"GP sold my share without my consent"

This article comes from the cooperative media: China investment network, author: Tao Huidong. Cloud hunting is authorized to release.

“GP sold my share without my consent.” Recently, Wang Zhaoqian to make complaints about the Internet Tucao encountered a bad thing.

Wang Zhaoqian is a limited partner of a venture capital fund “Shenzhen collaborative innovation tourism industry investment partnership (limited partnership)” (hereinafter referred to as collaborative innovation fund). Collaborative innovation fund is a single project fund, which invests in vertical technology of autonomous start-up companies.

At present, the income of collaborative innovation fund should be very good - Zongmu technology officially announced a round D financing of US $190 million in June 2021, and the development momentum is very good.

However, Wang Zhaoqian told China investment network that in May 2021, he was suddenly informed by the GP that he had withdrawn from the partnership and was no longer the LP of Collaborative Innovation Fund.

According to the statistics of China Foundation Association, by the end of January 2022, there were more than 31000 private equity investment funds and more than 15000 venture capital funds in China, a record high. With the growing prosperity of China’s venture capital industry and more and more venture capital funds, disputes between GP and LP have become common, and the causes of disputes are also various. However, what Wang Zhaoqian said was that the shares were sold without consent, which is still somewhat appalling.

With doubt, China investment network also contacted Li Wanshou, the manager of collaborative innovation fund and the actual controller of Collaborative Innovation Fund Management Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as collaborative capital). Wang Zhaoqian said that he had taken the initiative to fight for the best interests of Wanshou capital.

What the hell is going on?

Previously, Wang Zhaoqian has filed an application for arbitration with the Shenzhen International Arbitration Court, and the arbitration tribunal has also made an award. For more than 15000 GP and more LP in China, the result of the case should provide some reference on how to safeguard their legitimate rights and interests and avoid and resolve unnecessary disputes.

A rising Unicorn has been invested by Xiaomi

This event dates back to 2016, when Wang Zhaoqian and nine other investors jointly funded and established the collaborative innovation fund. According to the industrial and commercial publicity information, the total contribution of the fund is 19.2 million yuan, of which Wang Zhaoqian subscribed 1 million yuan and held 5.20833% of the fund.

Then, the collaborative innovation fund completed its investment in Zongmu technology. According to the public transfer statement disclosed by Zongmu technology when it was listed on the new third board in 2017, on June 21, 2016, collaborative innovation fund signed the equity transfer agreement with collaborative Hesheng, which transferred its 10% equity of Zongmu technology and its contribution obligation of RMB 1987.5 million to collaborative innovation at the price of RMB 125000.

Synergy Hesheng is also an equity investment fund. The manager is Shenzhen Zhaoyin synergy Fund Management Co., Ltd. in fact, the controller is also Li Wanshou.

In short, the collaborative innovation fund acquired 10% of the shares of Zongmu technology at the price of 20 million yuan in 2016, so the valuation of the latter should be 200 million yuan at that time.

Since then, Zongmu technology chose to delist from the new third board at the end of 2017. The financial data are unknown, but from the perspective of financing momentum, it has developed very rapidly. There is at least one round of financing every year, and the amount is getting larger and larger. It has become a star company of automatic driving track. At the end of 2021, Zongmu technology was selected into the annual Unicorn list in the field of automobile transportation selected by the media.

In June 2021, Zongmu technology announced that it had officially completed round D financing with a cumulative amount of 190 million US dollars. Previously, Zongmu technology completed the D1 round of financing invested by Japan electric equipment leading investment, Chongqing Liangjiang New Area equity investment fund, Huzhou Taihu Lake Group and Jingkai capital. The D2 round of Zongmu technology is led by Tongchuang Weiye, Gaoyuan capital and Langtai capital, and the D3 round is led by Xiaomi Changjiang industry fund. The investors include many well-known domestic investment institutions: Fosun (Chongqing) private equity investment fund, Shanghai Science and innovation investment group, industrial bank and strategic investors Chongqing Changxin Zhiqi private equity investment fund and keboda Investment Holding Co., Ltd, The old shareholders Junlian capital, Qualcomm venture capital and Jingkai capital continued to follow the investment.

Despite multiple rounds of dilution, industrial and commercial information shows that the collaborative innovation fund is still the seventh largest shareholder of Zongmu technology, holding 4.18776% of its shares. Although Zongmu technology did not disclose the latest round of financing valuation, the financing amount alone was six times the total valuation when the collaborative innovation fund was invested five years ago. The return of the fund is obviously considerable.

A dispute caused by wechat

Despite the good development momentum of investment projects, Wang Zhaoqian, as a Collaborative Innovation Fund LP, had a retreat in early 2021, and finally fell out with GP collaborative capital, so that he went to court.

On February 18, 2022, the Shenzhen International Arbitration Court has made an arbitration award on the case. According to the facts identified in the award, the course of events can be roughly restored.

The starting point of the dispute was at noon on March 22, 2021. At that time, the wechat group of collaborative innovation fund discussed the fund extension. Wang Zhaoqian expressed his objection and said: “I don’t agree with five years”. At the same time, Wang Zhaoqian also put forward the requirement of withdrawal: “I hope to withdraw now”. Wang Zhaoqian’s statement in the wechat group has since become the focus of this case.

For the reasons for the withdrawal, Wang Zhaoqian told China investment network that after investing in the collaborative innovation fund, his communication with the GP side was not smooth, and he had lost trust in them, so he hoped to withdraw as soon as possible. Wang Zhaoqian also told China investment network that he also invested in many other funds of collaborative capital, and put a question mark on his investment ability.

In addition to Wang Zhaoqian, there was another LP who proposed to withdraw at that time. After receiving the exit request from the two LPS, the cooperative capital made relevant arrangements. Four days later, the staff of collaborative capital sent a message in the wechat group to mention the exit price, pointing out that it was calculated according to the total valuation of Zongmu technology of 3 billion yuan. Wang Zhaoqian did not ask whether he could, but said, “thank you” and asked “can I return this month?”

Then the time came. On April 9, 2021, synergetic capital introduced the exit plan in wechat group. Synergetic innovation fund will sell some shares of Zongmu technology and return the obtained funds to Wang