Start typing to search this publication.
Civics Unhinged logo Civics Unhinged
Open menu
Civics Unhinged logo

Subscribe to Civics Unhinged

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Three Men and the World Between Them

History’s Verdict — A meditation on a photograph

F.P. Dunneagin avatar F.P. Dunneagin
4 min read

There they stand, three men who command sufficient military power to extinguish civilization, exchanging the courtesies of gentlemen who have met to discuss the disposition of a particularly valuable estate.

Donald Trump extends his hand to Vladimir Putin. Putin accepts it. Xi Jinping looks on.

The setting is Shenzhen, China, November 18, 2026. The occasion is the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. The photograph records a diplomatic greeting before a banquet. It does not record what any of the three men is thinking, what they have promised, or what they intend to do tomorrow.

But it records something else: a moment in which the world's most consequential rivalries have been reduced to the comfortable dimensions of three men standing together for the cameras.

Trump, one suspects, is delighted.

He has long displayed an appetite for historical immortality, preferably achieved during his own lifetime and acknowledged by everyone within earshot. History, unfortunately, has the inconvenient habit of withholding its verdict until the principal actors are no longer available to dispute it.

Trump has attempted to overcome this difficulty by supplying the verdict himself.

Here he stands alongside the presidents of Russia and China, a tableau calculated to suggest that the affairs of humanity are being conducted by the gentlemen presently assembled.

For a president who prizes spectacle, the photograph may be its own reward.

Putin has reason to appreciate it for altogether different purposes.

Four years after launching Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, he is photographed exchanging pleasantries with the American president at an international gathering hosted by China.

The handshake does not erase the invasion, absolve its author, or settle a single territorial dispute. But it demonstrates that Putin's aggression has not prevented him from enjoying the ceremonial recognition ordinarily accorded to respectable statesmen.

That is no small diplomatic benefit.

And Xi?

He is the host.

The distinction matters.

Xi has brought the two presidents together on Chinese soil, beneath the auspices of an international gathering, in circumstances that permit Beijing to present itself as an indispensable center of world diplomacy.

The photograph may flatter Trump and rehabilitate Putin, but it also advertises China's importance.

Indeed, of the three, Xi may have the least need to explain why he is there.

What makes the picture troubling is not the handshake itself. Presidents must sometimes shake hands with men whose conduct they condemn. Diplomacy would be impossible otherwise.

The question is what the handshake signifies within the larger history of these relationships.

American intelligence established that Russia interfered in the 2016 presidential election to benefit Trump. At Helsinki in 2018, Trump publicly treated Putin's denial of that interference with a deference that astonished many Americans. He has repeatedly entertained the restoration of Russia's standing among the world's leading powers.

Now, in Shenzhen, the two presidents are again exchanging public courtesies.

The chronology does not establish that Trump is repaying Putin for political assistance. Nor does it establish blackmail, secret obligations, or an undisclosed bargain.

But it does invite a question that has survived nearly a decade of American political controversy: Why has Donald Trump so often appeared more concerned with preserving his relationship with Vladimir Putin than with holding him publicly accountable?

Perhaps Trump believes personal diplomacy can accomplish what institutional diplomacy cannot. Perhaps he sees advantage in maintaining access to a powerful adversary. Perhaps his own political interests and Putin's ambitions have simply converged.

Each explanation deserves examination.

What cannot be dismissed is the constitutional distinction between the interests of an American president and the interests of the American republic.

The presidency is not personal property. Its diplomatic authority is not a private account from which favors may be withdrawn, exchanged, or repaid.

And the world's nations are not assets awaiting distribution among whichever powerful men happen to occupy the banquet hall.

History has seen such gatherings before.

At Yalta in 1945, Roosevelt, Churchill, and Stalin discussed the future of a world devastated by war. Their decisions—and the arrangements that followed—became enduring symbols of the privileges and dangers of great-power diplomacy.

Shenzhen is not Yalta. No comparable settlement has emerged from this photograph, and it would be irresponsible to suggest otherwise.

Yet the image recalls a persistent temptation among powerful states: the belief that the importance of their interests entitles them to determine the interests of others.

Ukraine is not represented in this photograph. Neither is Taiwan. Nor are the European allies whose security depends upon decisions made in Washington, Moscow, and Beijing.

Their absence from the frame does not establish their exclusion from the negotiations. But it reminds us how easily the ceremonial theater of great-power diplomacy can obscure the people whose futures are at stake.

And therein lies the danger.

Trump may see a photograph destined for the history books. Putin may see evidence that Russia has escaped diplomatic isolation. Xi may see confirmation that China has become the stage upon which the world's most consequential diplomatic encounters occur.

All three may leave believing they have accomplished something important.

Perhaps they have.

But history will not judge them solely by the prominence of their positions in a photograph.

It will judge what they did with the power entrusted to them, what they demanded of others, what they surrendered, and whose interests they considered expendable.

The camera has captured three men standing together.

The question for history is whether they understood that the world standing beyond the frame belonged to anyone else.

And perhaps, when the photograph is eventually consigned to the archives, a future historian will offer the simplest caption of all: Three men assembled to discuss the future of the world. The world was not consulted.

— Dunneagin

Subscribe to Civics Unhinged

A chronicle of American absurdity, written with a straight face and a sharp pen. Civics Unhinged — satire for those who still give a damn.