Start typing to search this publication.
TideTrade logo TideTrade
Open menu
TideTrade logo

Subscribe to TideTrade

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Tideline and Bullmania’s Money Line: what each one is for

TideTrade avatar TideTrade
4 min read
Cover image for Tideline and Bullmania’s Money Line: what each one is for

Tideline is a cryptocurrency market-scanning platform featuring the Tideline rule set. It tracks market states across a broad selection of crypto assets using completed-candle data on daily and weekly timeframes. The tool that does it is called the Tideline scanner.

The Tideline is not a secret. It is the Supertrend indicator with period 10 and multiplier 3, a trend rule from the early 2000s that sits on every charting platform. Take each daily candle’s midpoint, move three average true ranges away from it, and you have a line that stays below price in an uptrend and above it in a downtrend. When a candle closes on the other side, the direction flips. Above the line the tide is in; below it the tide is out; within half an ATR of it is slack water, where the next candle could go either way.

What Tideline adds is not a cleverer line. It is discipline around a plain one: the same rule on every asset, read only on completed candles, every flip written to a ledger nobody can edit, a hash of that ledger published daily, and a pre-registered study of what the rule actually did. If you want a line to argue with, this is the wrong product. If you want one you cannot argue with, read on.

Where Bullmania comes in

People searching for a Bullmania alternative often land on Tideline, so it is worth saying plainly how the two differ. Everything below about Bullmania comes from its own public website. Tideline has no connection with it.

Bullmania describes itself as a software company first, with education built around its tools. Its indicator is the Money Line, its scanner the Money Scanner, and around them sit courses, coaching calls, live streams and a private community. Its Inner Circle asks for a portfolio of at least $100,000 to apply. Its own site says the results and testimonials it shares are exceptional, not typical, and that it guarantees nothing. That is an honest sentence and it deserves to be quoted.

The differences that matter

The signal: The Tideline is published, versioned and hashed; anyone can recompute every flip from the public export. The Money Line is proprietary. That is not a criticism, it is a design choice, and it decides what kind of user each tool suits. If you want to know exactly why an asset flipped, down to the candle and the formula, you need a published rule. If you are happy to trust a tool as part of a method you are being taught, you do not.

The record: Tideline keeps every flip on a public ledger, labelled replayed, live, late or corrected, and posts a daily SHA-256 of the whole thing so an edit would show. We found no equivalent public signal record on Bullmania’s site; that does not mean one does not exist, only that it is not what the site leads with.

The evidence: Tideline’s claims come from a study whose wording was fixed before the numbers existed. Its finding, in the words the study was allowed to use: in past data the rule had smaller falls; its return was similar overall and lower in recent years. The same study shows 58% of its round trips losing money and a longest losing run of 17. Bullmania’s site offers testimonials with the caveat above. Different kinds of evidence, for different kinds of buyers.

What you are buying: Tideline is a scanner and a one-page set of rules for using it. There is no course, no coaching and nothing to apply for; the free plan shows your holdings against their lines and sends a Sunday digest, and Pro, at $25 a month or $250 a year, tells you the night a flip happens. Bullmania, by its own description, is an education and community business with software at the centre. If you want to be taught a framework by a person over time, that is what it sells and what Tideline does not.

What neither one does: Neither can tell you what the market will do next. A trend rule flips often in sideways markets and loses a little each time; that is the price of being out before the large falls, and a published rule just lets you see the bill.

How to choose

Ask three questions. Can you see the rule? Can you see every past signal, including the losing ones? And was the evidence written down before the results were in? Then ask what it costs in total, including the time a course takes and any minimum you must bring.

The full comparison, with the figures and the sources, is here: https://tidetrade.app/bullmania. The scanner itself is free to look at, read on completed candles, and does not need an account.

— -

  • Tideline is decision support, not financial advice. Cryptoassets are high-risk and trend rules lose money in sideways markets; past states do not predict future prices. Bullmania is a trademark of its owner; this post describes its public website as of 19 October 2026 and implies no affiliation or endorsement.*

Subscribe to TideTrade

TideTrade helps crypto traders replace emotional decision-making with a simple, transparent, rules-based approach to trend trading. At its core is the Tideline: a proven, widely available indicators applied consistently across crypto assets to identify when a market is trending up or down. When the tide is in, the rule signals a trend-following position. When the tide is out, it signals a move to cash. No predictions, no guesswork, and no changing the rules because of market noise.