There are at least two startups that I know of (Pave and Upstart) that facilitate VC-style equity investment in individuals. Upstart describes this as “the startup is you”.
In both cases, the idea is as follows: raise money from backers in exchange for a percentage of your future earnings. The idea here is that individuals, whether they are starting a company or restructuring their finances in some other way, can benefit from some amount of capital to take income pressure off of them for some period of time. That might give someone the opportunity to explore a product or company idea, or might give them the opportunity to do some other kind of life change (moving, having a child, etc.).
At USV, we were discussing this whole phenomenon a few months ago, and the general feeling in the room was that it felt a little icky to invest in individuals this way. Like indentured servitude. And that it runs the risk of striking a bad deal for those taking the cash, that they’ll resent later on.
I understand that perspective, but I think the view on this changes a lot if, rather than as an alternative to traditional equity investing / fundraising, you look at it as an alternative to debt. From that perspective, I think it starts to look a lot friendlier to the entrepreneurs / individuals.
I know from personal experience how it feels to have debt hanging over you. It’s a bad feeling (not to mention a source of chronic stress and illness), and something to be avoided if you can do it. And mismanaging debt from commercial banks is another reason why it’s expensive to be poor. But for many folks, it’s the only choice.
Personal equity, on the other hand, creates a different alignment between the investors and individuals. Everyone is bought into the individuals’ success. This is the same dynamic that makes traditional equity investing work so well.
I’m a firm believer that we are just scratching the surface when it comes using the internet to empower individuals in new ways. In finance, we’re seeing that everywhere — for individuals, in the debt (LendingClub, Prosper) and philanthropy (Kickstarter, Indiegogo) spaces, and for companies in equity (AngelList, CircleUp) and debt (Funding Circle, C2FO). Personal equity is a natural extension of that, and seems worthy of exploring.
For some reason I have always liked talking to taxi drivers about their business. Maybe it’s because my dad was a NYC taxi driver back in the 70s, or maybe it’s because driving a taxi is such a classic immigrant path to building a life here. And it’s certainly because of the amount of tech and business model innovation in the transportation space.
Last night I took an Uber home from the airport, and was talking to the driver about his experience with it. He loves Uber — in the past 2 years, he switched from being a Boston city cab driver to being an Uber driver — and in the process traded $4000 / month in cab lease fees (what you pay a garage as a base rate to drive the cab — regardless of how much you earn) for a $700 / month car payment and $400 / month in insurance. And he gets to have a vastly improved quality of work (managing his own business & time, driving in a nicer car, etc).
Of course there are tradeoffs — if the Uber business slows down, he’s still on the hook for that car payment. And it’s possible that the number of Uber drivers will continue to increase (unconstrained by medallion restrictions, which in NYC cap taxis at 13,000), increasing competition and bringing down his margins.
But overall, he said that Uber changed his life (for the better). Not everyone feels this way, but it’s one story.
Anyway, the most interesting thing he said was not about the business, but the impact on neighborhoods. He said that Uber has radically increased the taxi / car service business in the city’s tough neighborhoods. This comes across as sounding counter-intuitive since most tech-driven transportation platforms (like Uber, Lyft and Sidecar — but especially Uber) are derided as “For Yuppies By Yuppies”. But the reason makes perfect sense: with Uber, you know your passenger.
So whereas a traditional taxi would hesitate to pick up fares in tough parts of town, because you never know who’s going to get in, Uber drivers can do this with much more confidence, since there is personal identity (and therefore accountability) built into the system.
This makes perfect sense in theory, and I’d be really interested to explore data that could test this out. Especially as NYC gears up to offer mobile payments in traditional taxis.
This is a perfect example of Regulation 2.0 — using real-time / mobile accessible data to build trust and safety into a networked system. And it points out the limitations of “1.0” regulation schemes (in this case taxi licensing), that don’t have access to such data and can hence only solve for part of the problem (in this case, protecting passengers from bad drivers). And it’s a really great example of some of the unexpected benefits of allowing new, networked models to emerge.
For the past few weeks, I’ve been enjoying starting to use my new Chromecast. For those who don’t know, Chromecast is Google’s new internet-video-to-tv device — plug it in, then stream web content from any device to your TV.
The Chromecast experience has been eye opening, and it perfectly illustrates the opportunity and challenges we’re facing in terms of broadband and content policy.
First: the experience — we’ve been watching Netflix and Google Play videos over Chromecast and the experience has been great. It has been a breath of fresh air to be able to push web content from any of my devices (phone, ipad, nexus7, computer) to the TV. Especially with small kids, portable video content is super important. And nothing drives me more nuts than buying a video (say, Wreck-it-Ralph) on one platform (Verizon FIOS at home) and then buying it again on another (Google Play). So being able to collect content online and push it to the TV wherever I am has been so so so nice.
It also really helps that Chromecasts are priced at $35. That way, I can buy as many as I need, and put them wherever I want — like at my in-laws’ house, which I plan to do.
For me, this is perhaps the first experience that’s really proven the model of “over-the-top” video on TV. Even with Boxee and Roku, I never got into a steady pattern of using them. The fact that the Chromecast devices are cheap, and controlling them happens from any mobile device or computer really broadens the surface area of the experience.
So, this raises the question of competition. Of course, Chromecast is a (welcome!) direct threat to video services offered by cable providers. Already this is bearing true — I’m way less likely to buy an on-demand video from Verizon now. So it’s perfect test case to think about Net Neutrality, which has been in the news this week, as Verizon and the FCC battle it out in court.
In a nutshell, the argument for net neutrality is that ISPs (like Verizon and Comcast), which currently have near monopoly positions in broadband service, are in a position to favor their own services in the face of this competitive threat. So, for example, instituting data caps that apply to Netflix but not to video-on-demand; or by throttling web video. To avoid this, providers like Netflix and Youtube could strike a special deal with the ISPs for “fast lane” service. The net result of this would be a big blow to small innovators (“the next netflix|youtube”), who naturally wouldn’t be able to afford such fees.
The argument against net neutrality is that broadband providers have never been classified as “common carriers” (the classification that allowed similar rules to be placed on phone-based ISPs in the dial-up era), and aren’t subject to such rules. Further, net neutrality assumes a monopoly environment that doesn’t exist (with the growth of mobile internet, mesh networks, etc.). Instead, we should stay hands-off and let marketplace competition do the trick here.
Freedom is such a slippery issue. One way of looking at the argument around net neutrality is about the freedom of ISPs to manage their services as they please, vs. the freedom to watch & participate (as consumers of media) and the freedom to publish (as producers of media). Thinking about it through that lens, and taking the history of the internet thus far into account, my position is to favor creators and consumers. The best thing about the internet is that everyone can become a creator — the smallest blog can become a news powerhouse, and the smallest side project can become the world’s biggest personal video platform. This potential to start from nothing and reach millions of people is the heart of what makes the internet great and empowering.
With this issue heating up again, we’re starting to see more public discourse around it. If you haven’t seen it yet, here’s a pro-net-neutrality video, The Internet Must Go, that just launched last week:
And for some counter-arguments, here is TechFreedom’s commentary of the Verizon / FCC case.
Back to Chromecast for a sec: on top of all this, Chromecast introduces a new layer: for now at least, Chromecast appears to only work with “approved content partners” (so far, Netflix, Pandora), and Chromecast may be actively blocking some apps. So this puts Google in a new type of gatekeeper position, though a less defensible one, since anyone can connect anything to their TV. This is particularly interesting given how Google has begun to close up the Android ecosystem, but that’s a subject for another post.
