Start typing to search this publication.
Brandon Donnelly logo Brandon Donnelly
Open menu
Brandon Donnelly logo

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Brandon Donnelly — Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly. — Page 16

Cover image for How efficient core design unlocks small-footprint infill housing

How efficient core design unlocks small-footprint infill housing

  • Architecture
  • Development
  • Urbanism

In today’s edition of How Does Europe Build Such Nice Social Housing?, let’s look at this 8-home project in Pantin (outside of Paris) by Atelier Fuso. (Credit to Philip Oldfield for the tweet that alerted me to the project.)

First, some stats. The project is 6 storeys (R+5 in European nomenclature), so it’s exactly the kind of housing scale that is contemplated on an as-of-right basis along Toronto’s Major Streets. It has 394 m2 of residential area and 34 m2 of ground-floor commercial. So, about 4,607 square feet of total area. Interestingly enough, this is less than the total area of most infill multiplex projects in Toronto. That tells us the site is compact.

Second, I’d like to draw your attention to Atelier Fuso’s drawings:

They combined all of the project’s elevations and plans into single drawings, which is a neat way of showing you the relationship.

Lastly, let’s look at the project’s costs. The architect’s website shows €1.6M. Whenever I see a cost figure like this, I always assume it’s just the hard costs, and it excludes softs. Whatever the case, €1.6 million to CAD = C$2,544,160. Divided by 4,607 square feet = $552 psf. That feels high for just the hard costs. Are the soft costs less or more than here? I don’t know.

But once again we are reminded that part of the reason Europe is able to build such nice mid-rise buildings is that they’re able to build on extremely compact sites. And the reason they’re able to build vertically on such compact sites is because they’re able to design building cores that look like the one shown in the above drawings.

Urban housing like this is comprised of leasable and non-leasable areas. The former generates revenue, and the latter does not. The more developers are able to optimize and reduce the non-leasable areas, such as the core, the more they can build small. That’s a positive thing for cities.


Image and plans from Atelier Fuso

Cover image for The empty icon

The empty icon

  • Fashion
  • Art
  • Urbanism

This week at Paris Fashion Week, Saint Laurent’s creative director Anthony Vaccarello presented an open-air show in front of the Eiffel Tower that is widely rumoured to be his last show at the fashion house. (Too bad.) The set was opulent cinema. Everything was gilded — in an elegant way, not the gaudy Trump way — including the clothes themselves.

The overall set was intended to pay homage to the historic ballroom of the Hôtel InterContinental, where Yves Saint Laurent himself used to famously present his collections. And suspended above the runway was an enormous gold chandelier that effectively created an “urban ceiling” for the space. Here’s the full show if this at all interests you.

But this is not a post about fashion.

One of the things that stood out to me was the obvious relationship between the glittering Eiffel Tower and the enormous gold chandelier. It’s a good example of how you don’t necessarily need walls to frame an urban space. The hanging chandelier was all that was needed to turn a public plaza into a private salon.

At the same time, I was struck by how sexy and glamorous Paris always manages to make what is effectively a piece of raw industrial architecture. The Eiffel Tower was immediately popular with the general public at the 1889 Exposition Universelle because of its awe-inspiring stature, but elites derided it for its lack of Parisian taste. So how then did it become so synonymous with French high culture?

One theory is that it’s because the tower is generally useless.

In 1964, French theorist Roland Barthes wrote an essay where he argued that the Eiffel Tower became the ultimate global symbol precisely because it means basically nothing in itself, which is why it can be so easily imbued with other symbolic meaning. The Louvre is art. The Arc de Triomphe commemorates a military victory. And Notre-Dame is religion.

The Eiffel Tower, by contrast, is empty. It’s more or less a hollow skeleton of iron. Barthes called this an “empty signifier.” In other words, it’s a blank canvas — one that has come to symbolize everything from 19th-century industrial progress to 21st-century luxury fashion. Its greatest strength may be its uselessness.

It can be hard to predict when something might resonate in the way that the Eiffel Tower has. The so-called cultural elites certainly didn’t get it at the time. But cities desperately need these urban symbols, and what they come to mean ultimately depends on the urban context and positioning we choose to create. It’s malleable.

Take, for instance, the CN Tower in Toronto. There is nothing inherent to its concrete form that prevents it from symbolizing high design or civic sophistication in the way the Eiffel Tower does. The difference is in the curation: at its base, we put an aquarium; Paris brings out gilded Saint Laurent.

Saint Laurent’s show this week was equal parts marketing for the fashion house and for the city.

Can AI democratize property tax appeals? Doesn’t look like it.

  • Tech
  • Finance
  • Dallas

Property tax appeals are a routine part of owning commercial real estate. And there are lots of people who will help you with an appeal. One common way that these consultants charge for their services is as a percentage of achieved savings. This creates a low-commitment scenario for landlords and a strong incentive for the consultant to perform and get paid. The same is true for individual households, who also engage in property tax appeals. However, research shows that some groups are far less likely to appeal:

Lower-income homeowners are substantially less likely to file an appeal. Even holding home values constant, Hispanic and Black homeowners appeal at lower rates than White homeowners, while less-educated homeowners appeal at lower rates than more-educated homeowners. These disparities are often attributed, at least in part, to differences in knowledge of the tax system, confidence in navigating the appeals process, and the ability to afford a human agent (Doerner and Ihlanfeldt, 2015).

But what if more tools and support were provided?

Here’s an interesting study. To test this, the researchers recruited a sample of 645 households in Dallas County, Texas and gave each of them a website providing personalized property tax information and instructions for how to file an appeal. However, half of the households were assigned to a “treatment” version of the website that included a Claude-powered AI chatbot, which was there ready to answer tax-related questions and provide personalized guidance.

What they generally found was that homeowners liked the chatbot. 78% of those who had access to it initiated a conversation. The researchers also found that using the chatbot meaningfully increased the probability of filing a property tax appeal. The baseline increased from 41.4% to 50.5% (a 22% increase!). Importantly though, the increase in appeal filing was smaller among less-educated homeowners, those with lower-valued properties, and those from racial or ethnic minority groups. Overall chatbot take-up wasn’t all that different, but the translation into action was.

This is interesting because it provides “suggestive evidence” that simply providing access to AI isn’t enough. In fact, it had the opposite effect in this study. Rather than reduce inequity, it exacerbated it by increasing filing rates among the already more advantaged.

Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly

Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly.