Start typing to search this publication.
Brandon Donnelly logo Brandon Donnelly
Open menu
Brandon Donnelly logo

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Brandon Donnelly — Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly. — Page 159

Cover image for Garbage trucks take up too much space

Garbage trucks take up too much space

  • Toronto
  • Garbage
  • Type-g

Here in Toronto, we have something known as "Type G" loading spaces. They're used for collecting garbage and they are generally required in multi-family buildings with 30 or more homes (though exceptions do exist). The problem with these spaces is that they're highly consumptive. Below is an excerpt from a recent article in Azure by Kelly Alvarez Doran and Mitchell May:

In order to accommodate a truck’s large arms to swing a garbage bin up and over its frame, residential buildings require what’s known as a “Type G” loading space, which measures at least 13 metres long, four metres wide and 6.1 metres tall. While the area of the loading space alone is significant, the required turnaround space — allowing trucks to navigate in and out of the building — is often double or even triple its size. Current City of Toronto regulations require this loading space to be designed in order to allow a garbage truck to enter the site, collect the waste, and exit the site without the need to reverse onto a public road — resulting in T- or L-shaped paved areas to accommodate the turns of a wide wheel base. Due to the site constraints and density of these developments, Type G loading is often internalized within the building’s footprint. The outcome? A truck’s manoeuvring effectively consumes the ground floor at the expense of retail space and street-level activity.

They go on to analyze what would happen if you took a typical Toronto main street and then intensified it with buildings requiring Type-G loading. The result, for a particular stretch of Dundas Street between Dufferin and Brock, was that you'd end up losing somewhere around 44 storefronts just to accommodate all of this loading.

Here's their diagram showing the Type-G loading areas in blue:

New developments are often criticized for how they perform at the ground floor. But a big part of this has to do with all of the back-of-house services and other requirements that they need to accommodate. Type-G loading is a big one and it's simply not feasible on smaller projects. Projects between 31-60 homes can apply for an exception, but I think this flexibility should already be built in.

Beyond increasing the unit trigger, what else could we do? Well, the obvious ones are (1) make the trucks smaller and more nimble and (2) centralize garbage collection. Our approach to garbage collection is decentralized. It is collected from every house and every building. But there is the option to cluster the pickups, which is what many European cities do.

Here's Barcelona via Google Street View. Note the bins.

Admittedly, this isn't nearly as convenient as having a truck come right to your door or building, and it's not the most attractive way to decorate a street. So I'm inclined to start with option one. And for that, there are cities like Tokyo we can look to. Tokyo is famous for its strict garbage collection rules and for its smaller, cuter trucks. Here's a comparison to North American trucks via ChatGPT (meaning, I can't be held liable for any inaccuracies in this chart):

We aren't quite Tokyo. Few cities are. But surely there are ways we can be just as functional and take up a lot less space. This would not only benefit our main streets, but also improve the overall viability of infill housing.

Cover photo by Mak on Unsplash

No development charges and parkland dedication on sixplexes — hopefully

  • Toronto
  • Sixplex
  • Infill-housing

As you know, sixplexes are now permitted in certain parts of Toronto. We've spoken before about how it should be all of Toronto; but nevertheless, they are allowed in areas where they were not allowed before. That constitutes progress.

But it gets much better: This week, Mayor Chow announced that she will be bringing forward a motion to Council to eliminate development charges and parkland dedication cash-in-lieu requirements for new developments of up to six residential homes. This is a big deal and something that is necessary if we want to spur more rental housing.

To quote my friend Craig Race (of Craig Race Architecture), "this is the first thing [Olivia Chow has] done I'm happy about, and I hope to see more." Mayor Chow was criticized for standing around while sixplexes were being debated, and so this is perhaps her now trying to step up. Whatever it is, home builders will take it.

Globizen wasn't looking at this scale before, but I'm now going to adapt one of our screening models to see if the math works. If it does, then expect the industry to mobilize around it.

Cover image for Toronto's "traffic czar" is doomed to fail

Toronto's "traffic czar" is doomed to fail

  • Toronto
  • Chief-congestion-officer
  • Trafifc-czar

Okay, so the official title is Chief Congestion Officer.

But whatever. What's important is that the City of Toronto is apparently close to hiring a human that will become the so-called "congestion lead". This will be, in their words, a senior strategic cross-divisional leadership role that reviews programs and projects, and then works to minimize traffic congestion (this is among other things).

Translation: Construction is causing too much congestion so let's make sure we're better at managing what happens on Toronto's streets. Fine. Nobody is going to argue against being too coordinated. But there are at least two problems with the overall framing of this position.

Firstly, it is likely that this czar will go after things like construction lane closures. Maybe the city will make them harder to get and/or maybe they'll increase the occupancy fees they charge. (Reminder: Developers pay cities lots of money to occupy public streets.)

Regardless of what is done, it's important to keep in mind that there's a trade-off here. Any time you make construction more difficult, you add costs. And when construction costs are added, they have to go somewhere. Typically that means they get passed on to buyers and renters. So depending on how hard this czar goes after road closures, we could be indirectly increasing the cost of new housing.

Pick your poison.

But the even bigger problem with this new role is this: It presupposes that if only we did X, Y, and Z, we could solve traffic congestion. This is a fallacy. It's not going to happen. Of course, I'm not saying that better coordination wouldn't improve traffic flows; I'm saying that we're ignoring the root problem.

The Greater Toronto Area has a population of nearly 7 million people, and there’s simply no conceivable way we could all drive around everywhere and still have free-flowing traffic. It’s impossible — no matter how well we coordinate roadwork or how many people with whistles we plant at major intersections during rush hour.

The only way to solve this problem is to embrace a multi-modal approach to urban mobility. And so rather than a "traffic czar" narrowly focused on car congestion, what we really need is a "mobility czar" focused more broadly on moving the most number of people as efficiently as possible — across all modes of transport.

This is not the solution that many people want to hear — because it will mean a break from the status quo — but we already know that it works. Really well in fact.

Cover photo by Cyan Chen on Unsplash

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly.