If you’re a cyclist in Toronto, you probably know that Shaw Street is a damn good street for biking. The city first redesigned the one-way street in 2013, adding a bike lane in each direction (one of which is a contra-flow bike lane). Then in 2020, they made it so that the one-way direction for cars alternated every few blocks. This stopped drivers from using it as a high-speed shortcut. The result was an immediate increase in cycling.
Here’s some data from Observing the City for the intersection of Bloor and Shaw:
As of June 2025, the modal split at this intersection during peak hours was 34% bikes, 21% pedestrians, 1% trucks, and 44% cars. At times, there has been a 310% increase in cycling trips since the redesign. It goes to show you that the right street design (or the wrong one) will induce demand. If you look at the intersection counts for the entire city, you’ll see just how profoundly built form impacts behaviour. Cycling is broadly an Old Toronto thing.
A blog reader sent me this article by Adam Clermont arguing that “Hong Kong was a 15-minute city before the rest of the world knew what to call it.” It’s great. He was right. I did find it interesting, so much so that I subscribed without really looking at what I was subscribing to.
Here’s an excerpt:
There are things Hong Kong does not do well. The apartments are small. Mine is small. I have made peace with this in the way that a man makes peace with anything, which is to say, incompletely and with occasional resentment. The rents are obscene. The air quality on bad days could strip paint off a Renault. Nobody is moving here for the spaciousness. But the fifteen-minute city crowd keeps talking about access, about proximity, about the ability to live a full urban life without depending on a car. And on that score, Hong Kong is not a case study. Hong Kong is the answer key that the rest of the world keeps trying to peek at while pretending they came up with it themselves.
His overarching argument compares Hong Kong to Paris. While Paris was busy talking and planning to be a 15-minute city — by redesigning its streets and removing space for cars — Hong Kong was already busy doing it, by accident and out of necessity.
While it is certainly true that Paris has undergone a deliberately planned urban transformation over the last decade or two, it’s worth pointing out that we’re talking about two of the most dense cities in the developed world.
Hong Kong is, of course, on another level of hyper density, but Paris, as we like to talk about on this blog, is also sneakily dense, despite its mid-rise heights.
The fact that both cities might be described as so-called 15-minute cities places them in a rarified universe, regardless of how deliberately or accidentally they may have ultimately gotten there. Not all cities have the benefit of density, and Paris already had lots of 15-minuteness before it became a buzzword and it started planning for it.
Adam has a line that “density is not a problem to be solved but a feature to be exploited,” and I would agree with this. However, the broader problem to be solved is how do you create this feature in the first place, if you don’t already have it?
Modern cities are typically not as dense. It is almost universally true that high urban densities are the result of necessity — physical constraints and/or economic gravity. Hong Kong is an island with no place to go but up. The same is true of Manhattan.
Paris is not an island, but it hemmed itself into practical equivalents over the centuries through fortified walls. Even today, the boundary of Paris proper is the Boulevard Périphérique, which sits where the city’s last defensive walls were built in the 19th century.
Dhaka, to throw out another example, is hemmed in by major waterways that flood every year like clockwork. Naturally, the city focused development on higher, safer ground, though there are informal settlements that have found ingenious ways to navigate its precarious waters.
Density may be a feature to be exploited, but it tends to happen best when there’s no other choice. That’s why Hong Kong is so good at it. The real problem to be solved is getting there when it’s not the only option.
San Francisco’s Q2 2026 economic report is perhaps an idealized summary of how the post-pandemic, AI investment boom is transforming our cities.
Housing Supply Crisis:Residential apartment rents grew 14% from March to July, and single-family house prices are now growing at double-digit annual rates. And yet, the city continues to see a structural decline in housing permits, below pre-pandemic levels.
Segmented Commercial Market: The city’s office vacancy rate declined 3.7% over the past year, but the overall vacancy rate is still greater than 30%. Weekly office attendance also remains below 50% of pre-pandemic levels.
Urban Rebound:Average highway speeds are dropping, suggesting more user demand. MUNI Metro (local) ridership is also increasing rapidly, reaching over 70% of pre-pandemic levels. But downtown BART station exits (regional rail) are below 50% of 2019 levels, reinforcing the fact that though the city is active, but people simply aren’t commuting in nearly the same way.
Ultimately, the surge in housing prices proves that the “urban doom loop” narrative was fundamentally wrong (remember that?). San Francisco remains an intensely desirable place to live and work. But they’ve got to get moving on building more housing.
Subscribe to Brandon Donnelly
Daily insights for city builders. Published since 2013 by Toronto-based real estate developer Brandon Donnelly.