Start typing to search this publication.
Brandon Donnelly logo Brandon Donnelly
Open menu
Brandon Donnelly logo

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Brandon Donnelly — Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly. — Page 11

Why Waymo’s arrival in Toronto is our chance to price the roads

  • Mobility
  • Tech
  • Toronto

Today, Waymo announced that it has started training its vehicles on the streets of Toronto, with the goal of welcoming riders in 2028. This is exciting. I wish the timeline were shorter, but whatever, I’ll take it.

“Expanding into Canada marks an important milestone in Waymo’s global journey,” said Waymo co-CEO Tekedra Mawakana. “Toronto is one of the world’s great cities — innovative, diverse, and forward-looking. We’re proud to bring the Waymo Driver to Canada’s largest city and to partner with the vibrant business, arts and cultural communities that share our commitment to safer streets and more accessible mobility.”

But I also agree with Matt Spoke of Toronto Standard that this is a perfect opportunity to start talking seriously about congestion pricing. As we all know, road pricing is generally unpopular until it’s implemented and people see the benefits. To date, this obstacle has blocked Toronto from taking serious action around traffic congestion.

Autonomous vehicles are different. I think it would be politically pretty easy to levy congestion charges strictly on autonomous vehicles. Most people aren’t going to care about “the machines.” And it would be the proactive thing to do.

Based on the safety data we have on AVs, none of us should be driving cars anymore. This means it’s only a matter of time before AVs become the majority of vehicles on the road. I will bet you that my daughter will never drive her own car (unless she becomes an old-school motorcar enthusiast).

Implement road pricing for AVs today and nobody will notice. But in 10 years, it will be viewed as positively clairvoyant.

Toronto’s bike lane pendulum

  • Mobility
  • Toronto
  • Urbanism

This week, the Province of Ontario started work on its plan to remove about 19 kilometres of bike lanes in Toronto on major streets such as Bloor Street, Yonge Street, and others. The plan is to restore motor vehicle lanes, push bike lanes to secondary streets, and “keep drivers moving.” However, work did not start without protest. Hundreds of cyclists have been protesting this week, and a handful of arrests have been made.

The thing about bike lanes in Toronto, and other places, is that they tend to follow a political pendulum. We have a history of building bike lanes, and then paying lots of money to rip them out. It’s of course wasteful, but bike lanes are divisive and they can make for good politics. Recent polls suggest that the majority of Torontonians support removing them on major streets. And I can understand why. We’re all frustrated with traffic congestion!

But here’s what I would say in response to what’s happening this week:

  • The city should be making the decision, not the province.

  • A street like Bloor serves as an important east-west artery in our cycling network. Toronto’s grid does not have a secondary street equivalent.

  • Toronto needs more major streets like Bloor. It needs a bold 21st-century masterplan.

  • It is true that some sections, such as in Etobicoke, do have lower cycling ridership, but every lane needs to be evaluated in terms of the broader network.

  • Built form dictates behaviour.

  • Successful cities must be multi-modal.

Traffic congestion is no doubt a major problem in Toronto, but we’re nipping around the edges and unwilling to make big, bold changes. The keys to solving traffic congestion are appropriate land-use policies, road pricing, and investment in non-car forms of urban mobility. Pretending otherwise is just fooling ourselves. To solve congestion, Toronto needs to reduce automobile dependency.

Market > individual performance

  • Business
  • Development
  • 8 wellesley

It seems like eons ago now, but I remember when the pandemic hit in 2020 and pre-construction condominium sales in Toronto went on pause until the market could figure out what was going on.

Then, at the beginning of 2021, 8 Wellesley by CentreCourt launched and sold phenomenally well. It was an important moment because it signalled that the market was back. Developers could launch again.

Finding the right time to launch is something that developers weigh carefully, even in the best of times. I don’t believe that anyone can accurately time markets, but you want to feel like the market is strong and sentiment is positive.

Warren Buffett once wrote that “when a management with a reputation for brilliance tackles a business with a reputation for bad economics, it is the reputation of the business that remains intact.”

What this implies is that market dynamics ultimately trump individual performance. No matter how smart, creative, and diligent you may be, there’s only so much that you can do if the market isn’t there for you.

And in today’s condo market, developers are once again waiting for the next 8 Wellesley.

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly.