Start typing to search this publication.
Civics Unhinged logo Civics Unhinged
Open menu
Civics Unhinged logo

Subscribe to Civics Unhinged

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Mr. Justice Alito Discovers Congress

F.P. Dunneagin avatar F.P. Dunneagin
3 min read

There are few experiences more unsettling for a constitutional originalist than discovering something in the Constitution that has been there all along.

Justice Samuel Alito appears to have had just such an experience recently.

Speaking at a gathering of the Federalist Society, the justice warned that Congress possesses the power to make life exceedingly uncomfortable for the Supreme Court. It could, he explained, withhold funding, interrupt the Court's operations, and quite literally turn off the lights.

This was a remarkable discovery, particularly for a gentleman who has spent two decades interpreting the document in question.

One imagines the scene.

Justice Alito, having retired to his chambers with a well-thumbed copy of the Constitution, encounters Article I. There, to his considerable astonishment, he discovers an institution called Congress.

He summons a clerk.

"How long has this been here?"

"Since 1789, sir."

"And nobody thought to tell us?"

"The Founders did, sir. They put it first."

This would have been troubling enough. But further examination reveals that Congress possesses additional powers, including the authority to appropriate money, conduct oversight, and establish much of the machinery through which the federal government operates.

The implications are staggering.

For years, Americans have been instructed that the separation of powers is essential to constitutional government. The president must not usurp Congress. Congress must not interfere with the judiciary. The judiciary must preserve its independence.

All perfectly sound principles, provided everyone remembers that the arrangement involves three branches rather than one branch supervising two others.

Justice Alito, however, has had an interesting relationship with congressional authority.

In 2023, when lawmakers considered imposing enforceable ethical standards upon the Supreme Court, he declared that Congress lacked constitutional authority to regulate the Court. His formulation was admirably economical: "No provision in the Constitution gives them the authority to regulate the Supreme Court — period."

The period was particularly impressive. It suggested that the matter had been settled, the Constitution had spoken, and Congress might return to its other responsibilities, preferably somewhere out of sight.

Now the justice reminds us that Congress possesses formidable powers after all.

To be fair, the power to regulate judicial ethics and the power to appropriate funds are different constitutional questions. An originalist is entitled to distinguish them.

But the distinction does not entirely rescue the spectacle of a justice who once spoke as though Congress had wandered into judicial affairs without an invitation, now warning that the same institution might become altogether too powerful.

Nor is judicial independence a trivial concern. A Congress that attempted to punish judges for unwelcome decisions by starving the courts of resources would threaten the constitutional order.

The difficulty arises when concern for institutional independence appears to depend upon which institution is being restrained.

The Supreme Court has shown considerable solicitude toward presidential authority. In its 2024 immunity decision, the majority established sweeping protections for presidential official acts, reasoning in part that presidents must be free to perform their constitutional duties without debilitating interference.

Apparently, interference is a matter requiring careful constitutional analysis when it threatens the presidency, and immediate alarm when someone mentions the Supreme Court's electricity bill.

Perhaps the justice's discovery will encourage a broader appreciation of the Founders' handiwork.

Congress is not merely an inconvenient gathering of elected officials who occasionally interrupt the executive's plans or inquire into the judiciary's affairs. It is an independent constitutional institution, endowed with powers of its own and accountable, unlike the justices, to the voters.

Its authority does not disappear because a president finds legislation tiresome. Nor does its responsibility for oversight evaporate because a justice considers the subject disagreeable.

The Founders did not design a government in which each branch could invoke separation of powers whenever another branch became troublesome, then forget the principle when exercising its own authority.

They designed a system in which the branches would sometimes be troublesome to one another.

That was the point.

Justice Alito is correct that Congress could do considerable damage to the judiciary if it abused its constitutional powers. The same observation applies to presidents, courts, and every institution entrusted with public authority.

Checks and balances are not an emergency provision to be activated when one's preferred branch loses its advantage.

They are the operating instructions.

One hopes Justice Alito will continue his constitutional investigations. Should he proceed beyond Article I, he may discover that the document contains several additional provisions limiting governmental power.

And should he find the lights extinguished before completing his studies, perhaps Congress will appropriate funds for a candle.

It would, after all, be an original source of illumination.

— Dunneagin

Subscribe to Civics Unhinged

A chronicle of American absurdity, written with a straight face and a sharp pen. Civics Unhinged — satire for those who still give a damn.