Start typing to search this publication.
Civics Unhinged logo Civics Unhinged
Open menu
Civics Unhinged logo

Subscribe to Civics Unhinged

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

The $750 Million Change of Heart

F.P. Dunneagin avatar F.P. Dunneagin
2 min read
Cover image for The $750 Million Change of Heart

Mr. Elon Musk has announced that he is not MAGA, a discovery apparently made after spending more than three-quarters of a billion dollars helping Donald Trump and his Republican associates win elections.

One wonders what Mr. Musk might have discovered had the Republicans won in November.

Would he have expressed regret over his extraordinary expenditures? Would he have explained that both political parties possess virtues and shortcomings? Would he have assured the public that he had never really belonged to the movement whose electoral fortunes he had so generously underwritten?

Or would he have celebrated another magnificent victory for American civilization, made possible in no small measure by his own generosity?

These are questions worth asking because Mr. Musk's political identity appears to have undergone a remarkable transformation.

In 2024, he declared himself not merely MAGA but "dark, gothic MAGA," a distinction whose precise ideological significance remains obscure. By November 2026, however, he was explaining that he wasn't MAGA at all. He also confessed to feeling rather foolish about the vast sums he had spent supporting Republican candidates.

The timing is unfortunate.

Had Mr. Musk experienced his change of heart before the election, one might have attributed it to reflection, reconsideration, or even the belated discovery of a political principle. Coming after the voters delivered their verdict, it invites a less flattering interpretation.

Mr. Musk may have mistaken political contributions for investments carrying an implied guarantee of satisfactory returns.

Of course, a man is entitled to change his political convictions. He may even change them without first consulting his accountant. But when those convictions have been expressed through expenditures exceeding $750 million, the public might reasonably expect some explanation beyond the discovery that the enterprise was not quite what he had imagined.

President Trump, meanwhile, has responded with a reminder that those who abandon MAGA do not generally fare well. Apparently, political independence is another privilege that must be negotiated with the proprietor.

Mr. Musk may genuinely regret having supported the movement. He may regret only that the movement lost. Conceivably, he regrets both.

But one question remains unanswered.

If Republicans had won in November, would Mr. Musk still be dark, gothic MAGA—or would he have demanded his money back?

— Dunneagin

Subscribe to Civics Unhinged

A chronicle of American absurdity, written with a straight face and a sharp pen. Civics Unhinged — satire for those who still give a damn.