Start typing to search this publication.
Brandon Donnelly logo Brandon Donnelly
Open menu
Brandon Donnelly logo

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Brandon Donnelly — Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly. — Page 169

Cover image for Cities are forcing short-term rentals to evolve

Cities are forcing short-term rentals to evolve

  • Aparthotel
  • Serviced-apartment
  • Airbnb

Most global cities now have restrictions, and in some cases an effective ban, on short-term rentals. Here are some examples, along with their annual nightly rental cap as I understand them (and by this, I mean what ChatGPT is telling me):

  • Berlin: Secondary residence rentals are limited to 90 days per year

  • London: Annual cap of 90 nights

  • Mexico City: Annual cap of 180 nights

  • New York City: Only host-present stays allowed

  • Paris: Annual cap of 120 nights

  • Rio de Janeiro: Annual cap of 90 nights

  • San Francisco: Annual cap of 90 nights

  • Singapore: Minimum stay of 3 months for private properties and 6 months for HDB properties (Singapore's public housing authority)

  • Sydney: Annual cap of 180 nights

  • Toronto: Annual cap of 180 nights

These rules and caps will have nuances to them. Like if you want to rent your place on the third Tuesday of a month and your property faces west and has a view of an outdoor terrace with no more than 6 brass bistro tables, you probably require a special license. Okay, this isn't true. But broadly speaking, most cities now have strict caps in the range of 90-180 nights and differentiate between whole-home rentals and host-present stays.

What this, of course, means is that most big cities don't want people operating short-term rentals as a business. They'd like hosts to be people who maybe rent out their place while they're away on vacation and/or offer up an extra room when some conference or event is taking place in town. In other words, cities do not want short-term rentals to negatively impact their supply of long-term rentals.

It's no wonder that Airbnb is investing heavily in both its "experiences" and "services." It has to do this because its core "homes" business is facing significant regulatory headwinds. But what this also means is that the hospitality industry is now shifting toward other solutions — things like aparthotels/serviced apartments. These are purpose-built solutions that typically require commercial zoning.

Globally, the aparthotel segment is expected to be the fastest-growing subset in commercial lodging for the remainder of this decade. And that makes sense. With STR regulations only becoming more stringent and with the continued rise of digital nomadism, the demand for this kind of apartment-like product is going to need to be satisfied in other ways.

There's clearly a market for kitchens, washing machines, and a bit more space.

Cover photo by Aquilion Property on Unsplash

Cover image for Do you even develop, bro?

Do you even develop, bro?

  • Development
  • Real-estate
  • Land-development

In yesterday's post I spoke about the practice of buying land, rezoning it for a higher-and-better use, and then selling it for a margin. It may not make economic sense to do this in the current market, but it remains an important step in the delivery of new homes and other forms of real assets. Before you can build, you need entitled land.

But as I have mentioned before, there are people who look down upon this practice. They view it as a form of land speculation; one that just drives up land prices and doesn't ultimately create anything of tangible value. They might even go so far as to say that, if this is what you do, then you aren't actually a real estate developer!

Of course, this would be false and it shows a lack of understanding of how development works. It's also insulting to developers who work hard in this part of the business.

Let's consider Wikipedia's definition of development:

Real estate development, or property development, is a business process, encompassing activities that range from the renovation and re-lease of existing buildings to the purchase of raw land and the sale of developed land or parcels to others. Real estate developers are the people and companies who coordinate all of these activities, converting ideas from paper to real property. Real estate development is different from construction or housebuilding, although many developers also manage the construction process or engage in housebuilding.

The two most important points for this discussion are bolded. One, development includes a range of activities that might include the sale of land or parcels to others. And two, real estate development is distinct from construction or housebuilding. So the more accurate way to describe a developer who sells land and doesn't build is to call them a developer who isn't also a builder. It's that simple.

But more important than nomenclature is the fact that there's nothing inherently wrong with securing development approvals and then passing off the land to a builder to complete the rest. Somebody has to do it.

Entitling a site often takes years — sometimes even decades. It’s a process that creates value and serves as a prerequisite to building new homes. Whether it’s done by one company or two shouldn’t matter.

Cover photo by Alexander Tsang on Unsplash

Cover image for Land prices have been flat

Land prices have been flat

  • Toronto
  • Development-land
  • Land-economics

At the end of last year, I wrote this post arguing that development value has shifted from land to the build. And in it, I argued that it's no longer viable to be a high-density land developer in Toronto. The practice of buying land, rezoning it for a higher-and-better use, and then selling it for a margin, is over — at least for the time being.

It's also not easy to find value in the execution of new builds, but it's a better place to be looking. Because today, as we underwrite new development sites, we are seeing land prices (on a per buildable square foot) that are similar to what they were back in 2017 when we were assembling the land for Junction House. Meaning that, in some cases, land prices have been nearly flat over this 8 year period. This is despite a total inflation rate of approximately 25% and an average annual decline in the value of money of 2.86%.

This is not all that surprising, though. Land should, in theory, be the residual claimant in a development pro forma; so it should be one of the first things to reset during a market downturn. However, in the past, I have referred to land prices as being sticky in the face of changing cost structures, such as development charge increases and/or new inclusionary zoning policies. So which is it, Brandon?

Well, one way I think about this is that land prices tend to be sticky in the short term. Nobody wants to immediately take a loss. And as long as prices/rents continue to exhibit strong growth, there's a chance that these new costs will get absorbed into somebody's pro forma and that land prices won't need to adjust downward. But turn off demand and reverse price/rent growth, and now there's no other option but for land prices to come down.

This is what we've been seeing in Toronto since 2022.

Cover photo by Adam Vradenburg on Unsplash

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly.