Start typing to search this publication.
Brandon Donnelly logo Brandon Donnelly
Open menu
Brandon Donnelly logo

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Brandon Donnelly — Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly. — Page 135

Utah creates new Condominium Construction Loan Program

  • Utah
  • Starter-home
  • First-time-homebuyers

The state of Utah is trying to build 35,000 starter homes over the next five years. Last year, $300 million was allocated to something known as the Utah Homes Investment Program (UHIP). The initial idea was that these funds would be provided as low-cost deposits to financial institutions so that they could, in turn, offer low-interest loans to homebuilders who committed to building single-family starter homes.

But this didn’t go as planned. Apparently, the low-cost deposits weren’t low enough to compensate for the perceived lending risk. So Governor Cox asked if the funds could instead be directed to the Utah Housing Corporation. Enter the Condominium Construction Loan Program. The way this newly created program works is that UHC can now provide low-cost loans — up to 100% LTC — directly to developers.

However, there are some stipulations:

  • Warrantable projects: The projects must be warrantable to the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation, meaning the property and the individual condominium units need to be eligible for conventional mortgage financing.

  • Owner-occupancy requirement: The individual condominium units must be sold to an owner-occupant, with a recorded deed restriction in place for a period of not less than five years. This is obviously to stop investors from buying and reselling.

  • Equity sharing: The equity appreciation on the condominium unit is shared between UHC and the first owner-occupant. The homeowner earns 75% of the equity appreciation (15% per full year of occupancy, through five years), with the balance going to UHC upon sale of the unit.

So it’s a trade-off: buyers get access to new homes at below-market pricing (because the developer’s cost structure is reduced), and in exchange, they give up some of the potential upside. Will it work and help Utah achieve its starter home goal by 2030? I don’t know. But it’s clear recognition that if you want to deliver below-market housing, you need to provide subsidies.

Algorithms control our thoughts

  • Prof-g
  • Mark-cuban
  • Social-media

This week has been a busy one, but I managed to get through this recent Prof G Markets interview with Mark Cuban while on the road and in between meetings. I like Mark Cuban. He comes across as likable and balanced. He's also pretty good at making money.

The conversation covers a lot of topics: AI, why AI could change the way we design housing, healthcare, the media landscape, social media algorithms, why it should be easier to be a public company, and what Cuban would do if he were president of the US, among others. If you're interested in these topics, maybe have a listen.

The discussion around social media algorithms struck a bit of a chord. At one point, Cuban makes the statement that this is one of the underlying challenges facing the US: whoever controls the algorithms controls our thoughts. He goes on to say that the social media algorithms know his kids better than he does.

Algorithms also shape our cities. Everything these days is being reverse-engineered for the attention economy. Typically, this means promoting more extreme views, instead of measured ones, which can drive a further wedge between cyclists and motorists, existing communities and new developments, and so on.

We know all this. But it's scary to think about the influence it has on our behaviors.

Riz Dhanji on Toronto's housing market

Riz Dhanji, who is the founder and president of RAD Marketing, is a long-time partner of ours. We are working together on One Delisle and on our waterfront project in the Niagara Benchlands. Riz has worked on some of Canada's most high-profile development projects, has been through past cycles, and has even sold real estate to Elton John. That's something.

So today, I'm happy to share this recent Livabl podcast that he appeared on with host Matthew Slutsky.

One theme that you'll notice in the episode is the focus on end-user buyers. Talk to anyone in the condominium business and they'll tell you that these are the few active buyers today. Investors are largely sitting on the sidelines. On the surface, this should be a healthy reset for the market — a refocusing on the actual customer. It’s also, in my opinion, a generational opportunity for buyers.

But what I continue to find ironic is the number of end-users who also remain sidelined. For years, pundits loved to criticize Toronto's new home market for being too geared toward investors. The argument was that it was a market based on speculation and that investors were crowding out real people from fulfilling their basic shelter needs. Developers were creating financial assets, not homes.

Now the pundits have gotten exactly what they wanted: less speculation, less competition, and lower prices. So where, then, are all the end-users? Why are they not banging down the doors of sales galleries and saying, "Thank goodness — we're no longer being crowded out?"

Instead, what has happened is that the market has stalled out and new housing supply has largely shut off (the effects of which won’t be felt for a few more years).

The question now is what will it look like once it returns. Who will be the buyers? Like every market, most people prefer to buy when everyone else is buying the same thing. So I suspect many end-users are waiting until there's more activity (i.e. competition). But when that time comes, they won't be the only buyers in the market.

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly.