I spent the last two days in meetings with FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler and his staff, discussing their proposed Open Internet rules (aka net neutrality). Monday’s meeting was with a group of NYC VCs, and Tuesday’s meeting was with group of NYC startup CEOs and GCs. Coming out of these meetings, and after working on this over the past several months, a few things have become increasingly clear. Specifically, what we mean when we talk about the “freedom to innovate” and why it’s important for the future of the internet (both infrastructure and applications). The question that the Chairman opened both meetings with was: how can the FCC achieve the dual goals of “access” and “flexibility”. ”Access” meaning the ability for websites, startups, apps and content providers to reach end-users (and vice versa), and “flexibility” meaning the ability for internet access providers to expand and improve their networks in new (and potentially unexpected) ways. Access: innovation without permission (on the network) Yesterday’s startup meeting led off with each company[1] talking about why the open (non-discriminatory, non-prioritized) internet mattered to them — in particular, why it mattered to them when they were just starting out. Eli Pariser from Upworthy put it perfectly, when he said: “I’m here because I’ve thought a lot about the tests you have to go through as a startup CEO. And I’m very thankful that one of the tests I *didn’t* have to pass was the Knows How To Negotiate A Complex Deal With A Large Telecommunications Conglomerate Test. I’m not sure many of us could have passed that test in the early days of our companies.” Amen. Many companies noted how long they had operated before they need to hire a biz dev person or an in-house counsel. David Karp from Tumblr noted that their GC was hire #37 (this was considered early) and they didn’t hire a biz dev person until the company was 7-1/2 years old. Chad Dickerson from Etsy noted that their first GC was hire #500. Erik Martin, GM of reddit noted that they he is their policy person (out of a staff of about 50). Every company in room was able to reach and serve millions of users and customers without having to negotiate a pay-to-play deal with a carrier first. The buzzword idea is “innovation without permission” — the ability to launch an app, try out an idea, start writing, start competing with the big boys, start gaining real users, just by hitting enter. Anyone — a 16-year-old kid with an app or a 75 year-old grandmother with a blog — can simply start. No need to hire a lawyer, negotiate a deal for access, or (in the worst case) file and litigate a complaint with the FCC. Then, as David Pakman put it in the VC meeting, “the users can king-make the apps” (as opposed to the carriers charging, and picking, winners). This is what brought us the internet we have today, and this is the world I want to live in. Flexibility: freedom to innovate (in the network) Regardless of whether we want ISPs to “innovate” in the first place, a central and critical question in the open internet debate is how to stimulate ongoing investment in our internet infrastructure. To make internet faster, cheaper, and better for everyone. This is the contentious issue. Some argue that open internet rules would remove incentives for investment in infrastructure, by limiting the ways internet access providers are allowed to charge. In the VC’s meeting on Monday, my colleague Brad said the following (as published in the forthcoming FCC ex parte filing — emphasis mine):
Mr. Burnham pointed out that the relationship between innovation in the network and innovation on the network is more nuanced than often assumed. For example, integrating the network more closely with applications by making the network application-aware may be advantageous from a business perspective, because it allows access providers to control the economics and the innovation at the application layer. Mr. Burnham recalled that when he worked at AT&T, at a time when that company introduced several application aware network architectures in an effort to compete with Internet, the network engineers there were so worried that changes in the network would break applications, that innovation in the network was very rare. At the same time, investment and innovation in and on the Internet was growing exponentially because the Internet’s layered architecture separated the applications from the network and allowed each to evolve independently. He argued that regulatory policy that continues to separate the network and applications layers by requiring ISPs to manage their networks in ways that are application agnostic will promote innovation not limit it.”
In other words, separating the applications layer from the network layer actually stimulates investment in both, by giving both the freedom to innovate. The Virtuous Cycle This brings us to a central idea:the “Virtuous Cycle” of innovation and investment:

This theory of innovation and investment — in both the applications layer and the network layer — is the core idea behind the FCC’s 2010 open internet rules. And, contrary to what many critics argue, this rationale was not overturned in the recent court case vacating the rules. Rather, the court simply ruled that the FCC could not enforce those rules without reclassifying ISPs as “telecommunications services” under Title II. From the court’s decision:
"Internet openness, it reasoned, spurs investment and development by edge providers, which leads to increased end-user demand for broadband access, which leads to increased investment in broadband network infrastructure and technologies, which in turn leads to further innovation and development by edge providers." (link) "[The FCC’s] justification for the specific rules at issue here—that they will preserve and facilitate the "virtuous circle" of innovation that has driven the explosive growth of the Internet—is reasonable and supported by substantial evidence. " (link)
So that’s where I’m at right now. I believe in the power of innovation without permission. And I believe that we need to stimulate expansive and ongoing investment in our internet infrastructure. And I think the best way to do that is to align everyone’s incentives and give everyone the freedom to innovate. —- [1] Companies attending the 7/15/14 meeting: BuzzFeed, Codecademy, Dwolla, Etsy, Foursquare, GeneralAssembly, Gilt, Kickstarter, Meetup, Reddit, Spotify, Tumblr, Upworthy, USV, VHX, Vimeo, Warby Parker
I spent the day Tuesday at the Civic Media conference, put on annually by the MIT Center for Civic Media and the Knight Foundation. In addition to being a gathering of a fabulous community of civic hackers and builders, it's also where Knight announces the winners of the NewsChallenge grant contest each year (here are this year's winners, in the category of "strengthening the internet") Closing out the conference was Joi Ito, head of the Media Lab (and also on the Knight board). I always love listening to Joi speak, and reading his writing. He is like the Yoda of open innovation. The force is strong in him. In his remarks, he lays out his 9 principles for guiding the Media Lab into the future, which really double as 9 principles for open innovation. They are:
Resilience over strength (I would actually change this to "resilience over rigidity")
Pull over push
Risk over safety
Systems over objects
Compasses over maps
Practice over theory
Disobedience over compliance
Emergence over authority
Learning over education
This video is the best example of how I try to think about the world, and how I try to work, as I can think of. It's speaks to the USV investment thesis, to the ideas behind Regulation 2.0 (in particular resilience over strength and emergence over authority), and to the impacts that the web is having on every sector of the economy. Here's his talk -- it's 27 minutes worth watching, for a pure dose of Joi's philosophy of innovation and the internet:
Yesterday, the FCC met to vote on its notice of proposed rulemaking regarding the Open Internet. As was generally expected, the commission voted, along partisan lines, to move forward with their plan for Open Internet rules — a plan that, as currently designed, would allow for fast lanes and slow lanes on the Internet. (You can see the summary fact sheet here and the full notice here). There are really two issues: 1) Should we be striving for an open internet — more specifically, should we ensure that everyone has open accessto the internet, unrestricted by internet access providers; and 2) How do we achieve that On #1, I would encourage everyone to watch Chairman Wheeler’s remarks from yesterday’s meeting (embedded below). I was struck by how dead-solid he came out with a yes to that question. He spoke emphatically of “One Internet” and of enumerated all the ways he would stand up to internet access discrimination. The issue is #2. The FCC’s current plan is big trouble. But the win, incremental as it may be, is the rather dramatic shift in tone that the Commission has taken — specifically, explicitly considering reclassifying internet access providers as “common carriers”. The pressure from internet activists, tech companies (both at the applications layer and the transit layer), and investors, has had an impact. After yesterdays FCC meeting, I joined a press call and gave the following statement:
Union Square Ventures is a venture capital firm that manages $1B in assets and invests in the applications layer of the internet — apps like Twitter, tumblr, Etsy, Foursquare, Kickstarter, SoundCloud, and many more. As investors in internet applications, we’ve seen firsthand how the level playing field for startups that has existed with the open internet has been critical to the explosion of innovation and investment over the past decade. And we also know how an environment controlled by gatekeepers with end-user monopolies can stifle investment and innovation. That’s why we joined over 100 other VCs and internet investors in communicating this to the FCC and Chairman Wheeler in a letter last week. Collectively, we manage billions of dollars in investment capital and have invested in internet applications with hundreds of millions of users. And every one of these services started as a tiny company with virtually no resources, and very little chance of succeeding, even before worrying about discrimination and blocking from Internet Access Providers. At today’s meeting, we were pleased to hear the passion with which the Chairman voiced his support for unfettered, open access to “one internet”. It’s clear from his remarks that he believes in the value of, and the need for simple, enforceable rules that protect a wide-open marketplace for internet applications. Clearly, the debate over the next six months will focus on how best to achieve that goal. There is substantial concern that the FCC will not be able to practically achieve its open internet goals under its section 706 authority, which means that looking closely at an approach under Title II of the communications act is a logical next step. So, we look forward to engaging in that discussion, with the FCC, with the startups and other investors we work with on a daily basis, with carriers and with the public that is building more and more of their lives on top of the open internet every day.
So we will see where this goes. Starting now, and through July 15, the doors are open at the FCC for lobbying and public comment. One thing you can do today is write a letter to the FCC, stating what the open internet means to you:www.dearfcc.org. The important thing is to keep up the pressure.
