Start typing to search this publication.
Brandon Donnelly logo Brandon Donnelly
Open menu
Brandon Donnelly logo

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Brandon Donnelly — Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly. — Page 27

Cynics sound smart but optimists build the future

  • Business
  • Tech
  • Business

There’s an old saying that “cynics sound smart, but optimists move the world.” And indeed, studies show that we typically perceive pessimism as a sign of intelligence. On some levels, this makes sense because it requires intellect to understand something, and then expose its vulnerabilities.

But at the same time, pure cynicism can be inherently passive. It’s an easy armour to wear, one that protects the user from (1) taking risk, (2) being proven wrong, and (3) doing the hard work to determine whether something might actually work. Importantly, cynicism generally creates zero new value. It may protect you from a bad decision, but it also blocks you from the really great ones. Value creation demands action.

Now, blind optimism is not the answer. Risk management is essential. In fact, some of my real estate developer colleagues describe the business purely in these terms: “I manage risk for a living.”

The right answer is a kind of rational optimism. Because the greatest value creation comes when you believe something is true or possible, even if it has never been done before. If someone has already proven the thesis, it doesn’t require the same degree of optimism; it only requires research.

If you’re looking for evidence of this in practice, consider that the most entrepreneurial cities in the world have robust capital markets that are inherently tolerant of risk. Venture capital, for example, is rational optimism scaled across an asset class. It operates on a power-law distribution. The assumption is that most investments will be a failure, but a select few will more than make up for it.

This is an important feature because it rewards bold ideas that can change the world. But for all of this to work, you need a healthy dose of institutional optimism. Without it, these bets go unmade and the future gets created by someone else. Let’s not ignore this key ingredient as we build our cities.

Cover image for A 6-storey boutique hotel proposed for Kensington Market - Brandon Donnelly

A 6-storey boutique hotel proposed for Kensington Market - Brandon Donnelly

Fun fact: The bike I used throughout most of undergrad at the University of Toronto was a jaunty-looking red thing that I purchased from Bikes on Wheels in

Fun fact: The bike I used throughout most of undergrad at the University of Toronto was a jaunty-looking red thing that I purchased from Bikes on Wheels in Kensington Market. I used it every day. It was a workhorse.

And when I eventually moved to Philadelphia for grad school, I took it with me. Let me tell you, I probably stood out like a sore thumb riding that thing through the depths of West Philly. But then it got a flat tire and it sat in the corner of my apartment for the rest of the school year. I couldn’t tell you what happened to it after that.

This is a mostly irrelevant story except that a development application was recently filed for a site in Kensington that includes the former home of Bikes on Wheels. It’s a new six-storey boutique hotel designed by Joel Gerber Architect. The design looks great, and I like the yellow pitched-roof top hat that comes with it. It will look fun on the Kensington skyline.

But even more importantly, this is exactly the kind of infill development that Toronto needs, all over. We should be doing everything we can to reduce the barriers to building at this scale. It’s not easy, which is one of the reasons why we are not seeing a flurry of 6-storey buildings all along our avenues, even though they are technically now permissible.

So, whoever the team is behind this project, I wish them a speedy and straightforward approval.


Project rendering via blogTO

Cover image for How AI is transforming architectural workflows - Brandon Donnelly

How AI is transforming architectural workflows - Brandon Donnelly

I recently came across an online post criticizing a Canadian Tire ad that was very clearly created by AI. The text was illegible (most AI models aren't

I recently came across an online post criticizing a Canadian Tire ad that was very clearly created by AI. The text was illegible (most AI models aren’t excellent at text). The model’s face was plasticky. And everyone was piling on, saying things along the lines of: “Shame on Canadian Tire. They should have hired a Canadian model, photographer, and graphic designer.”

While I can appreciate where this is all coming from, the reality is that the cat is out of the bag. As I’ve said before: What is real anymore? It doesn’t matter. We all have to adapt. I have, for example, noticed a dramatic change in the architectural workflow on our projects. We are now seeing an infinite number of visualizations throughout the design process, and that is making it a lot easier to iterate and refine ideas. So much for the quick blue foam models.

On some projects, where we have a collaborative working relationship with the design team, we now send AI renderings back and forth in group chats: “I’ve changed the material on these soffits and modified the brick coursing. What do you think?” None of it is perfect. But neither were the physical models and other tools that we used to rely on to test ideas.

If anything, it’s overwhelming in the best possible way. The creative possibilities are endless.

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly.