Abstract:

Space exploration as a solution to Earth's resource scarcity involves debates on the feasibility of colonizing celestial bodies. Challenges include high financial costs, technological hurdles, and environmental risks. Critics argue that efforts should focus on Earth's environmental issues, like climate change, before embarking on space colonization. Supporters see space exploration as vital for scientific discovery, human survival through off-Earth colonies, and fulfilling the human urge to explore new frontiers.

Three perspectives: 

1. Against: Focus on challenges here on earth    

Zahaan Bharmal, who works for Google and is a recipient of Nasa’s Exceptional Public Achievement Medal for YouTube Space Lab contends that efforts to colonize Mars overlook more urgent challenges on Earth, such as climate change. He raises concerns about the potential contamination of Mars with Earth's microbes, which could hinder the search for Martian life. Bharmal advocates for focusing resources and attention on solving our planet's environmental crises before pursuing colonization of another. This perspective prioritizes Earth's sustainability over the expansion of humanity into space.

👉 Read: the space economy - 6 opportunities for innovators

1. In-between: Explore but don't colonise

Dr. Pamela Conrad advocates for a non-colonial approach to space exploration, emphasizing respect and non-interference in line with Star Trek's Prime Directive. She criticizes current ambitions to mine the moon and other celestial bodies for resources, suggesting instead that humanity should adopt the role of "gentle explorers." Conrad's perspective highlights the ethical implications of viewing space as merely an opportunity for exploitation, urging a shift towards exploration that honors the rights and traditions of all, including Indigenous perspectives on celestial bodies.

👉 Read: the commercial space age is here (HBR)

1. Pro: Space is the new digital

Marc Ventresca equates the burgeoning commercial space industry's impact to that of the digital revolution, suggesting that the future will see every company becoming a space company, much like every company today is a technology company. With $8.9 billion invested in space-related ventures in 2020 and projections of the global space industry reaching over $1 trillion by 2040, the sector is ripe for growth. This new space age invites firms from diverse industries to leverage their expertise, akin to the early days of the automobile industry, signaling a significant transformation and integration of space capabilities into various business sectors.

👉 Watch: Space venturing, lessons learned, and differences with other sectors

Bonus perspectives

SpaceX: Musk

Elon Musk's ambition to colonize Mars is fueled by a desire to safeguard humanity's future through multi-planetary habitation and to reignite the spirit of exploration. He envisions this endeavor as a unifying mission that inspires optimism and advances human discovery. Through SpaceX's Starship, he aims to make space travel feasible and affordable, facilitating the establishment of a self-sustaining Martian society governed by direct democracy. Musk sees these challenges as vital steps toward expanding human potential and ensuring our species' long-term survival.

Blue Origin: Bezos

Jeff Bezos advocates for colonizing the solar system with humans living in giant cylindrical space stations, rather than on planetary surfaces. He believes these space habitats, inspired by O'Neill cylinders, could support a trillion humans, offering a life full of resources, intelligence, and energy. Bezos' vision includes creating environments with normal Earth gravity and positioning these habitats to maximize energy and resource use, aiming to accelerate his space company, Blue Origin, to realize this future.

Noteworthy Concepts:

• CubeSat: A type of miniaturized satellite for space research that is made up of multiples of 10×10×10 cm cubic units. CubeSats have become a popular choice for space research and commercial missions due to their low cost, modular design, and ease of deployment.

• Terraforming: The hypothetical process of deliberately modifying the atmosphere, temperature, surface topography, or ecology of a planet, moon, or other body to make it habitable for Earth life, primarily humans. This concept is a staple of science fiction and future space colonization discussions.

• Exoplanet: A planet located outside our Solar System, orbiting a star other than the Sun. The study of exoplanets involves searching for planets that might have conditions suitable for life as we know it, and understanding the diversity of planetary systems.

• Space Debris: Refers to defunct human-made objects in space—mainly in Earth orbit—which no longer serve a useful function. This includes spent rocket stages, old satellites, and fragments from disintegration, erosion, and collisions. Space debris poses a threat to space missions and satellites due to potential collisions.

• Asteroid Mining: The exploitation of raw materials from asteroids and other minor planets, including near-Earth objects. Metals, water, and other valuable materials can be extracted and returned to Earth or used in space for construction materials, fuel, and life support.