
Permissionless Hierarchy : A new way to look at DAOs.
DAOs are the biggest misnomer of web3. They don’t work, and no one seems to know how to make it work. Here, I present a view to challenge the way we look at DAOs to begin with. The take-away for me from 2 days of DAO discussions in Amsterdam is nobody has figured out how to manage the chaos to get anything useful done in a DAO. DAOs are today just a glorified Discord channel with no clear route to be either Decentralized (what does that even mean?) or Autonomous. “DAO” is a marketing gimmick....
Request to build - Decentralized NFT based lending protocol
A completely decentralized protocol that lets people borrow money from the treasury by producing an NFT. This is to be built on top of LooksRare, because LooksRare is decentralized and hence infinitely composable.Borrow at floor priceProduce an NFT from an NFT collection on LooksRare. The maximum amount you can borrow against the NFT is the minimum floor price of that collection over the last 30 days. You can only deposit verified collections’ NFTs - for securing the protocol. Open to any oth...
Request to build - A decentralized Audit Marketplace mechanism design
Auditing wait times on top audit firms are 9-12 months and expensive. We need something that is more participative and allows for new and yet-unproven security auditors. Here I propose a decentralized audit marketplace that turns the auditing process into a prediction marketplace.1. Select a juryA jury is usually reputed security engineers. This jury doesn’t do the audit itself, but only signs off a reported vulnerability as a real bug. There are 5 jury members selected for every audit. They ...
Founder [Questbook (YCw21)](https://questbook.xyz) Writing about things that need to be built in web3

Permissionless Hierarchy : A new way to look at DAOs.
DAOs are the biggest misnomer of web3. They don’t work, and no one seems to know how to make it work. Here, I present a view to challenge the way we look at DAOs to begin with. The take-away for me from 2 days of DAO discussions in Amsterdam is nobody has figured out how to manage the chaos to get anything useful done in a DAO. DAOs are today just a glorified Discord channel with no clear route to be either Decentralized (what does that even mean?) or Autonomous. “DAO” is a marketing gimmick....
Request to build - Decentralized NFT based lending protocol
A completely decentralized protocol that lets people borrow money from the treasury by producing an NFT. This is to be built on top of LooksRare, because LooksRare is decentralized and hence infinitely composable.Borrow at floor priceProduce an NFT from an NFT collection on LooksRare. The maximum amount you can borrow against the NFT is the minimum floor price of that collection over the last 30 days. You can only deposit verified collections’ NFTs - for securing the protocol. Open to any oth...
Request to build - A decentralized Audit Marketplace mechanism design
Auditing wait times on top audit firms are 9-12 months and expensive. We need something that is more participative and allows for new and yet-unproven security auditors. Here I propose a decentralized audit marketplace that turns the auditing process into a prediction marketplace.1. Select a juryA jury is usually reputed security engineers. This jury doesn’t do the audit itself, but only signs off a reported vulnerability as a real bug. There are 5 jury members selected for every audit. They ...
Share Dialog
Share Dialog
Founder [Questbook (YCw21)](https://questbook.xyz) Writing about things that need to be built in web3

Subscribe to Madhavan Malolan

Subscribe to Madhavan Malolan
2021 was about NFTs, here’s what we got wrong and why I think the real potential of NFTs hasn’t been exposed yet.
NFTs that we saw in 2021 was all about signaling. You could flaunt your wealth in the offline world by driving a low clearance sports car on a bumpy road. But how do you flaunt wealth in the digital world?
Consider this profile :

There’s a famous NFT collection called CryptoPunks. There are exactly 10,000 crypto punk NFTs in the world. One of them numbered 6529 is owned by this user. All that we know about this twitter profile is that the person running it owns the crypto punk 6529. The profile picture is a visual representation of that NFT. The user has proven cryptographically and undeniably that he/she is the owner of this NFT. We don’t know the name of the person, where they’re from or any real world identity. This is a digital native identity - exists only in the digital realm.
The thing to note over here is that this profile was created in May 2021. But by end of 2021 had 200K+ followers. Why did that happen when we don’t know this person? We don’t know the person, but we know 2 things about the person behind this profile.
That they are crypto native. They bought the punk for about $400K. Many punks now are trading at north of $10M. So this person was a believer in the concept of crypto.
That they are crypto wealthy. This person has to be wealthy to “throw away” $400K. They likely made their wealth in crypto to be able to make such a large transaction in crypto.
So, what I’m getting to is even without saying it, the user has said many things about themself just by being the owner of an NFT.
I think that is the future. NFT not as collectibles. NFT not as trading objects. But, NFT as identities.
Unwarranted prediction : stagnant or plummeting NFT trading volumes in 2022, but explosion in number of NFTs & NFT owners.
In the next wave of NFTs, I expect people to build digital native identites using NFTs.
I can create an identity without revealing my name just by owning some NFTs. These NFTs could include - making contributions to github, a soccer match live stream that i attended, online courses I’ve completed etc.
People don’t need to trust me using the KYC of my physical documents. All they need to do is verify the NFTs that are a part of my "identity”.
NFTs are inherently verifiable. If Stanford issues a certificate, it can be verified only if Stanford exposes an API. But, when an online course issues an NFT, it is immediately verifiable - because all the data by definition is
Open to all
Adhering to a specific format
Because of these capabilities, the identities can be verified by a computer, a program without any human intervention.
One could create a discord server to only allow people who have completed one of the top 5 courses in the field.
One could give a discount on merchandise to anyone who had attended the soccer match live stream.
Many such usecases will get unlocked because the identities are
Proofs of ownership (You can prove that you are the owner of the NFT)
Programmable (Proof can be consumed by a computer software)
NFTs are Programmable Proofs of Ownership.
More interesting things that will happen with NFT based identities :
People can now create identities without having to expose their real life identity. You can now have a different identity for your gaming, different identity for your work.
Now I as a backend engineer can create an identity with my friend who is a frontend engineer and we can pool together our NFTs to create a new shared identity. We can even create rules on how to split money when someone makes a payment to this identity.
To the world, we’d be masquerading as a single fullstack engineer.
You can now destroy identities by just burning the NFTs once the work or project is completed.
Or if the identity was created by multiple people, the identity can be dismantled and the NFTs can be returned to the respective owners back.
Famously, bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto effectively destroyed their identity after the initial years of bitcoin launch. Now they’re never to be seen publicly.
For this to happen, we need to accept NFTs as a primarily non-tradable asset. It doesn’t make sense for me to buy your “completed a course” NFT. This should be a trivial modification that will become mainstream in the near future. I’d like to call this iteration of NFTs as programmable proofs of ownership. PPOs.
Happy 2022
2021 was about NFTs, here’s what we got wrong and why I think the real potential of NFTs hasn’t been exposed yet.
NFTs that we saw in 2021 was all about signaling. You could flaunt your wealth in the offline world by driving a low clearance sports car on a bumpy road. But how do you flaunt wealth in the digital world?
Consider this profile :

There’s a famous NFT collection called CryptoPunks. There are exactly 10,000 crypto punk NFTs in the world. One of them numbered 6529 is owned by this user. All that we know about this twitter profile is that the person running it owns the crypto punk 6529. The profile picture is a visual representation of that NFT. The user has proven cryptographically and undeniably that he/she is the owner of this NFT. We don’t know the name of the person, where they’re from or any real world identity. This is a digital native identity - exists only in the digital realm.
The thing to note over here is that this profile was created in May 2021. But by end of 2021 had 200K+ followers. Why did that happen when we don’t know this person? We don’t know the person, but we know 2 things about the person behind this profile.
That they are crypto native. They bought the punk for about $400K. Many punks now are trading at north of $10M. So this person was a believer in the concept of crypto.
That they are crypto wealthy. This person has to be wealthy to “throw away” $400K. They likely made their wealth in crypto to be able to make such a large transaction in crypto.
So, what I’m getting to is even without saying it, the user has said many things about themself just by being the owner of an NFT.
I think that is the future. NFT not as collectibles. NFT not as trading objects. But, NFT as identities.
Unwarranted prediction : stagnant or plummeting NFT trading volumes in 2022, but explosion in number of NFTs & NFT owners.
In the next wave of NFTs, I expect people to build digital native identites using NFTs.
I can create an identity without revealing my name just by owning some NFTs. These NFTs could include - making contributions to github, a soccer match live stream that i attended, online courses I’ve completed etc.
People don’t need to trust me using the KYC of my physical documents. All they need to do is verify the NFTs that are a part of my "identity”.
NFTs are inherently verifiable. If Stanford issues a certificate, it can be verified only if Stanford exposes an API. But, when an online course issues an NFT, it is immediately verifiable - because all the data by definition is
Open to all
Adhering to a specific format
Because of these capabilities, the identities can be verified by a computer, a program without any human intervention.
One could create a discord server to only allow people who have completed one of the top 5 courses in the field.
One could give a discount on merchandise to anyone who had attended the soccer match live stream.
Many such usecases will get unlocked because the identities are
Proofs of ownership (You can prove that you are the owner of the NFT)
Programmable (Proof can be consumed by a computer software)
NFTs are Programmable Proofs of Ownership.
More interesting things that will happen with NFT based identities :
People can now create identities without having to expose their real life identity. You can now have a different identity for your gaming, different identity for your work.
Now I as a backend engineer can create an identity with my friend who is a frontend engineer and we can pool together our NFTs to create a new shared identity. We can even create rules on how to split money when someone makes a payment to this identity.
To the world, we’d be masquerading as a single fullstack engineer.
You can now destroy identities by just burning the NFTs once the work or project is completed.
Or if the identity was created by multiple people, the identity can be dismantled and the NFTs can be returned to the respective owners back.
Famously, bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto effectively destroyed their identity after the initial years of bitcoin launch. Now they’re never to be seen publicly.
For this to happen, we need to accept NFTs as a primarily non-tradable asset. It doesn’t make sense for me to buy your “completed a course” NFT. This should be a trivial modification that will become mainstream in the near future. I’d like to call this iteration of NFTs as programmable proofs of ownership. PPOs.
Happy 2022
<100 subscribers
<100 subscribers
No activity yet