Contents
Adding a signup box to a website is easy. Getting people to fill it in, and keeping the list healthy once they do, takes a little more thought.
How do I set up an email signup form for my newsletter?
Pick an email tool to hold your list, build a form inside it, then paste the code it gives you into your site. Most tools work the same way, so the steps below apply whichever one you choose.
-
Choose where your list lives. This is the tool that stores subscribers and sends your emails. Some include signup forms on a free plan, including MailerLite [9] and Paragraph [2].
-
Build the form. Keep it to an email field and a button. Add a line that says what readers get and how often.
-
Copy the embed code. Mailchimp generates code you add to the backend of the page where the form should appear [8]. Beehiiv gives you an HTML snippet to copy and paste [11]. Paragraph gives you an iframe embed code in your settings [7].
-
Paste it into your site. Check how it looks live. Mailchimp's embedded forms inherit your site's style sheet, so they can look different on your site than in the editor [8].
-
Test it. Sign up with your own address and confirm the email arrives.
If you don't want to touch code yet, share a direct link instead. On Paragraph, adding /subscribe to your publication URL sends people straight to a signup page [7].
Where should the signup form go on my website?
Put it where readers already are: at the end of posts, on your homepage, and on any page people reach from search or social. One form on a contact page rarely gets seen.
The form type matters too. Inline forms sit inside the page and don't interrupt reading. Pop-ups and slide-ins are harder to miss, so use them with restraint.
If your blog and newsletter run on the same platform, you may not need to place anything by hand. A Paragraph site includes subscribe prompts on every post and page [3].
How do I get more people to sign up?
Give people a clear reason to join, make signing up take seconds, and ask at the right moment. Small changes to the offer and the placement are the easiest place to start.
-
Say what they'll get. "Weekly product notes for early-stage founders" tells a reader far more than "Subscribe to our newsletter."
-
Ask for less. An email address is enough to start.
-
Offer something useful. A checklist, template, or short guide gives a reader a reason to sign up today.
-
Ask after you've earned it. The end of a strong post is a natural place to invite a reader back.
-
Keep the list real. MailerLite supports double opt-in to confirm consent and reCAPTCHA to block bots [9]. A smaller list of real readers is worth more than a large one full of fake signups.
That last point affects deliverability. Gmail advises sending only to people who want your messages, since they're less likely to report you as spam [13].
Which newsletter signup tool should I use?
If you already have a website and only need a list, a dedicated email tool like Mailchimp or MailerLite fits well. If you want your blog, newsletter, and list in one place, a publishing platform like Beehiiv or Paragraph saves setup.
| Tool | How the form gets on your site | Worth knowing |
|---|---|---|
| Mailchimp | Generated code added to your page [8] | Inherits your site's styles [8] |
| MailerLite | Signup forms on the free plan [9] | Double opt-in and reCAPTCHA [9] |
| Beehiiv | Copy-paste HTML snippet [11] | Works on WordPress, Webflow, Squarespace, Shopify [11] |
| Paragraph | Built into every post and page, or iframe embed and | Forms and basic sending free forever [2] |
MailerLite is the better pick if you want double opt-in and bot protection on a free plan [9]. Beehiiv suits you if your site runs on one of the platforms it lists and you want a snippet you can drop in [11]. Mailchimp works if you're happy for the form to take on your site's existing styles [8].
Paragraph fits companies that want the blog, newsletter, and list together. Your site, articles, and subscribe form live at your paragraph.com address [4], and your subscriber list belongs to you [2]. Custom site builds include working subscribe forms on the page instead of redirecting elsewhere [6].
What should happen after someone signs up?
Send a welcome email right away, then meet your basic legal duties. The first email sets expectations while the reader still remembers why they joined.
A good welcome email is short. It should:
-
Thank them and confirm the signup. One line is enough.
-
Restate what they'll get and how often. Match what the form promised.
-
Point to your best work. Link two or three posts a new reader should start with.
-
Deliver anything you offered. If the form promised a template or guide, include it here.
-
Invite a reply. Asking what they want to read starts a conversation early.
Most email tools can send this automatically. On Paragraph, a new subscriber email sends when a reader subscribes, and new emails are created disabled so you can review them before anything goes out [5]. You can also filter subscribers by source to see who signed up through your site or a post [3]. More on that in the subscribers docs.
Whatever tool you use, cover the basics:
-
Honor unsubscribes fast. The CAN-SPAM Act requires you to act on opt-out requests within 10 business days [14].
-
Include a postal address. Your messages must include a valid physical postal address [14].
-
Support one-click unsubscribe at scale. Gmail requires it if you send more than 5,000 messages a day [13].
Start with a form on every page
If you want signup prompts on every post without pasting code, create a free Paragraph site. Already have a website? Grab the embed code or /subscribe link, then set up your welcome email. The pricing page shows what's included free.