a>, and <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/jeffrey-epstein-iran-contra-planes-leslie-wexner-pottinger-leese-arms-weapons-smuggling"><u>intelligence</u></a> connections. Those stories will continue, and there is much more to come. But it is also worth taking a step back to ask why Epstein matters exactly, and why the public is so enthralled by his case.</p><p>On one hand, there is a perennial human fascination with stories of illicit sexual transgression, and Epstein and his associates’ crimes against women and young girls naturally draw such attention. But there is another reason people remain gripped by this episode, one at least as important: what it reveals about transnational corruption, and the hollowness of our fake meritocracy.</p><p>Epstein and his associates are creatures of the post-Cold War world, where formal institutions have been weakened by transnational capital. Instead of democratic institutions with identifiable representatives, power has gradually shifted into the hands of opaque networks of wealthy private individuals, global governance bodies, and “philanthropic” organizations. Epstein was both a generous patron and expert manipulator of these networks.</p><p>We now have overwhelming documentary evidence that Epstein held regular counsel with heads of state, diplomats, oligarchs, scientists, and intelligence chiefs worldwide—even facilitating <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/jeffrey-epstein-ehud-barak-putin-israel-russia-syria-war-depose-assad"><u>backchannel negotiations</u></a> on matters of war, peace, and <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/epstein-leviathan-jpmorgan-gas-deals-netanyahu-ehud-barak"><u>global energy flows</u></a>.</p><p>Yet unlike the diplomats and politicians of the twentieth century, Epstein did not have a business card signifying his allegiance, or to whom he was accountable. If he answered to anyone at all, it was the transnational elite that some are now acidly referring to as the “Epstein Class.” These are the people who continue to shape politics outside institutional channels—in conversations on private islands, in encrypted email threads, and in Signal chats—while hollowing out the increasingly impotent institutions that are supposed to represent the general public.</p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/8ed32a7e11af40648e2b23a9237ad3b80a54b5ffd50298a34039c51caad200b4.jpg" alt="" blurdataurl="" nextheight="887" nextwidth="1456" class="image-node embed"><figcaption htmlattributes="[object Object]" class="">Nothing to see here obviously.</figcaption></figure><p>The phenomenon of wealthy individuals working privately with one another across borders to advance shared political and economic goals appears ad nauseam in Epstein’s communications. Such activity is, by its nature, a “conspiracy,” and it is also part of what makes the Epstein Affair so infuriating to the broader public. People feel powerless in the face of these elite networks, which have predictably descended into extreme forms of corruption—including sexual corruption—in the absence of transparency. To add insult to injury, the public is now being denied the right to even name the phenomenon.</p><p>Because of elite capture of many institutions, the coverage of Epstein’s activities by establishment news outlets feels a lot more like damage control than accountability. Despite his extensively documented political influence and even his role in shaping <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/jeffrey-epstein-recruited-nsa-codebreakers-genome-russia-skolkovo-bill-gates-mit"><u>frontier research in AI and biotechnology,</u></a> Epstein himself has attempted to be quarantined as merely a “<a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.thefp.com/p/heres-what-i-know-about-jeffrey-epstein"><u>con-man</u></a>” and “<a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/5607711-bill-maher-trump-epstein-saga/"><u>dead pervert</u></a>.” What is being covered up here are not his sexual abuses, but what his role and activities reveal about how power actually operates today.</p><p>In the absence of establishment media attention, small teams of investigative journalists and members of the public have been left to extract meaning from mountains of raw data abruptly released by the government on late Friday evenings, in what appears to be a deliberate effort to sow confusion and muffle the impact of what is being disclosed. Although they are being forced to continue talking about it, the whole issue seems to make people in power extremely uncomfortable.</p><p>Epstein was a fixture on the sidelines of gatherings like the Davos Summit. If you look at the agenda of such an event, you will see lots of mention of inspiring topics like fighting climate change and ending global hunger. This framing acts as a moral alibi, justifying to the masses an otherwise intolerable condition of democratic helplessness. It assures people that even if they can’t see exactly what they’re doing, their elites are upstanding individuals, interested in their general wellbeing, and deserving of the unique privileges they have been afforded.</p><p>Recent disclosures suggest that this morally upright image is quite bogus. The powerful people who shared Epstein’s networks spent a tremendous amount of time engaged in sordid and self-interested financial dealings, manipulated public institutions to their personal ends, and profiteered from the most extreme human misery—all to say nothing of their evident involvement in the global sex trade and, in some cases, pedophilia.</p><p>In one comically evil exchange that was emblematic of <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/jeffrey-epstein-israel-surveillance-state-cote-d-ivoire-ehud-barak-leaked-emails"><u>many of their joint activities</u></a>, Epstein wrote to his close friend, former Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak, “with civil unrest exploding in ukraine syria, somolia [sic], libya, and the desperation of those in power, isn’t this perfect for you.” Barak replied: “You’re right [in] a way. But not simple to transform it into a cash flow. A subject for Saturday.”</p><p>Insisting that anyone who even notices any of this is a morally reprobate conspiracy theorist is predictably just making people even more furious.</p><p><strong>Mafia Boss</strong></p><p>In social critic Christopher Lasch’s final book, <em>The Revolt of the Elites and the Betrayal of Democracy</em>, he predicted the emergence of a transnational elite that was completely alienated from the people it ruled. These people would view themselves primarily as “world citizens,” while avoiding taking on any of the “obligations that citizenship in a polity normally implies.”</p><p>Deeming itself both superior and fundamentally different from the masses, this ostensibly meritocratic elite would feel no real obligation toward them, having, as Lasch put it “removed themselves from the common life.” Had he lived to see the current situation, Lasch would have recognized Epstein and his associates immediately.​</p><p>Epstein was a node in a transnational network—similar in its parastatal structure and clandestine operations to a criminal mafia—that is connected by shared tastes, institutional affiliations, and class interests. These people come from around the world, including the Middle East, Africa, Russia, Europe and the United States. Yet despite their veneer of cosmopolitanism, the ethnic, national, and religious differences among them are largely irrelevant. What really matters is being a member of the club.</p><p>Another thing that characterizes this club is the stark divide in cultural and moral attitudes between them and the people over whom they rule. The enthusiastic embrace of sex trafficking is merely one aspect. In Epstein’s communications with his associates the cultural and religious beliefs of ordinary people are treated as something to be mocked and humiliated, while they, as an avowedly transhumanist class, pursue loftier aims like genetic modification and even immortality.</p><p>In this world, the poor do not even receive the <em>noblesse oblige</em> of earlier eras, and are treated either as a threat to be carefully monitored, or as a commodity to be exploited for sex and economic gain. There is an unmistakable air of contempt in it all. The very same people Epstein mingled with in life, and who participated in or abetted his abuses, now seem to relish the prospect of rendering the vast majority of humanity redundant through advances in robotics and artificial intelligence.</p><p>Some defenders of the Epstein Class have implied that the public’s intense interest in this episode reflects a moral failing. That supposed failing lies not with Epstein and his associates, but with the public itself—portrayed as a primitive mob, incapable of processing information rationally, and easily drawn into spirals of medieval superstition.</p><p>In reality, public interest and outrage over Epstein is entirely justified. This whole sordid episode is another data point in a ruthless class war being waged by a relatively small number of networked wealthy people against the rest of society. That there aren’t actual riots and disorder in response to the revelations contained in the latest Department of Justice disclosures only reflects how far the neoliberal project of atomization and suppression of the public has progressed.</p><p>Many people are by now fully aware of what is happening, and they are angry. Yet the formerly proud and autonomous citizens of democracies have had their mechanisms for collective action dismantled, leaving them to vent their rage impotently through social media platforms controlled by the very oligarchs responsible for this adverse transfer of power, and whose names are overflowing in these disclosures.</p><p><strong>Power Broker</strong></p><p>Contrary to attempts to portray him as merely an elite confidence man, Epstein, despite his profound moral failings—including sexual abuse, pedophilia, and racial supremacism—was also highly intelligent. He understood how power operated, particularly in technology, finance, and global logistics. That is why he surrounded himself with scientists and stayed abreast of emerging developments in biotechnology and cryptography.</p><p>He did not do this out of idle curiosity, but because he understood keenly from where future power would flow. It was also why he went to such lengths to befriend and influence the people who controlled the ports and shipping terminals upon which the global economy now depends, including his close friend whom we wrote about, the <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/jeffrey-epstein-united-arab-emirates-sultan-sulayem-dubai-dp-world"><u>now-former Dubai Ports World</u></a> chief Sultan Sulayem.</p><p>Any collective effort to push back against the Epstein Class requires an equally keen understanding of where real power lies today, along with the development of legal and political tools to confront it. Despite its flaws, the nation-state still contains structures designed to respond to public pressure—mechanisms that could be used to track down and dismantle the vast pools of capital that have enabled this oligarchic, transnational elite to flourish.</p><p>Many years ago, in very different circumstances, Hannah Arendt wrote about a form of tyranny in which “there is nobody left with whom one can argue, to whom one can present grievances, on whom the pressures of power can be exerted,” calling it “a tyranny without a tyrant.” Arendt was referring to the power of faceless bureaucracy—but her description resonates uncannily with the grey networks of transnational influence revealed in the Epstein disclosures.</p><p>If there was anything Jeffrey Epstein did in his life that ultimately served the public, it was to shatter a veil of secrecy and provide a potent symbol—himself—through which people could identify the networked tyranny that now defines our world.</p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>unmediatedthoughts@newsletter.paragraph.com (Murtaza)</author>
            <enclosure url="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/a583576515ce876b0de45e91d0ceabd9bd6d64d2698c5d62bd439e55fde4903e.jpg" length="0" type="image/jpg"/>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Digital Vice as Class Warfare]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@unmediatedthoughts/digital-vice-as-class-warfare</link>
            <guid>U5Xg3xWaTvAtQHIqSdBF</guid>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Jan 2026 21:57:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[In the mid-19th century, European powers fought two wars against China’s Qing Dynasty to force it to continue accepting a particular vice: opium. The opium trade filled the coffers of a small group of European traders and governments while unleashing enormous social damage inside China. The Qing state, militarily overmatched, was physically incapable of stopping the flood of narcotics, which hollowed out families, degraded individual dignity, and rendered Chinese society vulnerable to politic...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the mid-19th century, European powers fought two wars against China’s Qing Dynasty to force it to continue accepting a particular vice: opium. The opium trade filled the coffers of a small group of European traders and governments while unleashing enormous social damage inside China. The Qing state, militarily overmatched, was physically incapable of stopping the flood of narcotics, which hollowed out families, degraded individual dignity, and rendered Chinese society vulnerable to political exploitation.</p><p>“Those who smoke opium waste time, neglect their duties, ruin their families, and shorten their lives,” warned Lin Zexu, a Qing imperial official who observed how the drug enervated the population. Zexu later wrote a pleading letter to Queen Victoria noting that Britain itself banned opium consumption for its own population,  asking the Queen, “what has become of that conscience which heaven has implanted in the breasts of all men?”</p><p>The Opium Wars were a brazen illustration of a long-standing reality: unregulated vices can function as a form of aggression by the powerful against the weak.</p><p>Aristotle spent considerable time in his <em>Nicomachean Ethics</em> warning that a person overwhelmed by appetite was not merely unfree, but met his definition of being “enslaved.” More than a century later, the Pan-African activist Marcus Garvey issued a similar warning to Black Americans navigating a licentious modern society: “If the Negro is not careful he will drink in all the poison of modern civilization and die from the effects of it.”</p><p>Just as British colonialists flooded a helpless Qing Empire with opium to extract profit while destroying the population’s ability to resist, the American public now appears to be facing a deliberate assault by tech oligarchs—assisted by pliable government allies—aimed at putting a final nail in the coffin of American culture, and the ability by Americans to politically resist their agenda. Unlike opium, which was finite, costly, and difficult to transport, today’s elites possess a vastly more powerful weapon: unlimited digital vice, deployed to overwhelm the psychological defenses of an unprepared population, particularly the young and the poor.</p><p>During the COVID-19 pandemic, when daily life was rapidly virtualized, venture capitalist Marc Andreessen articulated this worldview with remarkable candor. A small minority of humanity, he argued, enjoys “reality privilege”: access to rich physical environments, meaningful work, and full social lives. For everyone else, he suggested, virtual worlds constructed on the internet should replace what reality fails to provide.</p><p>“A small percent of people live in a real-world environment that is rich, even overflowing, with glorious substance, beautiful settings, plentiful stimulation, and many fascinating people to talk to, and to work with, and to date. Everyone else, the vast majority of humanity, lacks Reality Privilege — their online world is, or will be, immeasurably richer and more fulfilling than most of the physical and social environment around them in the quote-unquote real world.”</p><p>Andreessen continued, with a note of barely concealed mockery towards those who preferred reforms in the real world to building everyone their own personal version of <em>The</em> <em>Matrix</em>:</p><p>“The Reality Privileged, of course, call this conclusion dystopian, and demand that we prioritize improvements in reality over improvements in virtuality. To which I say: reality has had 5,000 years to get good, and is clearly still woefully lacking for most people; I don’t think we should wait another 5,000 years to see if it eventually closes the gap. We should build — and we are building — online worlds that make life and work and love wonderful for everyone, no matter what level of reality deprivation they find themselves in.”</p><p>What, then, does this “wonderful for everyone” virtual world look like? Increasingly, it resembles a 24/7 private digital casino and brothel, operating under constant surveillance, optimized for real-world profit, and accompanied by a corporate-controlled tabloid news outrage machine flickering in the corner.</p><h3 id="h-three-horsemen" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">Three Horsemen</h3><p>Over the past decade, aided by broadband expansion and permissive regulatory shifts, the United States has experienced explosive growth in online gambling and pornography. Alongside these has come a subtler form of political manipulation enabled by ubiquitous short-form video platforms, which are rapidly eroding the culture of the written word and replacing it with flickering images projected on the wall of Plato’s cave.</p><p>Together, these form what might reasonably be called the three horsemen of virtual experience. All are aggressively capitalized, heavily promoted, and expanding at extraordinary speed.</p><p>The vices themselves are not new. Gambling and pornography are as old as recorded history. But changes in delivery can fundamentally alter their effects.</p><p>There is a clear difference between an evening poker game with friends and unlimited, anonymous, 24-hour gambling from a phone in one’s bedroom. The former places you in a social space, while the latter removes all friction, context, and restraint.</p><p>Moving vice into private accelerates atomization and alienation while insulating users from the social feedback that can prevent total degradation.</p><p>After the Supreme Court struck down the federal ban on sports betting in 2018, Americans wagered under $5 billion annually. Last year, they bet roughly $150 billion. Around 90 percent of those bets are now placed on phones. The explosive growth of prediction markets represents yet another turn of the same screw, converting the world itself into a gigantic casino. Monthly trading volume on these platforms surged from under $100 million in early 2024 to more than $13 billion by the end of 2025.</p><p>The "digital brothel" of the internet is perhaps even more destructive.</p><p>A recent <em>Harper’s</em> article described communities of young men whose lives have been slowly destroyed by compulsive online pornography—an addiction made possible only relatively recently by ubiquitous high-speed internet. “Anyone paying attention to online porn’s evolution over the preceding twenty years could sense, in its brain-melting variety and abundance, the blueprint for a new kind of person, a new relationship to human sexuality,” the article notes, while observing the growth of cult-like communities of men who actually exited reality for a world of digital experience, as Andreesen proposed. The picture painted is not an idyllic one but a vision of social collapse and poersonal degradation.</p><p>Moral objections aside, a growing body of scientific literature documents the neurological harm caused by unlimited streamed pornography. Pascal Emanuel-Gobry writes:</p><blockquote><p>“If our reward system interprets each new porn clip as the same thing as a new sexual partner, this means an unprecedented sort of stimulus for our brain… Even decadent Roman emperors, Turkish sultans, and 1970s rock stars never had 24/7, one-click-away access to infinitely many, infinitely novel sexual partners.”</p><p>“The combination of a pre-existing natural circuit for neurochemical reward linked to sexual stimulus and the possibility of immediate, infinite novelty—which was not a feature of porn until 2006—means that a user can now keep his dopamine levels much higher, and for much longer periods of time, than we can possibly hope our brains to handle without real and lasting damage.”</p></blockquote><p>Its easy to look down on the people in the Harper’s article, whose ability to process real-world pleasure and experience meaningful social interactions has been utterly ruined by their online addictions. </p><p>But as the article notes in its conclusion, their mode of digital self-destruction is not even that different from others familiar to tech-centered modern life: hours lost to short-form video, chasing dopamine hits on social platforms, parasocial relationships, and the abandonment of complex relationships with others in exchange for the warm certainties of a solitary, glowing screen.</p><h3 id="h-the-illusion-of-power-and-autonomy" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">“The Illusion of Power and Autonomy”</h3><p>Over the past generation, the United States has undergone an extraordinary concentration of wealth, producing levels of inequality unmatched in modern history and giving rise to a powerful new oligarchy based in Silicon Valley. Whatever their differences, the wealthy share acute class consciousness. They understand their position very well—and they are nervous about it.</p><p>“It’s become quite difficult to hide one’s money,” Peter Thiel said in a recorded interview later reported by the Washington Post. “An incredible machinery of tax treaties, financial surveillance and sanctions architecture has been constructed.” Wealth gives the “illusion of power and autonomy,” Thiel added, “but you have this sense it could be taken away at any moment.”</p><p>Faced with a population for whom meaningful material improvement is neither planned nor expected, today’s oligarchs appear to be pursuing a different strategy: pacification through virtual experience. They aim to preserve their status through enforcing psychological compliance, encouraging the majority to live absorbed in screens, distracted and isolated, while real power and resources remain elsewhere.</p><p>Tech elites opportunistically cloak themselves in patriotic rhetoric, only to threaten to move to Dubai or Singapore whenever a U.S. politician suggests raising their taxes. In practice, they resemble a class waging a kind of colonial occupation against the American public. Their openly articulated vision is that the ordinary people whose opinions they consider irrelevant, and whose labor they hope to replace with AI and robotics, should disappear into a haze of digital pleasure —much as opium-addicted subjects of the Qing Empire did two centuries ago.</p><p>One lingering obstacle is that Americans still conceive of themselves as autonomous political actors. From the perspective of tech oligarchs, technology also offers a solution to that problem. Major social-media platforms are now being purchased and reengineered for explicitly political ends, with algorithms and video feeds used to alternate between pacification and periodic waves of mass hysteria, directed at targets their owners deem acceptable. These cycles often focus on internecine ethnic or racial antagonisms—sudden surges of fury aimed at Haitians, Somalis, or whoever else the algorithm happens to surface that week.</p><p>This form of tech-driven political warfare is our third horseman. Yet as destructive as this behavior is, it is also deeply insulting, because it reveals how thoroughly the society being targeted has already been neutralized. Americans are fragmented, dependent, and incapable of even negative collective action. Passions are deliberately inflamed, yet, for the most part, nothing ultimately happens. Beyond the fleeting physical satisfaction of hitting “send” on an angry post, there is rarely catharsis or translation into real-world action. </p><p>Hannah Arendt once observed that what prepares people for domination is not ideology alone, but loneliness. Once an exceptional condition, that state of atomization has become a mass experience. Isolation and loneliness, she noted, are not the same. Today, Americans increasingly suffer both, while being subjected to a limitless barrage of vices designed to keep them blinking their lives away at screens.</p><h3 id="h-no-way-out" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0">No Way Out</h3><p>What, then, is to be done? It would be easy to tell people to unplug entirely—and to the extent that this is possible, they should—but full disengagement from platform capitalism really has become a form of “reality privilege,” one available primarily to the wealthy.</p><p>Regulation seems like one option. In China today, the state has explicitly labeled even video games an “opium of the soul” and banned online pornography rather than facilitating its spread. That posture reflects hard historical experience. After nearly a century of devastation caused by the opium trade, China did not escape mass addiction through cultural evolution alone. It took direct, sustained intervention. </p><p>Beginning in 1907, the Qing government negotiated a formal agreement with British India to phase out Indian opium exports over ten years; by roughly 1917, the foreign opium trade had largely ended. Domestic production and addiction persisted, however, until the establishment of the People’s Republic of China in 1949, after which the Communist government launched aggressive nationwide suppression campaigns that effectively eliminated opium smoking as a mass social phenomenon by the mid-20th century.</p><p>It is unlikely that any existing political movement in the United States will attempt anything remotely comparable. The left remains enamored with the idea that the only form of unfreedom is the restriction of personal choice. That worldview is survivable for the affluent, who can afford rehabilitation programs when things get out of hand and do not need to live their lives with a slim margin of error, but it is lethal for the poor. The right, meanwhile, actively accelerates the catastrophe in the name of short-term profit and oligarchic patronage.</p><p>A modest step we could all take is to revive a cultural habit that has largely been abandoned: acknowledging that vice exists, and that it is, in fact, harmful. That begins with recognizing the sheer scale of what is now being deliberately aimed at us through digital mediums. There is precedent for resistance. Past efforts to stigmatize destructive behavior like smoking successfully reshaped norms from the ground up and even challenged entrenched corporate power.</p><p>Unlike the opium traders of the nineteenth century, today’s tech oligarchs do not even bother supplying physical vice. Instead, they flood society with cheap, infinitely scalable virtual substitutes: simulations of risk, pleasure, intimacy, and meaning. </p><p>Whatever you want to do in the world, whatever fulfillment you seek, exists out there, in reality. It is not inside the digital cage being built to capture your attention, drain your agency, and pass itself off as freedom.</p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>unmediatedthoughts@newsletter.paragraph.com (Murtaza)</author>
            <enclosure url="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/f918814ab545c08ce8d69c5da7be4c535eca299afec8bb16df78d4a54958c507.jpg" length="0" type="image/jpg"/>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Capitalism Replaced America
]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@unmediatedthoughts/how-capitalism-replaced-america</link>
            <guid>9s4rvb4eSxyVFwIfXQMj</guid>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Dec 2025 04:08:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[Recently, I’ve been going down a rabbit hole studying contemporary China, its industrial modernization, and the Mandarin language. As part of that, I recently read a popular new book on the Middle Kingdom, Breakneck: China’s Quest to Engineer the Future by Dan Wang. The book is a breezy personal reflection, and advances a now-familiar thesis: American elites are disproportionately trained as lawyers, Chinese elites are mostly engineers, and that background shapes the way that they respond to ...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Recently, I’ve been going down a rabbit hole studying contemporary China, its industrial modernization, and the Mandarin <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://mazmhussain.substack.com/p/a-new-guide-to-passive-language-learning"><u>language</u></a>. As part of that, I recently read a popular new book on the Middle Kingdom, <em>Breakneck: China’s Quest to Engineer the Future</em> by Dan Wang. The book is a breezy personal reflection, and advances a now-familiar thesis: American elites are disproportionately trained as lawyers, Chinese elites are mostly engineers, and that background shapes the way that they respond to collective problems.</p><p>The subtext of Wang’s argument is that state-communist China has grown into a ruthlessly capitalist society; arguably more capitalist in practice than the United States. Wang writes:</p><blockquote><p>“Capitalist America intrudes upon the free market with a dense program of regulation and taxation while providing substantial (albeit imperfect) redistributive policies. Socialist China detains union organizers, levies light taxes, and provides a threadbare social safety net. The greatest trick that the Communist Party ever pulled off is masquerading as leftist.”</p></blockquote><p>This is all true. But there is another dimension of the U.S.–China divergence that his argument only partially captures, one that matters for understanding American anxieties over national identity, inequality, immigration, and other issues shaping the present.</p><p>Wang describes how Deng Xiaoping, seeking to escape the failures of the Maoist command economy, created “sandboxed” free-market zones within China. These zones multiplied in a careful process aimed at growing the economy, while maintaining ultimate Communist Party political control. The experiment worked: Within two generations, nearly every Chinese person had become a producer and consumer within a vast market economy. In daily life, ordinary Chinese increasingly have come to resemble ordinary Americans: working, saving, and consuming.</p><p>The crucial difference is that while China utilized capitalism as a tool, it never redefined its national identity around the supremacy of capital. The Communist Party remains the unchallenged sovereign. However wealthy or powerful a Chinese enterprise becomes, there is no conceptual universe in which it might negotiate as equals with, let alone defy, the Party. No Chinese banker could dream of strolling into the Zhongnanhai to lecture Xi Jinping, as American financiers feel free to lecture or even <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/15/business/15sorkin.html"><u>snub</u></a> American presidents.</p><p>China has repeatedly shown its willingness to subordinate capital to political authority. Between 2020 and 2021 it erased $1.1 trillion in tech-sector valuation through regulatory crackdowns, halted Jack Ma’s record-breaking Ant IPO after he criticized regulators, and made plain Xi Jinping’s own repeated guidance that capital must serve the interests of the people and the Party.</p><p>America took the opposite path. As political scientist Samuel Huntington observed years ago, “America’s elites increasingly define national identity in purely economic and ideological terms, not cultural ones.” The turning point came during the Cold War when capitalism stopped being merely an economic system and became a core part of American identity; marginalizing competing visions of ethnic, religious, and culturally-based national selfhood.</p><p>During the Cold War, American elites framed capitalism as the moral antithesis to communism. Supporting free markets became synonymous with supporting the nation. An influential 1971 memo by Supreme Court justice Lewis F. Powell Jr. demanded the construction of a permanent political infrastructure to “shape social, economic, and political thought,” in support of capitalism. By the 1980s, Ronald Reagan was ready to push the envelope further, declaring: “Freedom is the right to question and change the established way of doing things. It is the continuing revolution of the marketplace.”</p><p>This process that began in the 1970s accelerated in the triumphant atmosphere following the collapse of the Soviet Union, before crystalizing its final form after the 2008 financial bailouts. Despite failed right and left-wing insurrections since then, it has continued unabated.</p><p>The global capitalist revolution in America, never formally declared, has already been successful. Over decades, vast swathes of the economy were sold off to international investors. Immigration levels were reshaped by corporate demand rather than cultural self-conception. Even stewardship of land and future generations became subordinated to the interests of global markets. At mid-twentieth century, foreign investors held only around 5 percent of U.S. corporate equity. That figure is 40 percent today, alongside massive and expanding international ownership of U.S. real estate, and even agriculture.</p><p>The project succeeded so thoroughly that raising even modest doubts about capitalism has come to be seen as suspiciously un-American; more offensive than criticizing Christianity or the ethnic makeup of the founding generation. Following the guidance of their leaders, for many people patriotism is defined by participation in the free market as consumers and entrepreneurs. (George W. Bush <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://content.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1872229_1872230_1872236,00.html"><u>famously</u></a> told people to go shopping to express their patriotism after 9/11.)</p><p>This low barrier to entry has made the country more welcoming to assimilation for outsiders, which remains one of its most charming characteristics. But it has also raised vexing questions about national identity that persist to this day.</p><p>The transformation of America by capital has made it a more dynamic, tolerant, and creative society. These are things that many people, including myself, find welcome. Yet inarguably, it also repressed and even destroyed an older American nation in favor of a new cosmopolitan empire that is still in process of becoming.</p><p><strong>Optimized for Wealth</strong></p><p>The supremacy of capital was on display again recently in a particular episode: the proposed takeover of Warner Bros Discovery by Paramount Skydance. The takeover is backed by a consortium of Saudi, Emirati, and Qatari sovereign wealth funds, Jared Kushner’s investment firm, and the Ellison family— the latter being figures with <a target="_blank" rel="" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/larry-ellison-vetted-marco-rubio-israel-hacked-emails-ron-prosor"><u>deep</u></a> personal, political, and economic ties to the state of Israel. If completed, the deal would finalize control over vast pillars of American mass culture—HBO, CNN, Paramount Pictures, CBS, DC Films, Nickelodeon, and now TikTok—within a network of capital holders largely foreign to the United States, or with shared sympathies to other states.</p><p>According to the logic of modern American capitalism, nothing is wrong with this. But if the deal goes through it would reduce even further national control over institutions central to American culture and governance. The American media would be penetrated to an unprecedented extent by foreign interests, in this case Gulf Arab and Israeli. It is impossible to imagine China permitting anything remotely comparable with their own media, which closely shepherds not just the interests of the Party or Chinese citizens, but even the cultural and political centrality of the domestic Han majority.</p><p>This oligarchic media consolidation by foreign investors is a step further in a decades-long transformation. The idea that the US should be run mainly for the sake of its citizens—let alone, as some demand, in reference to its original European, Native American, and Black lineages—has been displaced by the idea that the country is a platform for global capitalism. It helps explains why elites like Kushner admire the glittering, frictionless, deracinated consumerism of the UAE and other Gulf Arab states. Dubai represents a post-national, antidemocratic future, optimized only for wealth, that many people find desirable for the US itself.</p><p><strong>Citizenship as Bond</strong></p><p>Understanding the America that global capitalism has built is also key to understanding the populist anger that now defines much of our politics. Trump’s 2016 campaign suggested that he would confront global capital’s control over the country, including by providing healthcare to ordinary Americans in defiance of market preferences, limiting immigration, and ending foreign entanglement in overseas conflicts. He renewed those promises in 2024, less convincingly, but with enough vigor to defeat an exhausted Democratic Party that lacked a counterargument.</p><p>In practice, his alliances with Gulf Arab and Israeli elites reveal where Trump’s loyalties truly lie. Many Americans whose concerns have been ignored for decades see this plainly. A 2023 PRRI survey found that 65% of Republicans and 40% of Democrats believe “the country is being run for the benefit of outsiders.” Regardless of how they feel about their government and domestic elites, can any comparable number of people in China believe that their country is being administered for the benefit of foreign powers?</p><p>I’m not endorsing state socialism, communism, ethnic nationalism, or any other radical transformation of American society. Too many revolutionary movements end in catastrophe, several of these ideologies have been tried and failed in past, and America itself is too far down its current road to abruptly switch towards something totally different. There are also many aspects of the current version of America that I cherish, including its entrepreneurial culture and cosmopolitanism.</p><p>That said, there is a real tradeoff here, and absent a dramatic course correction, global capitalism will continue to carve away pieces of America in the years ahead. Ideally, a functioning democracy can still mitigate this drift—above all by restraining the power of the domestic and foreign oligarchs who treat the United States not as a nation or community in formation, but as a mere platform for their own economic and political ambitions.</p><p>This brings us back to China. Despite its material strengths, there are also many appalling aspects of the Chinese political system, which may yet lose in its competition with the American empire. The irony, though, is that many angry Middle American voters who have been taught that capitalism is their identity may feel less existentially dislocated under a system like that run by Beijing, where the ruling party makes no apology for prioritizing its own citizens, strictly polices the activities of foreign capital, and shapes the economy for the benefit of the nation, rather than the reverse.</p><p>China, for all its failings, will almost certainly maintain a thread of cultural continuity stretching into the future. America, by contrast, is becoming a landscape shaped less by citizens than by capital, with the people themselves and their interests receding into the background.</p><p>The way to fight back is not to retreat into ethnic nationalism, which is neither desirable nor viable for modern Americans, but with a renewed understanding of citizenship, including potentially exclusive and singular citizenship, as a real bond. That is one of the few remaining grounds on which Americans might still resist being overshadowed by amorphous global interests, interested in extracting from them, but indifferent to their fate.</p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>unmediatedthoughts@newsletter.paragraph.com (Murtaza)</author>
            <enclosure url="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/e0970042986c76319e74c4292be20cb1c663eced9732550b4f51dc59de2d289d.jpg" length="0" type="image/jpg"/>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Writer Coins and the Crisis of Funding Journalism]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@unmediatedthoughts/writer-coins-and-the-crisis-of-funding-journalism</link>
            <guid>QBo21eABcdqXOsYASs1Y</guid>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Dec 2025 21:48:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[Digital media has spent the last two decades trying to reinvent the economics of writing, and yet the industry remains stuck in a strange paradox: more people read news than ever before, but fewer are willing or able to pay for it. Out of this dilemma has emerged a new idea known as “writer coins.” The concept borrows from cryptocurrency logic and turns readership interest into a tradeable token that can support journalists directly. I recently experimented with this by launching a MAZ coin f...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3 id="h-" class="text-2xl font-header !mt-6 !mb-4 first:!mt-0 first:!mb-0"></h3><p>Digital media has spent the last two decades trying to reinvent the economics of writing, and yet the industry remains stuck in a strange paradox: more people read news than ever before, but fewer are willing or able to pay for it. Out of this dilemma has emerged a new idea known as “writer coins.” The concept borrows from cryptocurrency logic and turns readership interest into a tradeable token that can support journalists directly. I recently experimented with this by launching a MAZ coin for this Paragraph blog. </p><p><a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://farcaster.xyz/mazmhussain/0xe21552c9">https://farcaster.xyz/mazmhussain/0xe21552c9</a></p><p>At first glance this looks like a clever fix to the collapse of advertising revenue and the unexpected difficulties of subscriptions. But beneath the novelty of the idea lies a deeper structural problem: we still have not solved how to fund journalism without either chasing clicks or relying on patrons. Writer coins offer an innovative mechanism, yet they also expose the uncomfortable truth that good reporting will always require stable capital, not just clever technology.</p><p>A “writer coin” imagines each journalist as their own miniature economy. Instead of subscribing to The New York Times or supporting an entire platform like Substack, readers would invest in the writer themselves. The more popular a writer becomes, the more their coin is worth; the value rises as readership grows, producing financial incentives for quality content and sustained engagement. It is essentially equity in a person instead of a company. In theory, this encourages a healthier relationship between writer and reader: supporters feel like stakeholders rather than passive consumers, and writers get access to upfront capital that allows them to pursue investigations, long-term research, or niche interests.</p><p>But as appealing as this sounds, writer coins also reflect the market logic that has damaged journalism in the first place. Audiences do not necessarily reward what is most important; they reward what is most engaging, most entertaining, or most aligned with their existing worldviews. A reporter trying to investigate corruption in municipal zoning laws will almost always lose, financially, to someone writing spicy opinion takes or culture-war commentary. We already know this from social media: virality is a terrible compass for civic value. Writer coins, if left to pure market dynamics, could accelerate that trend rather than reverse it.</p><p>Part of the difficulty is philosophical: journalism is a public good, not a speculative asset. Democracies require fact-gathering, verification, institutional memory, and courage. These are expensive. They demand time, travel, legal support, and editorial scrutiny. Historically, newspapers subsidized investigative work through advertising revenue on classifieds, cars, and department store circulars. That model is gone. Google and Facebook ate it. Subscription models emerged as the response, but subscriptions introduce another barrier: people gravitate toward a few big brands and ignore smaller, local outlets, even though local reporting is the most essential part of a functioning information ecosystem.</p><p>Writer coins attempt to individualize that problem: what if you could raise money person by person, story by story, rather than organization by organization? Yet individualization is itself risky. Journalism is collaborative. Even the most iconic lone reporter is backed by lawyers, editors, researchers, and institutional memory. If every writer has to function like their own startup, we risk turning reporting into a hustle, and hustling is corrosive to truth. Information becomes another gig economy product where emotional intensity and community allegiance matter more than accuracy.</p><p>There is also the moral hazard of speculation. If a writer’s income depends on the market value of their coin—which depends on audience excitement—then sensationalism becomes profitable. Controversy becomes revenue. Journalism already struggles with polarization because outrage pays; writer coins could further financialize outrage.</p><p>Still, it would be a mistake to dismiss the idea entirely. One of the positive aspects of writer coins is that they implicitly recognize journalism as labor that deserves investment before the work happens. Many reporters spend months digging into a lead before publishing anything. Traditional subscription and ad models only reward the end product, not the process. De-risking investigative effort is a legitimate goal, and any mechanism that moves money front-loaded to writers could be beneficial.</p><p>The real question, then, is whether writer coins are a supplement to journalism’s funding crisis or an attempted replacement. They should be understood as the former. We need multiple, layered economic structures: public subsidies (as found in parts of Europe), philanthropic nonprofit newsrooms, subscription models for large institutions, local cooperatives, and potentially writer coins as a way for loyal audiences to become micro-patrons. No single mechanism solves the problem of paying for truth.</p><p>The biggest obstacle is cultural. We treat information as something that should be free, failing to acknowledge that journalism is labor-intensive civic infrastructure. Until societies accept that reliable information requires ongoing investment, new financial gadgets will only offer temporary relief. Writer coins are creative, maybe even promising in small communities or niche expertise areas, but they cannot solve the structural reality: journalism isn’t a market luxury. It is a public necessity. And public necessities require stable, long-term systems of funding that aren’t built around attention volatility or investment hype.</p><p>Innovation is welcome. Speculation, less so. The future of journalism will likely borrow ideas from technology, membership models, crowdfunding, and cooperative ownership. But the goal should remain constant and non-negotiable: sustainable funding for people willing to tell the truth in a world that increasingly rewards anything but.</p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>unmediatedthoughts@newsletter.paragraph.com (Murtaza)</author>
            <enclosure url="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/89d36da3a0254c04e879b246f9381555be32e41b6d27b6245b272a4e1636e8f4.jpg" length="0" type="image/jpg"/>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA["Casino Killed the Computer Star"]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@unmediatedthoughts/casino-killed-the-computer-star</link>
            <guid>wCM4YIaEUNdzRsToMS7p</guid>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Sep 2024 19:15:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[It has been said that the scale of the internet revolution is so massive that it is impossible for human society to fully tabulate whethe...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p></p><figure float="none" data-type="figure" class="img-center" style="max-width: null;"><img src="https://img.paragraph.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto/https://storage.googleapis.com/papyrus_images/5d4c4c1e1e0353cf6ec9928a18a4255f.jpg" blurdataurl="" nextheight="500" nextwidth="325" class="image-node embed"><figcaption htmlattributes="[object Object]" class="hide-figcaption"></figcaption></figure><p>It has been said that the scale of the internet revolution is so massive that it is impossible for human society to fully tabulate whether it has been positive or negative. On a personal level, however, I can say that for me at least the internet has been very good. All the advertised benefits of intermediation, egalitarianism, and connection promised by this technology have made themselves powerfully felt in my life as a result of being online. Whatever minor drawbacks or annoyances the internet may have given me at times pale in comparison to these wonders. </p><p>As a result, whenever I hear that some people are designing some new expansion or improvement to the digital world, my initial bias is to say: Amazing! That was indeed my response when I first started learning about Bitcoin, smart contracts, blockchains, and so forth, all of which years ago won my quick enthusiasm and interest. In addition to being an outsider in my own field, as many Silicon Valley people perceive themselves, I was one of the journalists who worked on the original Edward Snowden stories in the 2010s, which gave me a bit of a libertarian streak and endeared these technologies to me even further. I quickly became a mini-evangelist for the promise of blockchain, and converted more than a few people to the cause. </p><p>For reasons I will get into later, and which are relevant to this essay, I have stopped enthusing to people about cryptocurrency and blockchain in general. Though I continue to stay abreast of developments in the industry and even play around with blockchain-based platforms, I find myself much more skeptical than I was a few years ago of the promises made by this industry. </p><p>But I do keep an open mind. And in that spirit, I recently picked up, "Read, Write Own," by Chris Dixon. In addition to the snazzy cover that will look nice on my shelf, I found the book to be an admirable attempt to revive the promise of what has become a far more controversial technology than it ever should have been. Ever so lightly, Dixon's book also offers an initial word on a painful debate that will determine whether blockchain actually winds up saving the internet from the evils of centralization, censorship, and corporate control, or simply entrenches them further.</p><p><strong>Casino, Computer, Counterculture</strong></p><p>In the past few years, I estimate that I've read about 18-20 books on cryptocurrency and blockchain. While some of them were helpful, I have since grown weary of the hyperbole, arrogance, empty speculation, and ideological extremism that characterize much of this genre. "Read, Write, Own," in contrast, is the work of a sober professional. Dixon is a crisp writer, and someone who clearly know and cares about the internet. </p><p>"Read, Write, Own" provides a brief history of the internet and its evolution from protocols to platforms, before refocusing on the problems of corporate control today and how blockchain might remedy them. Dixon makes incisive points about the exploitative "take rates" of Big Tech companies, and the undemocratic nature of the status quo digital world that has reduced most of us to mere sharecroppers in the content farms. </p><p>He also engages in some criticism of the cryptocurrency industry as it exists. In doing so, he gets close to what I see as the core problem facing this technology and its prospects.</p><p>As Dixon puts it, blockchain is today divided between the "casino" and the "computer," a metaphor to which I will also return. The casino is the world of rampant speculation with which cryptocurrency has today become largely synonymous in the public mind, while the computer refers to the underlying technology, and its promise of building a better internet.</p><p style="text-align: justify">Dixon's book is written on behalf of "computer" people. He writes with evident affection for the internet – an affection that I happen to share – while gesturing back to a world of financially-indifferent nerds passionately tinkering away in their garages on ways to improve their gadgets. Portraying blockchain developers as revolutionary outsiders, and tugging on the thread of past rags-to-riches genius stories, Dixon asks us to:</p><p><em>“Picture a counterculture-loving, twentysomething Steve Jobs attending the Homebrew Computer Club, a den of microcomputer-obsessed geeks that hosted monthly meetups in California in the 1970s. Picture Linus Torvalds as a student at the University of Helsinki in 1991, coding up a personal project that would become his namesake Linux operating system. Or picture Larry Page and Sergey Brin dropping out of Stanford and moving into a Menlo Park garage in 1998 to turn their web-link-cataloging project, BackRub, into Google.”</em></p><p>That is the world of the computer, whereas the FTX's and shady Bitcoin influencers most of us are familiar with represent the casino. “Computer culture is long term. Casino culture is not," Dixon writes. "So, it’s the computer versus the casino battling it out to define the narrative for this software movement.”</p><p>While he is right to note a basic conflict, I think the problems go much deeper than Dixon expresses. Blockchain technology itself is still in the garage tinkerer stage. Yet in terms of economic valuations, it has prematurely gone eons beyond that. </p><p>As of this writing, the market capitalization of the global cryptocurrency industry is well more than $2 trillion USD. Usually, an industry of such size is created after people have already built something that has proven to be socially useful. In this case, the fortunes have come first, and the utility is still based on vague future promises of redemption. With some noble exceptions like stablecoins, all that has actually been built today with this money is a giant global casino and tool for evading capital controls, along with an endless stream of beguiling promises and motivational stories worthy of the book <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691182292/narrative-economics?srsltid=AfmBOop3d79gU8Vutm-8RtNFmbm3tELIa-LcHt4NSy4NyuHSIfeJBLNU"><em>Narrative Economics</em></a>.</p><p>As I see it this unorthodox sequencing, where the riches came long before the utility, is not just a mistake that will smooth itself out over time. It is a mortal threat to the technology itself ever reaching its potential.</p><p><strong>Can't Be Evil, but Already Evil</strong></p><p>Google had a famous corporate motto at one time, "Don't be Evil." While partly tongue-in-cheek, it recognized that great power and wealth naturally create a moral hazard to act in ways that run counter to the public interest. Eventually, Google changed this motto, along with its name, presumably as it embraced a little bit of evil as the inevitable byproduct of growing to such an economic scale.</p><p>Dixon sees blockchain as a technology that prevents future evil transformations by Big Tech. “Blockchain networks turn 'Don’t be evil' into 'Can’t be evil," he writes. "Their architecture provides strong guarantees that their data and code will forever remain open and remixable.”</p><p>As he describes it, corporate platforms inevitably move towards an "extraction" phase where they start squeezing their users as much as possible for financial gain to the detriment of the platform. He makes a compelling case that Twitter and Facebook would've been better off run as protocols, in the style of email, or potentially as blockchain-based services, such that no censorious or profit-hungry CEO could ever turn them against their users.</p><p>Yet while the technology itself is neutral, Dixon's reference to corporate "evil" brings me to an important point about the blockchain and cryptocurrency industry itself: It's already evil. </p><p>Cryptocurrency has its own galaxy of CEOs, investors, VCs, many of whom have already gotten fabulously rich from a technology whose use-case is perpetually somewhere in the hazy distance. While it has not yet transformed the world, or even the internet, for the better, the blockchain industry has already gotten into lots of robber-baron stuff like lobbying politicians for favorable treatment, elite financial self-dealing, catastrophic investor scandals, and other activities people usually associate with the worst evils of the corporate world.</p><p>On top of this there is the incredible rise in ransomware exploitation using cryptocurrency (much of it unreported) which, while not an indictment of crypto itself, greatly exceeds the volume of people using it today for noble purposes like sending remittance payments to rural Congolese villages cut off from Western Union. </p><p>We are thus left with the unsettling reality of an industry that became "evil" before it became useful. It should be no surprise then that much of the public has soured on it. One can dismiss this hostility to crypto as Luddism, "wokeness," or atavistic hostility to progress, but in my assessment it is a rational and understandable response to what has taken place to date.</p><p>Many blockchain developers downplay concerns about current conditions by insisting that the technology is "early," or that we are in "1999 of the internet" (the year is never really consistent). After a decade and a half since Bitcoin first launched, this no longer strikes me as a passable argument. The idea that technology is naturally teleological and grows from phase to phase by nature seems closer to the realm of religious expectation than rational analysis. Lots of great promises experience a failure to launch, and this is in fact closer to the norm historically.</p><p>For all the incredible financial and political weight of the blockchain industry, there are only estimated to be around 22,000 actual developers working on blockchain projects at the moment. According to recent statistics that number is actually <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://crypto.news/number-of-blockchain-developers-slid-by-24-in-2023-data-shows/\"><em>decreasing</em></a><em>. </em></p><p>While that does not mean that the technology itself is dead or holds no promise, it suggests that the gap between the vastly overgrown "casino," whose proponents are already funding elections and rewriting laws in their interest, and the dimunitive "computer," still sitting idle in a garage somewhere, may be even more lopsided than it appears.</p><p><strong>Revolutionary Suicide</strong></p><p>Representatives of the blockchain world enjoy deeming themselves "inevitable," holders of privileged knowledge, the persecuted opponents of an unworthy and corrupt establishment, and a would-be counter elite in waiting. I have heard such arguments before. </p><p>While covering the Syrian Civil War, I listened to opposition leaders, many of them wealthy and globally-connected, make powerful critiques of the regime that they were trying to overthrow. The regime was indeed very bad, and in the early days the opposition seemed to have a slam-dunk case. But it didn't work out that way. Unfortunately, in part due to the rebels own inability to self-police and build attractive governance under their control, the majority of the population eventually wound up siding with the devil that they knew. The regime change many of us thought was inevitable in 2011 simply never happened. Such is the fate of many aborted revolutions.</p><p>Things might have gone better in Syria with some more unsparing self-scrutiny by the opposition, which is also true for any human endeavor. I have been waiting a long time to hear some serious self-criticism from the crypto industry, whose culture seems to be characterized more by standard Panglossian corporate boosterism, mixed with expectations of rapture and other religious sentiments seemingly inherent to the creation of a new type of money. </p><p>Cryptocurrency was a revolutionary technology when it launched, but the revolution has already seemingly been corrupted. The lack of accountability, exploitation, and other shortcomings of many of its present champions has had the effect of alienating much of the public and pushing them back into the arms of the establishment that it was supposed to topple. Even I have developed some previously unfelt warm feelings towards the New York Times and Chase Bank after seeing the behavior of many of our new would-be overlords.</p><p><strong>Physician, Heal Thyself</strong></p><p>You can call me a hater for these harsh comments (In fact, I have been deemed an "establishment shill" by individuals whose net worth I estimate to be between 800-1200x greater than my own). But at the end of the day, I'm writing this article on Paragraph for the benefit of people who use Farcaster, which is a platform I want to help grow. I don't hate cryptocurrency or blockchain, and even play around with them on the margins. I like the internet in general, and am impressed with some past innovations produced by Silicon Valley. I just want this industry to live up to the grand promises that it is constantly making.</p><p>In cryptocurrency, we have a very sick patient who will need an aggressive and painful course of treatment to be cured. Responsible regulation is a given, but the effects also need to be considered. For the computer to ever live, the casino must be drastically cut down to size, if not shut down entirely. </p><p>It gives me no pleasure to say this as someone who holds a few cryptocurrency assets, but the best thing for the future of blockchain would be if its $2 trillion USD present market cap were cut down by 80-90 percent in the short-term, either by regulation or rigorous industry self-policing. Such a decrease would shut down the many grifters, scam artists, and opportunists who tend to crowd around casinos, both online and offline, and give the public square back to those computer-based yeomen who are really committed to the noble vision of "Read, Write, Own." It would also allow a chance for a reset with the public, who can be reintroduced to blockchain again on humbler terms.</p><p>Such an unsavory prospect would probably not appeal to the many people who have gotten wealthy from cryptocurrency already, or who today feel the need to intellectually justify their wealth through various political endeavors. But if anyone is really serious about decentralization, disintermediation, anti-censorship, and many other lofty ideals, the clamor of the casino needs to flicker off for awhile, until the computer can make something worthwhile to society.</p><p>We all want to go to the moon, and there is no shame in that. But to get to the moon, you need to build something that is worthy of taking you there. And you need to build it <em>first</em>.</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p></p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>unmediatedthoughts@newsletter.paragraph.com (Murtaza)</author>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A View from Far(caster) Afield]]></title>
            <link>https://paragraph.com/@unmediatedthoughts/a-view-from-farcaster-afield</link>
            <guid>3wFUQLpvYSfXIfA8wCBU</guid>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Aug 2024 12:40:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <description><![CDATA[On an balmy afternoon in early July, while sitting in traffic on a long drive home, my mind was working overtime gaming out my next inves...]]></description>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On an balmy afternoon in early July, while sitting in traffic on a long drive home, my mind was working overtime gaming out my next investigative reporting story – an <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://www.dropsitenews.com/p/pakistan-military-social-media-program">expose</a> of a top-secret Pakistani military social media manipulation operation.</p><p>While my thoughts drifted miles away from the North Jersey traffic, the buzz of my cellphone jolted me back to the moment. On the phone was a longtime <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://theintercept.com/2019/06/09/heshmat-alavi-fake-iran-mek/">reporting</a> contact (<a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow ugc" class="dont-break-out" href="https://theintercept.com/2021/08/01/saudi-arabia-twitter-harassment-jamal-khashoggi/">and onetime subject</a>) that I knew from my stories, a social media forensics expert and general techie named Geoff Golberg. </p><p>Geoff was returning my own call from earlier that week.&nbsp;I had asked him to get in touch with me to review some information related to the secret program, and to see if he could provide any analysis drawn from his own expertise. After we chatted for a few moments about the report, with him promising to provide me a few quotes, I prepared to hang up and continue my drive. </p><p>But before I did, Geoff said that there was something else that he wanted to run by me.</p><p>"Hey, you know I'm also on this app called Farcaster, you should really try it, it'd be great if more people like you were using it!," he said.</p><p>As is common with me, my thoughts were so consumed with the story that I was working on that I didn't even fully process his comment. I had never really been interested in Bluesky, Mastodon, Threads, or any of the other Twitter alternatives (despite my growing dissatisfaction with Twitter) so I had gotten used to tuning out such requests anyways.</p><p>Mumbling, that I'd look into it, Geoff then added something that caught my attention.</p><p>"There's a crypto part of it too!"</p><p>Interesting!</p><p>Geoff, who I'd later discover is a voluble presence in the Farcaster community, gave me a few more brief details about the platform and where to sign up. As I merged on to the highway exit back towards New York, I told him I'd check it out. </p><p>That night, before going to bed, I logged into the Warpcast website, paid the nominal five dollar fee to get started, and created my account. </p><p>Thus began the journey that surprisingly brought me to writing this post today. </p><p><strong>Airdropping on the Boardwalk</strong></p><p>I'm a bit of an oddity among non-tech people in that I'm curious about cryptocurrency and blockchain. This is not primarily for purposes of speculation and generating wealth (although those are great), but due to my own moderate libertarian views about privacy and financial sovereignty.</p><p>I had worked with Edward Snowden as a journalist years ago, and have met enough refugees and political prisoners to know that being able to safeguard your information and capital in a place protected from political exigency can be solid insurance against future oppression.</p><p>This is what I like about crypto, and why I hold my nose about the gauche financialization, rampant scamming, political myopia that otherwise surrounds the industry and continue to pay it some interest.</p><p>The first thing I noticed when logging onto Warpcast is that it feels a lot like a much sleeker version of Twitter. The addition of channels makes it easier to segment information, and prevents the informational chaos that Twitter has devolved into today. </p><p>Although some people seemingly have hundreds of thousands of followers on the platform, as far as I can tell Farcaster is actually a much smaller community than that. It feels more like a village. Accordingly, I got village-like hospitality upon logging on the first time, with innumerable people sending me personal messages of welcome and even offering to set up calls to help me learn about it. This is certainly a stark contrast to Twitter, which feels more like accidentally walking into a bar brawl.</p><p>Another thing I noticed was that people were sending me casts that included the terms HAM, DEGEN, and MASKS. At first I wasn't sure if this was some kind of gesture of respect or insult (300 HAM sent to guy named "Hussain" = Hate crime??), but as it turned out people were kindly sending me "tips" of cryptocurrency as a welcome. Later on, another currency called MOXIE would be introduced whose distribution was even more streamlined into the platform.</p><p>I had no idea where I could find this cryptocurrency that was apparently mine, and there was no real explanation from it evident on the platform. But because of my preexisting familiarity with the subject I was able to deduce that these were essentially airdrops that I could claim from my MetaMask wallet. </p><p>Because of how atypical it is for a social media platform to generate revenue for its user, I almost couldn't believe this was happening. To prove the concept was real I actually went and claimed these airdrops, swapped them to USDC, and then cashed them out to my bank account. </p><p>As it turned, out the cryptocurrency that I was receiving for the mere act of posting – something that comes as naturally to me as breathing at this point – was totally real, liquid, and even had accumulated enough in a week to pay for a pleasant meal out for myself and my wife.</p><p>As Sacha Baron Cohen would say, "very nice!"</p><p><strong>Cast Away</strong></p><p>Warpcast has a relatively narrow range of subject matter being discussed, as the platform mostly seems to consist of people into coding, software, computer science, and other things that are specific to one industry. I get the sense that many people have preexisting relationships IRL, or are at most a degree of separation away. The culture of the platform accordingly feels like an industry networking event, or a lively employees-only corporate Slack channel.</p><p>I don't know much about software or computer science so there is not much I can do to join in such conversations. But I do know about reporting, foreign affairs, politics, language, and philosophy, all of which I love to discuss, so I began casting in earnest about those topics. After being kindly gifted thousands of "Warps" by other users welcoming me onboard, I even started my own channel to serve as a platform for global affairs commentary and news updates. At present it has nearly 600 subscribers, and I'm quite pleased with it.</p><p>Despite the generally tech-centric nature of the platform, I've also found that there are quite a few people with significant knowledge of literature and politics lurking around here too. I've been surprised on numerous occasions by the erudition and worldliness of a few people I've met on Warpcast – sort of like being at the coffee machine at work and running into someone who had an interesting past life as a journeyman adventurer or literary savant. When there are fewer people in a community, the qualities of each individual person tend to shine through more brightly, and you do find that on Farcaster.</p><p>Because its a smaller platform as well, there is less incentive to get into fights, and instead more of a focus on collegial conversation, even on areas of disagreement. I'm a person who has unilaterally injected politics into Warpcast and intruded on peoples discussions of tokens and cryptocurrency market prices, and sometimes it does feel a bit strange doing that. Politics, after all, is inherently polarizing. But although some people do heatedly direct cast me to debate now and then, everyone on the platform is quite relaxed and easygoing in general. </p><p><strong>Far(caster) Ahead</strong></p><p>Am I going to continue to use Farcaster? Yeah, I think so.</p><p>I have around 7500 followers now, many of whom are not bots, and I do feel a sense of responsibility to people who have followed me or tipped me because they like my commentary.</p><p>I enjoy casting in general, everything from deep philosophical ruminations to frivolous memes, and I'm enjoying the casual culture of the platform which has less pressure than more developed platforms. Casting is not work, its something I do to unwind, and its great to also get rewarded in DEGEN and MOXIE or whatever else to do what I'd be doing for free on Twitter anyways.</p><p>I've frequently offered my unsolicited advice on how to improve Farcaster and I will do that again by saying that to make it popular its important to promote it to people who are outside the world of cryptocurrency and technology generally. </p><p>You need what I would call "news influencers." These are people who either report new information like actual journalists, or who simply enjoy discourse and debate and whose presence makes a social media platform a nonstop rollicking conversation, as Twitter was in its heydey.</p><p>There is a sort of rivalry between Silicon Valley and journalism, and as I gather Farcaster is somehow part of a broader attempt by SV people to create a new frontier with their own information distribution channels. I have a lot of thoughts about this rivalry, which I find mostly asinine and ego-driven, that I might write about in future. But I don't think that you can really have a social media platform that does not include society as a whole, including all the messy and conflictual parts. </p><p>On a personal level, I'm enjoying using the platform and feel gratified to be rewarded and recognized a bit for my casts. When my social media manipulation story eventually came out this August, I made sure to share it in my Warpcast channel right away. I got lots of shocked comments from my followers, who were also interested and supportive when I shared in the days thereafter that the military was now threatening to sue me. (I'm fine by the way.)</p><p>I'm going to be dealing with that stuff for awhile now and that may take up some of my focus. </p><p>But in the meantime, I'm going to keep posting on Farcaster and engaging with the community. My verdict on the platform? So far, so good.</p><p></p><p></p><p></p>]]></content:encoded>
            <author>unmediatedthoughts@newsletter.paragraph.com (Murtaza)</author>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>