2022 Forbes Top 20 Consumer Vibrant Cities in China Chongqing ranked 3rd, beating Guangzhou, Xi'an was ahead of Tianjin, ranking 11th, Shenyang was 14th, higher than Hefei. As the largest city in the west, it is indeed extraordinary in terms of consumption vitality. In 2022, Forbes ranked No. 3 among the top 20 consumer cities in China, which is the existence of the two first-tier cities, Guangzhou and Shenzhen. Xi'an is ahead of Tianjin and has become the most dynamic city in the entire northern region, second only to Beijing, and ranks 11th in the country. Shenyang is still your "big brother". Among the cities with dynamic consumption, Shenyang ranks 14th in the country, higher than Hefei, which has developed rapidly in recent years, and is tied with Ningbo. What do you think about this?