Google Pixel Slate: first impressions

post image

For the past week or so, I have been experimenting with the Pixel Slate, Google's new hybrid tablet/laptop. Here is me typing this blog post right now, on the train to NYC. 

For a longer,  more technical analysis, this review from The Verge is good.

The Pixel Slate is an odd machine, and I am still trying to figure out how to use it, and then, whether I like it or not.  The heart of the oddness is that it is really equal parts laptop and tablet -- when the keyboard is attached it feels and acts like any other Chromebook.  And with the keyboard detached, it feels like an Android tablet -- actually running mobile apps from the Google Play store.  (I didn't realize this until now, but apparently this is also true for other new Chromebooks)

It is the back and forth between tablet mode and laptop mode that is odd, and requires a fair amount of cognitive overhead.  Like, for reading email should I use Gmail in Chrome or use the Gmail app?  Same goes for all other apps -- you have to make about which experience you want, when, and then adjust accordingly.  Often times this means multiple apps doing the same thing simultaneously (or more specifically, a Chrome web version and a mobile app version).

But to take a step back: what got me interested in the slate was exactly this mix of form factors:

For example, for long-form reading, I like tablet-mode, where I can get full focus on the content, and page through with my finger (like reading a newspaper on my lap).  Same goes for short-form emailing.  Basically, I like the addition of this "lean back" mode that the tablet form factor gets you.

And then, in "laptop mode", you want the experience of, well, a laptop.  High fidelity interaction with emails, docs and websites.   The slate does all of that basically fine, though the major question is the keyboard.  I am currently using the Google Pixel Slate Keyboard, which is a floppy, folio-style magnet-attached model.  The key and trackpad action are surprisingly good, but the dynamics around folding and holding the keyboard take a little getting used to -- the attachment is floppy, and the magnetized folding holder on the back takes up additional space.   Another option is the Brydge keyboard, which intends to deliver more of a "laptop feel" when using it in laptop mode -- I am curious here about both the key action and the quality of the Bluetooth connectivity.

Another nice feature of the tablet+laptop is fingerprint unlock -- this is what you'd expect from a phone or tablet, but don't normally see on a laptop.  It's a nice convenience.

So, I would say the jury is still out.  The real questions are whether "tablet mode" and the fingerprint unlock are worth the overall cognitive load of a device that's neither entirely here nor there.

A Visual Guide to the Howey Test

Disclaimer: I am  not a lawyer, and I am not your lawyer. 

I have been in an uncountable number of conversations over the past few years discussing the question of what defines a "security" in the context of cryptocurrencies, cryptonetworks, and token offerings. 

Here is my current understanding, including a number of key questions I am still working on.  I invite any and all corrections to this visual framework.  And I should note that this is a high-level framework: the nuanced details are the subject of many enforcements, settlements, and litigations and will be worked out over a long-period of time to come.

First: the what constitutes a "security" has been defined by the courts more specifically as an "investment contract", which is a transaction with the following properties:

  1. An investment of money

  2. With the expectation of profits

  3. In a so-called "common enterprise" (roughly meaning: investors and the company rise and fall together)

  4. From the efforts of a promoter or third party (some dispute over whether this means "solely" from a promoter, but clear that it entails "significant managerial efforts" of a single promoter)

This four-part test was established as part of SEC vs. Howey, a 1946 supreme court case involving the sale of tracts in an orange grove, with an associated lease-back arrangement where buyers of the land leased the land back to the Howey corporation in exchange for profits generated from cultivation of orange crops.  This so-called "Howey Test" is now the basis for determining whether such a transaction constitutes an "investment contract" and would therefore fall under securities laws (with all associated registration and disclosure requirements).

The way the test works is that, if the contract satisfies all 4 "prongs", it "passes" the Howey Test and is therefore a securities transaction. If the contract does not satisfy any one of the prongs, it fails the Howey Test and is therefore is not a securities transaction. 

The 4 prongs of the Howey Test

Ok, with all of that as background, here is how I see the Howey Test -- 4 prongs that all need to be satisfied:

post image

So, if you were to start to think about how to "knock out" prongs of the test, thereby removing a transaction from securities status, you'd start one-by-one.

1) Remove the "investment of money" and what you have looks more like a Gift (think: receiving airline miles, or ride credits on Uber, or "airdrops" of tokens in a crypto network)

post image

2) Remove the "expectation of profit" and what you have looks more like a product  (think: pre-buying a backpack or movie on Kickstarter, purchasing laundry or arcade tokens, or buying Stacks Tokens to insert records in the Blockstack blockchain):

post image

3) Remove the "common enterprise" and what you get looks more like a collectible (think unique items like stamps, baseball cards, or CryptoKitties):

post image

4) Finally, remove the "efforts of a promoter or third party" and what you get looks more like a commodity (think gold, wheat, or Bitcoin or Ethereum):

post image

All together, it looks like this:

post image

Is a "security" an asset or a transaction?

A key question throughout all of this is whether the "security" is the digital asset itself, or instead the transaction involving the digital asset.

In a key speech by the head of SEC's Corporate Finance Division, Bill Hinman, earlier this year, he addressed this question head on:

To start, we should frame the question differently and focus not on the digital asset itself, but on the circumstances surrounding the digital asset and the manner in which it is sold. To that end, a better line of inquiry is: “Can a digital asset that was originally offered in a securities offering ever be later sold in a manner that does not constitute an offering of a security?” In cases where the digital asset represents a set of rights that gives the holder a financial interest in an enterprise, the answer is likely “no.” In these cases, calling the transaction an initial coin offering, or “ICO,” or a sale of a “token,” will not take it out of the purview of the U.S. securities laws.

But what about cases where there is no longer any central enterprise being invested in or where the digital asset is sold only to be used to purchase a good or service available through the network on which it was created? I believe in these cases the answer is a qualified “yes.”

The Hinman speech clarified two things: 1) that by knocking out the "efforts of others" prong of the Howey Test (#4 above) a crypto asset transaction can be viewed through the lens of commodities vs securities and 2) that an early transaction of that asset (in this case the pre-sale of ETH) can be analyzed under Howey distinctly from a later sale, given different facts and circumstances at the time.

This last part is really important, and I still have a hard time pinning down (really smart, expensive) lawyers on the subject.  There is an idea that a "security" is a thing rather than a transaction, which does seem at odds with both Howey and the Hinman speech.    In the case of Howey, the oranges produced under the contract are not the same as the contract itself (similar to contracts for future tokens), and in the case of the Hinman speech, it's the transaction rather than the underlying token (BTC or ETH).

Finally taking all of this together, it's important to remember that 1) there are many kinds of cryptoassets, and 2) they are offered/sold/traded/transferred under different circumstances over time. I think about it like this:

post image

I hope that is helpful.  This is complicated stuff, and new territory.

Crypto fundamentals

Our good friend Chris Burniske was on Squawk Box this morning. I got up and watched it.  You can see the video here.

post image

Of course there is interest in the crypto market right now, as it is falling hard. I suspect there are many out there who are enjoying the drop, waiting for the bubble to finish popping and for this whole idea to go away.

One takeaway from watching the segment is how much of a learning curve there still is around this whole space.  If you look at the questions Chris fielded this morning, you'll see a looming gap in understanding of the fundamentals.  The questions range from "why do we even need this" to "what is the rational basis for these prices"

It's a complicated topic, with complicated mechanics, and to make matters worse, the narrative itself has shifted a bunch over time (digital cash, digital gold, decentralized computing, the new internet, etc).

Here is one way to think about it, that feels native to CNBC and the financial markets industry:

Crypto is a market-based system for providing computing services.  The "miners" and other participants are just like the participants in other commodities markets.  It really is a shift from providing computing services via a corporate/securities/centralized model to an ecosystem/commodities/decentralized model.

If you just hold that idea for a moment, then where Chris was trying to take the conversation (but didn't exactly manage to -- talk TV is tough!) is around the rational pricing of commodities.  A simple way to start is by looking at the marginal cost of production, which is one way of looking at commodities pricing.  While this does not make sense in a highly speculative bull market, it makes a lot of sense in a flat or bear market, as we seek a basis for understanding where the bottom might be.

Another challenge here is that the utility of cryptoassets like bitcoin ethereum is still being understood, so we do not yet have solid anchors for pricing.  In the case of oil, for example, we have industries upon industries using it, establishing consumer value which lets price flow back to the original production.  This is still nascent in the crypto space, but is getting clearer every day.

Thank you Chris for working to advance the dialogue.

The Slow Hunch by Nick Grossman

Written by

Investing @ USV. Student of cities and the internet.

Subscribe