Start typing to search this publication.
Brandon Donnelly logo Brandon Donnelly
Open menu
Brandon Donnelly logo

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Brandon Donnelly — Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly. — Page 12

Is cycling an inferior economic good?

  • Mobility
  • New york
  • Paris

Across most global cities, higher household income tends to correlate directly with higher rates of car ownership, solo car commuting, and vehicle miles travelled. So, one could argue, as many do, that cycling is what economists call an inferior good, meaning that as incomes increase, demand for cycling decreases.

But this isn’t perfectly true. Data from the US — an obviously car-dominated place — has shown that bicycle demand is actually U-shaped. A 2013 community survey showed that the poorest quartile of Americans accounted for 39% of bicycle commuting, whereas the wealthiest quartile accounted for 20%. It was the people in the middle who biked the least.

In the case of the poorest quartile, it is out of necessity; for the wealthiest quartile, it is a choice, often for health, environmental, and overall efficiency reasons. Cycling saves time and money.

It could also be the case that the wealthy are able to live closer to work in more walkable communities, and so biking becomes a more tenable option. Irrespective of the reason, it casts doubt on the argument that cycling is truly an inferior good.

I actually think that the more fundamental cause is our built environment. If you design a place for cars, then of course, as people make more money, they’re going to choose the more convenient option and drive more. It’s what you’ve been optimizing for.

On the other hand, if you design for transit or cycling, then you start to break this relationship with income.

Consider that in some of the wealthiest arrondissements in Paris, private vehicle commuting is less than 10%; that in Manhattan, the majority of households do not own a car despite having incomes that far exceed the US national average; and that in Copenhagen, high-income earners in the city centre cycle at the exact same rate as low-income earners.

Wealthy people will always optimize for convenience. In a car-centric city, that means driving. But this doesn’t mean that cycling is an inferior good; it just means we’re building inferior cities.

Do children need to grow up in a detached home with a backyard?

  • Housing
  • Barcelona
  • Detached housing

This is a perennial debate in urbanist circles.

Mike Moffatt, founding director of the Missing Middle Initiative, recently wrote about it in The Globe and Mail and, not surprisingly, he cites survey results indicating that, if you ask most people in this part of the world, 90% will tell you that a two-storey single-detached house with a backyard is the most suitable for a young family.

However, a survey doesn’t actually answer the question. You need data. One challenge in parsing the data is that families who buy two-storey single-detached houses with a backyard also tend to be wealthier, more financially stable, and consistently employed. These features are broadly good for child development.

But according to Moffatt, if you strip away these variables, most of the advantages typically associated with this housing type disappear, except for one: access to green space.

Kids need space to play, and it’s good for development. But does the green space need to be a private backyard attached to the home? The article also cites a study from Scotland that determined the answer to be yes. Private green spaces where kids can play independently with minimal parental supervision are better than public parks.

Perhaps.

Scotland would fall into the “part of the world” that has a cultural bias toward single-family housing. There are many cities and places where most people live in multi-unit housing — places like continental Europe. Are the children there, you know, less developed?

There seems to be a general consensus that children need exposure to green space. Here, for example, is another study from Barcelona. But because single-family housing is so rare there, the researchers didn’t even consider that option.

Instead, they focused on urban spaces, finding that (1) green spaces proximate to schools were actually the most critical for cognitive development (versus near home and along their commute) and (2) trees and vegetation are an important filter for urban air pollution. So at this point, I’m going to reserve final judgement.

That said, the value of green spaces in general leaves city builders with an important insight: you may want to start with the green space strategy and then figure out the building type. Because there’s an argument to be made that it’s one of the most important pieces for families.

Cover image for The context behind the viral Edmonton multiplex site

The context behind the viral Edmonton multiplex site

  • Urbanism
  • Housing
  • Planning

I’ve had a few people respond to my recent post about the multiplex battle underway in Edmonton, and so I now have a bit more information. The address of the house in the photo is 10014 147 Street NW. Here’s a post-construction photo from the street courtesy of Edmonton City Councillor Michael Janz:

Here’s a street view image showing the two flanking multiplexes under construction:

Here’s how close the house is to the LRT station currently under construction at Stony Plain Road & 149 Street (this is the Valley Line West extension):

Here’s the route map:

And finally, here’s the station’s location in relation to downtown:

Customarily, this is exactly what you want to do on top of and around new transit investments. You want to build density. Transit investment and land-use policy, as I like to harp on here, are integral to one another. And if you do everything correctly, you won’t have to worry about parking minimums.

Happy Thanksgiving weekend, everyone.

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly.